UPSC MainsECONOMICS-PAPER-I201120 Marks200 Words
Q16.

How can the structural independence between A-sector and K-sector in the dualistic economy foster growth in the absence of external stimuli?

How to Approach

This question requires understanding of the Lewis model of economic development, specifically the dual-sector model. The answer should explain the concept of structural independence between the agricultural (A-sector) and industrial (K-sector), and how surplus labor transfer from A to K, coupled with capital accumulation in K, can drive growth even without external demand shocks. Focus on the reinvestment of profits within the K-sector as the key mechanism. Structure the answer by first defining the sectors, then explaining the independence, the growth mechanism, and finally, potential limitations.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The dual-sector model, pioneered by W. Arthur Lewis in 1954, posits an economy with a traditional, labor-surplus agricultural sector (A-sector) and a modern, capital-intensive industrial sector (K-sector). This model is particularly relevant for understanding the development trajectories of many post-colonial economies. Structural independence between these sectors, meaning limited direct linkages and a degree of self-sufficiency in the K-sector’s reinvestment, is crucial for sustained growth. This independence allows the K-sector to expand and absorb labor from the A-sector, fostering economic development even in the absence of significant external stimuli like foreign aid or export demand.

Understanding the A and K Sectors

The A-sector, typically agriculture, is characterized by low productivity, surplus labor (marginal product of labor is near zero), and traditional production techniques. The K-sector, representing industry and modern services, exhibits higher productivity, capital intensity, and potential for technological advancement. The core assumption is that labor can be transferred from the A-sector to the K-sector without reducing agricultural output significantly, at least initially.

Structural Independence and its Significance

Structural independence implies that the K-sector is not heavily reliant on the A-sector for inputs or demand, and vice versa. This is achieved through:

  • Limited Backward Linkages: The K-sector doesn’t necessarily require substantial inputs from the A-sector. It can import necessary raw materials or develop its own synthetic substitutes.
  • Limited Forward Linkages: The K-sector doesn’t primarily cater to the demand of the A-sector. Its output is directed towards domestic urban markets or exports.
  • Autonomous Investment: Crucially, profits generated in the K-sector are largely reinvested *within* the K-sector, rather than being siphoned off to other sectors or abroad.

This independence is vital because it insulates the K-sector from shocks originating in the A-sector (e.g., poor harvests) and allows it to pursue its own growth path.

Growth Mechanism in the Absence of External Stimuli

The growth process unfolds as follows:

  1. Labor Transfer: Surplus labor migrates from the A-sector to the K-sector, drawn by higher wages.
  2. Profit Generation: The K-sector, utilizing this labor, generates profits due to its higher productivity.
  3. Capital Accumulation: These profits are reinvested in the K-sector, expanding its capital stock and increasing its capacity to absorb more labor.
  4. Wage Increase (eventually): As labor becomes scarcer in the K-sector, wages begin to rise, eventually eliminating the wage differential between the two sectors.

This self-sustaining cycle of labor transfer, profit generation, and capital accumulation drives economic growth. The absence of external stimuli is less critical because the reinvestment of profits within the K-sector provides the necessary impetus for expansion. This is an internally driven growth process.

Limitations and Considerations

While powerful, this model has limitations:

  • Diminishing Returns: Eventually, the supply of surplus labor in the A-sector may be exhausted, leading to diminishing returns to labor in the K-sector.
  • Capital-Output Ratio: The model assumes a constant capital-output ratio, which may not hold in reality.
  • Institutional Factors: The model doesn’t fully account for institutional factors like property rights, corruption, and political instability, which can hinder investment.
  • Demand Constraints: While the model focuses on supply-side factors, sustained growth also requires sufficient demand for the K-sector’s output.

Furthermore, complete structural independence is rarely observed in reality. Some degree of linkage between the sectors is inevitable and can be beneficial, fostering agricultural modernization and rural development.

Conclusion

The structural independence between the A and K sectors, as envisioned by the Lewis model, provides a compelling framework for understanding how developing economies can achieve self-sustained growth through internal dynamics. The reinvestment of profits within the industrial sector is the key driver, reducing reliance on external factors. However, acknowledging the model’s limitations and addressing institutional constraints are crucial for realizing its full potential and ensuring inclusive growth. Moving forward, policies should focus on fostering a conducive investment climate and promoting technological advancements within the K-sector while simultaneously improving productivity in the A-sector.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Dual-Sector Model
A macroeconomic model of development in which the economy is divided into two sectors: a traditional, labor-intensive agricultural sector and a modern, capital-intensive industrial sector.
Surplus Labor
Labor whose marginal product is zero or very low; removing such labor does not significantly reduce output. This is a key characteristic of the A-sector in the Lewis model.

Key Statistics

India's share of agricultural contribution to GDP has declined from 55.11% in 1990-91 to 18.8% in 2022-23 (as per Economic Survey 2023-24).

Source: Economic Survey 2023-24

According to the World Bank, the share of manufacturing value added in GDP in India was 17.6% in 2022, indicating the relative size of the K-sector.

Source: World Bank Data (2022)

Examples

East Asian Tigers

The rapid industrialization of countries like South Korea, Taiwan, and Singapore in the 1960s and 70s exemplifies the Lewis model. They successfully transferred labor from agriculture to manufacturing, reinvested profits in industry, and achieved high growth rates.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens when the A-sector experiences a negative shock, like a drought?

If the K-sector is structurally independent, the impact of the A-sector shock will be limited. The K-sector can continue to grow, potentially even absorbing more labor from the A-sector as agricultural employment declines. However, if there are significant linkages, the shock can propagate to the K-sector.

Topics Covered

EconomyDevelopment EconomicsEconomic DevelopmentStructural ChangeSectoral Growth