UPSC MainsGeneral Studies Paper IGeographyPractice question

Human Interventions in Fragile Geomorphic Landscapes

"Human interventions in fragile geomorphic landscapes produce unintended geographical consequences". Discuss with reference to India's hill and rocky ecosystems.

Discuss~250 words3 min readmedium
Attempt it first, timed · optional

Write the answer on paper, as in the exam. Start the timer, keep to the word target.

00:00/ 11 min · 250 words

Done writing? Photograph the sheet and see how it scores against this model answer, with feedback on what to fix.

Upload your answer sheet

How to approach

Introduce the concept of dynamic equilibrium in India's hill and rocky ecosystems and how anthropogenic pressure disrupts it. Analyze the specific geomorphic mechanisms and unintended consequences in the Himalayas, Western Ghats, and Deccan plateau with relevant case studies. Conclude with sustainable, geomorphologically informed planning frameworks and committee recommendations.

Model answer

417 words

Introduction

India's hill ecosystems, such as the Himalayas and Western Ghats, and rocky landscapes like the Deccan plateau exist in a precarious dynamic equilibrium. Unplanned anthropogenic interventions disrupt foundational geomorphic mechanisms, triggering compounding hazards that transform localized human activity into widespread environmental vulnerabilities.

Geomorphic Footprint in Fragile Landscapes

Geomorphic systems balance tectonic uplift, weathering, and gravitational stress. Disruption occurs across distinctive terrains:

  • Young Fold Himalayas: High-relief, seismically active terrains composed of unconsolidated glacial moraines and fractured strata.
  • Western Ghats Escarpments: Steep gradient slopes underlain by weathered laterite caps subjected to intense monsoonal precipitation.
  • Deccan Basaltic Traps: Ancient rigid rocky shields where human manipulation of hydraulic stress alters subsurface crustal equilibria.

Mechanisms of Unintended Geographical Consequences

  • Altered Slope Mechanics and Shear Failure: Extensive 'toe-cutting' for linear infrastructure projects, such as highway widening across the Himalayas, artificially steepens hill slopes beyond their natural angle of repose. This sharply reduces the resisting shear strength of the slope, turning stable hillsides into active zones of recurrent rockfalls and slope slips.
  • Elevated Pore-Water Pressure and Debris Avalanches: Replacing indigenous deep-rooted montane vegetation with shallow-rooted monoculture plantations weakens slope cohesion and impairs natural drainage. In the Wayanad disaster of July 2024, extreme rainfall of approximately 573 mm over 48 hours, coupled with altered subsurface hydrology, elevated pore-water pressure along planar joints, resulting in catastrophic debris flows.
  • Hydrological Disruption and Ground Subsidence: Heavy tunneling for hydroelectric projects, such as the Tapovan-Vishnugad HEP, together with unchecked urban drainage into unconsolidated glacial moraines, washes away fine sediments and creates internal voids. In Joshimath, National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) evaluations documented widespread structural damage as ancient landslide debris lost its bearing capacity.
  • Crustal Loading and Reservoir-Induced Seismicity (RIS): Impounding massive volumes of water behind mega-dams over fractured basaltic rock alters hydrostatic pore pressure and crustal stress fields, precipitating induced seismic events such as those observed around the Koyna Dam in Maharashtra.

Policy and Geomorphological Remedies

  • Carrying Capacity Assessments: Enforce ecological carrying capacity assessments before sanctioning urban expansions, drawing upon policy frameworks like NITI Aayog's hill-region planning initiatives.
  • Ecologically Sensitive Zoning: Delineate non-negotiable Ecologically Sensitive Zones (ESZs) and regulate destructive activities, aligning with recommendations of the Madhav Gadgil and Kasturirangan committees.
  • Nature-Based Bio-Engineering: Combine civil mitigation with bio-engineering techniques, including deep-rooted vetiver grass, geotextiles, and retaining benching, in line with NDMA slope stabilization guidelines.

Conclusion

Economic development in ecologically fragile terrains must operate strictly within geomorphic and hydrological boundaries. Shifting from hard, disruptive civil engineering toward Earth-systems-integrated land-use planning is critical to ensuring India's ecological stability and long-term infrastructural resilience.

Key facts to remember

definition
Angle of Repose

The steepest angle of dip relative to the horizontal plane to which a loose material can be piled without slumping or undergoing slope failure.

case study
Joshimath Ground Subsidence

Unregulated multi-storey construction and infrastructure tunneling atop unconsolidated glacial moraine debris severely undermined soil bearing capacity, damaging more than 65% of local structures.

statistic

Wayanad district received roughly 573 mm of rain in 48 hours, creating intense pore-water pressure in fractured lateritic slopes that catalyzed fatal debris avalanches.

India Meteorological Department (IMD)
scheme
Ecologically Sensitive Zones (ESZ) Notification

Notified under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, to serve as 'shock absorbers' around protected areas and regulate hazardous infrastructure in high-vulnerability mountain tracts.

Frequently asked questions

How does toe-cutting cause chronic landslides in hill roads?

Excavating the toe or base of a slope removes the natural mechanical buttress supporting the overburden, steepening the slope gradient beyond the critical angle of repose and drastically lowering its shear strength.