UPSC MainsBOTANY-PAPER-II201115 Marks
Q14.

Distinguish between monoploid and haploid and their role in evolution.

How to Approach

This question requires a clear understanding of the genetic concepts of monoploidy and haploidy, and their significance in evolutionary processes. The answer should begin by defining both terms, highlighting their differences in chromosome number and origin. Subsequently, it should elaborate on how each contributes to evolution, focusing on mechanisms like adaptation, speciation, and the exposure of recessive alleles. A comparative approach, outlining the advantages and disadvantages of each in an evolutionary context, will strengthen the response.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The study of chromosome number and its variations is fundamental to understanding evolutionary processes. Both monoploidy and haploidy represent deviations from the typical diploid state found in most sexually reproducing organisms. While often detrimental, these conditions can also provide the raw genetic material for evolutionary innovation. Monoploidy, representing a single set of chromosomes, and haploidy, representing half the number of chromosomes found in a normal somatic cell, each offer unique evolutionary pathways. Understanding their distinctions and roles is crucial for comprehending the mechanisms driving biodiversity and adaptation.

Distinguishing Monoploid and Haploid

Both monoploidy and haploidy involve a reduction in chromosome number compared to the diploid state (2n). However, their origins and implications differ significantly.

  • Haploidy (n): This refers to possessing a single set of chromosomes, typically found in gametes (sex cells) or in certain organisms undergoing asexual reproduction. It arises naturally during meiosis, the process of gamete formation. Haploidy is a normal and essential part of the life cycle in many organisms, including bees (males), fungi, and some algae.
  • Monoploidy (n-1): This refers to the loss of one chromosome from a diploid set, resulting in 2n-1 chromosomes. It typically arises due to non-disjunction during meiosis or through errors in early cell division. Monoploidy is generally more detrimental than haploidy, often leading to sterility or developmental abnormalities.

The key difference lies in their origin and frequency. Haploidy is a natural and functional state in certain life cycles, while monoploidy is usually an accidental and often deleterious condition.

Role of Haploidy in Evolution

Haploidy plays a significant role in several evolutionary processes:

  • Exposure of Recessive Alleles: In haploid organisms, there is no masking of recessive alleles. This allows for immediate selection based on the phenotype expressed by these alleles, accelerating adaptation.
  • Rapid Adaptation: Haploids can adapt quickly to changing environments because beneficial mutations are immediately expressed and selected for.
  • Speciation: In some fungi and algae, haploidy is a crucial stage in their life cycle, facilitating genetic recombination and contributing to speciation.
  • Male Determination in Hymenoptera: In bees, wasps, and ants (Hymenoptera), males develop from unfertilized eggs and are therefore haploid, while females are diploid. This unique system influences social structure and sex determination.

Role of Monoploidy in Evolution

While generally detrimental, monoploidy can also contribute to evolution, albeit in a more limited capacity:

  • Source of Aneuploidy: Monoploidy can be a stepping stone to other forms of aneuploidy (abnormal chromosome number), which, while often harmful, can occasionally lead to novel traits.
  • Hybrid Speciation: In rare cases, monoploidy can occur in hybrids, potentially leading to the formation of new species. This is more common in plants.
  • Genetic Variation: Although rare, surviving monoploids can contribute to genetic variation within a population, providing material for future selection.

However, the negative consequences of monoploidy – such as reduced fertility and developmental defects – often outweigh its potential benefits.

Comparative Table

Feature Haploidy (n) Monoploidy (2n-1)
Chromosome Number Single set (n) Missing one chromosome (2n-1)
Origin Meiosis, asexual reproduction Non-disjunction, errors in cell division
Frequency Common in certain life cycles Rare, usually accidental
Viability Often viable and functional Often lethal or causes severe defects
Evolutionary Role Adaptation, speciation, sex determination Source of aneuploidy, rare hybrid speciation

Conclusion

In conclusion, both monoploidy and haploidy represent deviations from the typical diploid chromosome number, but they differ significantly in their origins, frequencies, and evolutionary consequences. Haploidy, being a natural state in many organisms, plays a more prominent role in adaptation and speciation by exposing recessive alleles and accelerating selection. Monoploidy, while generally detrimental, can occasionally contribute to genetic variation and hybrid speciation. Understanding these chromosomal variations is crucial for comprehending the complex mechanisms driving evolutionary change and the diversity of life on Earth.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Aneuploidy
Aneuploidy refers to an abnormal number of chromosomes in a cell, differing from the normal diploid number. This can involve the loss or gain of one or more chromosomes.
Diploid
Diploid refers to having two complete sets of chromosomes, one inherited from each parent. This is the typical chromosome number in most somatic cells of sexually reproducing organisms.

Key Statistics

Approximately 1 in 500 births are estimated to have a sex chromosome aneuploidy (e.g., Turner syndrome, Klinefelter syndrome).

Source: National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI) - as of 2023 knowledge cutoff

Plant species exhibit a wider range of ploidy levels than animal species. Approximately 30-80% of flowering plant species are polyploid (having more than two sets of chromosomes).

Source: Soltis et al., 2007, American Journal of Botany

Examples

Honeybee Sex Determination

Honeybees exhibit a haplodiploid sex-determination system. Females are diploid (developed from fertilized eggs), while males are haploid (developed from unfertilized eggs). This system leads to unique genetic relationships within the hive.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can monoploidy occur in humans?

Yes, but it is almost always lethal. Very rarely, individuals with mosaicism (some cells are monoploid, others are diploid) may survive, but they typically have severe developmental abnormalities.

Topics Covered

GeneticsEvolutionPloidyGenetic VariationEvolutionary Biology