UPSC MainsBOTANY-PAPER-I201115 Marks
Q7.

Giving suitable reasons, describe inter-alia, evolutionary status of Psilotum, Selaginella and Marsilea.

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of plant evolutionary history, specifically focusing on the phylogenetic positions of Psilotum, Selaginella, and Marsilea. The answer should trace their evolutionary origins, highlighting key characteristics that place them on the evolutionary tree of land plants. A comparative approach, outlining their primitive and advanced features, is crucial. The answer should demonstrate knowledge of the transition from vascular plants to seed plants, and the role these plants play in understanding that transition. Structure the answer by discussing each plant individually, then comparing their evolutionary status.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The evolution of land plants represents a pivotal moment in Earth’s history, leading to the diversification of the plant kingdom we see today. Understanding the evolutionary relationships between different plant groups is crucial for comprehending the development of key adaptations for terrestrial life. Psilotum, Selaginella, and Marsilea represent distinct lineages within the vascular plants – specifically, the lycophytes and monilophytes – and provide valuable insights into the evolutionary steps leading to modern seed plants. Their characteristics reveal a complex interplay of primitive and advanced traits, allowing us to reconstruct their evolutionary status and relationships. This answer will detail the evolutionary status of each plant, providing reasons based on their morphological, anatomical, and reproductive features.

Psilotum: A Relic of Early Vascular Plant Evolution

Psilotum, often referred to as whisk fern, is a peculiar plant that has long fascinated botanists due to its simple morphology. It lacks true roots and leaves, possessing only dichotomously branching stems with scale-like appendages. Its evolutionary status was initially debated, with some considering it a primitive vascular plant, even a direct ancestor of ferns. However, molecular phylogenetic studies have revealed a more nuanced picture.

  • Evolutionary Status: Psilotum is now considered a highly reduced fern ally, belonging to the Psilotales order. It is not a primitive ancestor but rather a descendant that has undergone significant secondary simplification.
  • Primitive Features: The absence of true roots and leaves, along with its simple vascular tissue, suggests a loss of complexity rather than a primitive state.
  • Advanced Features: Its sporangia are borne on short stalks, and it exhibits a unique synangium structure, indicating a derived condition. The presence of underground rhizomes for perennation is also a more advanced feature.
  • Evidence: Molecular data places Psilotum firmly within the ferns and fern allies (monilophytes), demonstrating its evolutionary relationship to more complex ferns.

Selaginella: A Representative of Early Lycophytes

Selaginella, commonly known as spikemoss, is a genus of lycophytes characterized by its small, scale-like leaves arranged spirally or oppositely on the stem. It differs from other lycophytes like Lycopodium in having ligules (small flaps of tissue) on the upper surface of the leaves.

  • Evolutionary Status: Selaginella represents a more advanced group of lycophytes compared to early forms like Baragwanathia. It is considered a crucial link in understanding the evolution of heterospory.
  • Primitive Features: Its vascular tissue is relatively simple, and it reproduces via spores. The microphylls (small, single-veined leaves) are considered a primitive feature of lycophytes.
  • Advanced Features: Selaginella is renowned for exhibiting heterospory – the production of two distinct types of spores (microspores and megaspores). This is a significant evolutionary step towards the development of seeds. The presence of ligules is also a derived character.
  • Significance: The evolution of heterospory in Selaginella is considered a precursor to the evolution of seeds, as it allows for the development of specialized male and female gametophytes.

Marsilea: A Water Fern with Seed-Like Characteristics

Marsilea, a genus of aquatic ferns, is characterized by its four-lobed leaves that resemble clover leaves. It is a heterosporous plant, and its sporocarps (spore-containing structures) are unique and resemble seeds in their protective function and dispersal mechanisms.

  • Evolutionary Status: Marsilea is a relatively advanced fern, belonging to the Salviniales order. It represents a significant step in the evolution of vascular plants, exhibiting features that foreshadow the development of seeds.
  • Primitive Features: It reproduces via spores and requires water for fertilization, indicating a dependence on moist environments.
  • Advanced Features: Marsilea exhibits pronounced heterospory, with highly reduced male gametophytes contained within the microspores and female gametophytes developing within the megaspores. Its sporocarps provide protection to the developing spores and aid in dispersal, resembling seeds in function. The sporocarp wall has multiple layers, offering robust protection.
  • Adaptations: The sporocarp’s ability to withstand desiccation and disperse via water currents demonstrates adaptations that are analogous to those found in seed plants.

Comparative Table of Evolutionary Status

Plant Primitive Features Advanced Features Evolutionary Significance
Psilotum Lack of true roots & leaves, simple vascular tissue Synangium structure, rhizomes Represents secondary simplification within ferns; insights into fern evolution.
Selaginella Microphylls, spore reproduction Heterospory, ligules Crucial link in the evolution of heterospory; precursor to seed evolution.
Marsilea Spore reproduction, water dependence Pronounced heterospory, sporocarps resembling seeds Demonstrates adaptations analogous to seed plants; provides insights into seed evolution.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Psilotum, Selaginella, and Marsilea each occupy a unique position in the evolutionary history of vascular plants. Psilotum represents a highly reduced fern ally, Selaginella showcases the pivotal evolutionary step of heterospory, and Marsilea exhibits adaptations that foreshadow the development of seeds. Their combined characteristics provide a compelling narrative of the transition from simple vascular plants to the more complex seed plants that dominate terrestrial ecosystems today. Further research, particularly in molecular phylogenetics, will continue to refine our understanding of their precise evolutionary relationships and the intricate processes that shaped the plant kingdom.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Heterospory
The production of two distinct types of spores – microspores (male) and megaspores (female) – by a plant. This is a key evolutionary step towards the development of seeds.
Microphylls
Small, single-veined leaves characteristic of lycophytes. They are considered a primitive type of leaf compared to the larger, more complex megaphylls found in ferns and seed plants.

Key Statistics

Approximately 85% of all known plant species are angiosperms (flowering plants), highlighting the success of seed plant evolution.

Source: Raven, P. H., Evert, R. F., & Eichhorn, S. E. (2013). Biology of Plants (8th ed.). W. H. Freeman and Company.

The fossil record indicates that lycophytes were dominant plants during the Carboniferous period, comprising up to 70% of the vegetation in some areas.

Source: Stewart, W. N., & Rothwell, G. W. (1996). Paleobotany and the Evolution of Plants (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press.

Examples

Rhynia

Rhynia is an extinct early vascular plant from the Silurian period, representing one of the earliest known land plants. Its simple structure, lacking true roots and leaves, provides a glimpse into the ancestral condition of vascular plants, offering a point of comparison for understanding the evolution of plants like Psilotum.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is Psilotum considered a reduced fern rather than a primitive ancestor?

While Psilotum lacks roots and leaves, molecular phylogenetic studies consistently place it within the fern lineage, indicating it *lost* these features through evolution, rather than representing an ancestral state. Its sporangia structure also shows derived characteristics.

Topics Covered

BotanyEvolutionPteridophytesPlant PhylogenyEvolutionary Biology