UPSC MainsGeneral Studies Paper IGeographyPractice question

Disaster Vulnerability in Kerala and Assam

Recent incidents of devastating floods and landslides in Kerala and Assam highlight the vulnerability of different geographical terrains in India to extreme weather events. Examine the climatic and anthropogenic factors responsible for these recurring disasters in such contrasting landscapes.

Examine~250 words3 min readmedium
Attempt it first, timed · optional

Write the answer on paper, as in the exam. Start the timer, keep to the word target.

00:00/ 11 min · 250 words

Done writing? Photograph the sheet and see how it scores against this model answer, with feedback on what to fix.

Upload your answer sheet

How to approach

Introduce by highlighting recent disaster events in Kerala and Assam to illustrate the vulnerability of contrasting physiographic zones. Analyze the distinct climatic and geological drivers for each region, followed by anthropogenic interventions that exacerbate the risks. Conclude with tailored disaster risk reduction measures aligned with national and international frameworks.

Model answer

487 words

Introduction

Recent disasters, such as the catastrophic July 2024 Wayanad landslides and recurrent floods across the Brahmaputra basin in Assam, underscore the heightened vulnerability of India's diverse physiographic zones to extreme weather events. While Kerala features steep orographic escarpments along the Western Ghats, Assam comprises low-lying aggradational floodplains. Despite these contrasting landscapes, both terrains face recurring crises driven by complex climatic anomalies and human-induced ecological stress.

Climatic Factors: Physical Geography Dynamics

The contrasting topographies of Kerala and Assam interact differently with atmospheric mechanisms, resulting in localized weather extremes:

  • Kerala (Steep Escarpment Terrain):
    • Sea Surface Temperature (SST) Warming: Anomalous warming of the Arabian Sea fuels intense moisture transport via narrow atmospheric rivers.
    • Orographic Lift: Moisture-laden winds undergo rapid forced ascent against the steep Western Ghats escarpment, triggering hyper-localized cloudbursts. Rainfall exceeding 570 mm within 48 hours hyper-saturates the lateritic soil mantle, completely destroying its shear strength and triggering mass wasting.
  • Assam (Low-Lying Floodplains):
    • High Sediment Budget and Riverbed Aggradation: The Brahmaputra carries one of the highest sediment loads in the world, eroded from the geologically young, fragile Himalayas. This deposition raises the riverbed over time, severely diminishing its natural water-carrying capacity.
    • Upper Catchment Hydrology: Unpredictable glacial melt coupled with heavy precipitation in the upstream catchments of Bhutan and Arunachal Pradesh causes sudden, massive surges downstream, overwhelming floodplain channels.

Anthropogenic Drivers Exacerbating Vulnerability

Human activities have systematically disrupted the ecological balance and natural drainage systems in both landscapes:

  • Kerala (Slope Destabilisation):
    • Land-Use and Vegetation Shift: The conversion of deep-rooted native Shola forests into shallow-rooted monoculture plantations (tea, cardamom, rubber) drastically reduces slope cohesion and root anchoring.
    • Unregulated Infrastructure and Quarrying: Unscientific road-cutting, slope toe-cutting, and stone quarrying destabilize fragile hillsides, exacerbated by poor implementation of the Madhav Gadgil and K. Kasturirangan Committee recommendations on Ecologically Sensitive Zones (ESZs).
  • Assam (Drainage Obstruction and Structural Failure):
    • Perils of Aging Embankments: Heavy reliance on an aging network of over 4,500 km of earthen embankments artificially confines river discharge. When hydraulic pressure builds up, catastrophic breaches occur, leading to sudden and extensive inundation.
    • Wetland Encroachment: Encroachment on wetlands (beels) and natural channels for urban expansion around hubs like Guwahati chokes natural retention basins, transforming seasonal river swells into prolonged waterlogging crises.

Way Forward: Strategic Disaster Risk Reduction

  • Nature-Based Flood Management: Adopt the 'Room for the River' approach in Assam, creating controlled overflow zones and reconnecting disconnected wetlands rather than constructing higher embankments.
  • Hazard-Informed Land Zoning: Enforce high-resolution LiDAR-based hazard susceptibility mapping across the Western Ghats to strictly prohibit construction and quarrying in high-risk landslide zones.
  • Advanced Early Warning Systems: Deploy AI-enabled hydrology models integrated with high-density X-band Doppler radars to enhance lead times for flash floods and debris flows.

Conclusion

Contrasting physiographies demand differentiated, terrain-specific disaster risk reduction strategies aligned with the Sendai Framework. Shifting the governance paradigm from reactive post-disaster relief to proactive, nature-based Integrated River Basin and Catchment Management is essential for building long-term climate resilience in both Kerala and Assam.

Key facts to remember

example
2024 Wayanad Landslide Disaster

In July 2024, extreme rainfall of over 570 mm within 48 hours triggered catastrophic debris flows in Wayanad, Kerala, leading to more than 375 fatalities and demonstrating the high vulnerability of modified Western Ghats slopes.

statistic

Over 71 embankment breaches were documented during the July 2024 monsoon floods in Assam, displacing more than 2.5 million residents.

Assam State Disaster Management Authority
scheme
Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction (2015–2030)

A global framework emphasizing a shift from disaster response to disaster risk reduction through risk governance, understanding disaster risk, and investing in resilience.

Frequently asked questions

Why do structural embankments often worsen flood disasters in Assam?

Embankments prevent natural spread and deposition of silt over floodplains, accelerating riverbed aggradation. When high peak flows cause sudden breaches under intense hydraulic pressure, floodwaters inundate surrounding areas with higher velocity and volume.