UPSC MainsPolitical Science (Optional)Environment and EcologyPractice question

Theoretical Foundations and Core Schools of Ecofeminism

Comment on Ecofeminism.

Comment~250 words2 min readmedium
Attempt it first, timed · optional

Write the answer on paper, as in the exam. Start the timer, keep to the word target.

00:00/ 11 min · 250 words

Done writing? Photograph the sheet and see how it scores against this model answer, with feedback on what to fix.

Upload your answer sheet

How to approach

Introduce ecofeminism by defining its historical emergence and central intersectional premise linking patriarchal oppression with ecological exploitation. In the body, examine the distinct schools of thought—cultural versus materialist ecofeminism—and discuss the conceptual shift toward feminist environmentalism. Conclude by highlighting ecofeminism's relevance to modern climate justice and sustainable development.

Model answer

335 words

Introduction

Coined by French feminist Françoise d’Eaubonne in 1974, ecofeminism is an intersectional political and social ideology that posits that the patriarchal subjugation of women and the capitalist exploitation of nature share identical structural roots of domination. It critiques dominant anthropocentric and patriarchal paradigms, emphasizing that ecological sustainability cannot be achieved without addressing systemic gender inequality.

Core Schools of Ecofeminist Thought

Ecofeminist scholarship is multifaceted, encompassing divergent theoretical perspectives regarding the nature of women's relationship with the environment:

  • Cultural Ecofeminism: Thinkers such as Vandana Shiva (in Staying Alive) posit an inherent, spiritual, and nurturing affinity between women and nature (Prakriti). This school critiques patriarchal modernity and mechanistic science for reducing nature and female life-giving capacities to commodified resources, advocating for a resurgence of feminine principles of reciprocity and care.
  • Materialist and Socialist Ecofeminism: Theorists such as Maria Mies and Ariel Salleh reject biological essentialism. They ground women's environmental consciousness in the material reality of capitalist patriarchy, arguing that women's proximity to nature arises from their structurally assigned roles in unpaid social reproductive work, caretaking, and subsistence economies.

Theoretical Evolution: Feminist Environmentalism

Scholars have sought to move beyond the essentialist pitfalls of early cultural ecofeminism by developing more grounded analytical frameworks:

  • Material Reality of Labour: Bina Agarwal conceptualises Feminist Environmentalism, critiquing cultural ecofeminism for romanticizing an innate spiritual connection. She demonstrates that female environmental mobilization—such as during the Chipko Movement—is driven by the gendered division of labour, where women bear the brunt of collecting fuel, fodder, and water for daily survival.
  • Structural and Environmental Vulnerability: Degradation of communal natural resources directly impacts women's livelihood security and time poverty, turning environmental preservation into a struggle for basic socio-economic survival rather than an abstract ecological or metaphysical pursuit.

Conclusion

By systematically linking ecological destruction with gendered vulnerability, ecofeminism provides an indispensable theoretical foundation for modern climate justice. It underscores that equitable climate governance, in alignment with Sustainable Development Goals 5 (Gender Equality) and 13 (Climate Action), necessitates dismantling both patriarchal hierarchies and unsustainable exploitative economic models.

Key facts to remember

definition
Ecofeminism

A branch of political and social philosophy that connects the systemic degradation of the natural environment to the patriarchal oppression and exploitation of women.

definition
Feminist Environmentalism

A concept formulated by Bina Agarwal arguing that women's engagement with ecological preservation stems from their concrete material dependence and gendered division of labour rather than biological or spiritual essence.

example
Chipko Movement

A grassroots ecological resistance in the Himalayas where women mobilized against deforestation to safeguard vital forest resources needed for subsistence, fuel, and fodder.

Frequently asked questions

What is the primary critique against cultural ecofeminism?

Cultural ecofeminism is primarily critiqued for biological essentialism—presuming an innate, universal spiritual bond between women and nature—which obscures historical, regional, and class-based differences in women's material realities.