UPSC MainsGeneral Studies Paper IEthicsPractice question

Political Obligation and Thomas Hobbes

What is political obligation? Explain Hobbes' views on ensuring political obligation.

WhatHow~250 words3 min readmedium
Attempt it first, timed · optional

Write the answer on paper, as in the exam. Start the timer, keep to the word target.

00:00/ 11 min · 250 words

Done writing? Photograph the sheet and see how it scores against this model answer, with feedback on what to fix.

Upload your answer sheet

How to approach

Begin by defining political obligation and its relevance to the relationship between the state and the individual. Next, analyze Thomas Hobbes's rationale for political obligation, focusing on the state of nature, the social contract, lex naturalis, and the absolute authority of the sovereign. Conclude with a brief assessment of Hobbes's contribution to modern political theory.

Model answer

401 words

Introduction

Political obligation refers to the moral, legal, and rational duty of an individual to obey the laws and directives of the sovereign political authority. It addresses the fundamental question of why citizens ought to submit to the state and under what circumstances that obedience is warranted. In modern political thought, Thomas Hobbes provided one of the earliest secular and contractarian justifications for this obligation.

Concept of Political Obligation

Political obligation forms the foundational bond between the citizen and political institutions. It implies that authority is not based purely on coercive force, but on legitimate grounds that require voluntary compliance from citizens to maintain civic order and common welfare.

Hobbes' Views on Ensuring Political Obligation

Writing in the backdrop of the seventeenth-century English Civil War, Thomas Hobbes moved away from the divine right of kings to establish a rationalist, secular grounding for state authority centered on human preservation.

  • The State of Nature and the Social Contract: Hobbes posited that in the absence of a common power, life in the state of nature would be 'solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short,' marked by a perpetual war of all against all. To escape this constant fear of violent death, rational individuals collectively consent to surrender their natural rights to an absolute sovereign (the Leviathan), creating a binding covenant that constitutes the bedrock of political obligation.
  • Laws of Nature (Lex Naturalis): Human reason deduces fundamental precepts of self-preservation, primary among them being the command to seek peace and follow it. Obeying the established sovereign is a direct deduction of this natural reason, as breaking covenants returns humanity to anarchy.
  • Distinction between Liberty and Capacity: Hobbes defined liberty strictly as the absence of external impediments to motion, whereas capacity denotes internal power. Citizens willingly accept legal impediments (civil laws) enacted by the sovereign because these constraints guarantee the internal security needed to exercise their capacities meaningfully.
  • Absolute Authority as the Guarantee of Order: Hobbes argued that even a harsh sovereign is preferable to the lawlessness of the state of nature. Consequently, political obligation remains absolute and unconditional, bounded only by the sovereign's ongoing ability to protect the lives of the subjects.

Conclusion

Hobbes transformed political philosophy by rooting political obligation in individual self-interest and rational consent rather than theological doctrine. His framework established that individuals obligate themselves to the state primarily because an overarching, centralized authority is essential for survival, order, and social peace.

Key facts to remember

definition
Political Obligation

The moral and legal duty of citizens to obey the laws, rules, and commands of their political community or sovereign government.

definition
Lex Naturalis (Law of Nature)

A precept or general rule discovered by reason, by which a person is forbidden to do that which is destructive of his life, demanding that individuals seek peace through mutual covenants.

quote
In the state of nature, there is 'no arts; no letters; no society; and which is worst of all, continual fear, and danger of violent death; and the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.'
Thomas Hobbes on the State of Nature

Frequently asked questions

Under what condition can a citizen disobey the Hobbesian sovereign?

A citizen retains the inalienable right to self-preservation. If the sovereign directly commands an individual to take their own life or fails completely to protect their life from violent threats, the primary rationale for political obligation dissolves.