UPSC MainsPUBLIC-ADMINISTRATION-PAPER-I201120 Marks200 Words
Q2.

‘Media is a Parliament of citizens.’ Explain.

How to Approach

This question requires an understanding of the role of media in a democratic society and its function as a platform for public discourse. The answer should explain how media, through its various forms, facilitates citizen participation, holds power accountable, and shapes public opinion, mirroring the functions of a parliament. Structure the answer by first defining the concept, then elaborating on the ways media acts as a 'parliament of citizens', providing examples, and finally, acknowledging the limitations.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The phrase ‘Media is a Parliament of citizens’ encapsulates the vital role the media plays in a democratic setup. Traditionally, a parliament is a forum for debate, deliberation, and law-making, representing the will of the people. However, in contemporary democracies, the media – encompassing print, television, radio, and increasingly, digital platforms – has emerged as a powerful space where citizens express their views, scrutinize government actions, and participate in shaping public policy. This expanded public sphere, facilitated by the media, effectively functions as an ongoing, dynamic ‘parliament’ of the citizenry.

Media as a Platform for Public Discourse

The media provides a platform for diverse voices and perspectives, allowing citizens to engage in public discourse on issues of national importance. This is analogous to the debates and discussions that occur within a parliament.

  • Agenda Setting: Media outlets, through their coverage, influence which issues are considered important by the public, similar to how a parliament prioritizes legislation.
  • Public Opinion Formation: By presenting different viewpoints, the media shapes public opinion and influences policy decisions. This mirrors the role of parliament in reflecting and responding to public sentiment.
  • Citizen Journalism & Social Media: The rise of citizen journalism and social media has further democratized the media landscape, allowing individuals to directly participate in news dissemination and public debate. Platforms like Twitter and Facebook have become virtual town halls.

Media’s Role in Accountability and Oversight

A crucial function of parliament is to hold the executive accountable. The media performs a similar role by scrutinizing government actions and exposing corruption or wrongdoing.

  • Investigative Journalism: Investigative reporting, like the exposure of the 2G spectrum scam (2010) or the Radia tapes (2010), acts as a check on power, forcing accountability.
  • Right to Information (RTI) & Media: The interplay between the RTI Act, 2005 and media reporting has been instrumental in uncovering corruption and promoting transparency.
  • Parliamentary Coverage: Media coverage of parliamentary proceedings, though often selective, keeps citizens informed about the actions of their representatives.

Limitations and Challenges

While the media functions as a ‘parliament of citizens’, it is not without its limitations. These challenges can hinder its effectiveness and distort the democratic process.

  • Media Ownership & Bias: Concentrated media ownership can lead to biased reporting and suppression of dissenting voices.
  • Fake News & Misinformation: The proliferation of fake news and misinformation, particularly on social media, erodes public trust and undermines informed debate. According to a Reuters Institute report (2023), misinformation is a significant threat to democratic processes globally.
  • Sensationalism & Yellow Journalism: The focus on sensationalism and ‘yellow journalism’ can detract from substantive issues and polarize public opinion.
  • Lack of Diversity: Underrepresentation of marginalized communities in media ownership and reporting can lead to skewed narratives.

The Evolving Media Landscape

The digital revolution has fundamentally altered the media landscape. The emergence of online news platforms, blogs, and social media has created new opportunities for citizen engagement, but also new challenges related to regulation and accountability.

Traditional Media New Media
Gatekeepers of information Decentralized information dissemination
One-way communication Interactive and participatory
Professional journalists Citizen journalists and bloggers

Conclusion

In conclusion, the assertion that ‘Media is a Parliament of citizens’ holds considerable truth. The media, in its diverse forms, provides a crucial platform for public discourse, holds power accountable, and shapes public opinion, mirroring the core functions of a parliament. However, it is essential to acknowledge the limitations and challenges facing the media today, including bias, misinformation, and concentrated ownership. Strengthening media literacy, promoting ethical journalism, and fostering a diverse media landscape are crucial for ensuring that the media continues to serve as a vibrant and effective ‘parliament’ for all citizens.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Public Sphere
A realm of social life where individuals can come together to freely discuss and identify societal problems, and thus influence political action. Jurgen Habermas conceptualized the public sphere as essential for democratic governance.
Agenda Setting Theory
A theory in political science that states that the media doesn't tell people *what* to think, but *what to think about*. By choosing which stories to cover and how to frame them, the media influences the salience of issues in the public mind.

Key Statistics

India has over 1.4 billion mobile phone users (TRAI, 2023), making it one of the largest mobile markets globally, significantly impacting media consumption patterns.

Source: Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI), 2023

Digital news consumption in India has grown by 80% since 2018 (Newslaundry, 2023), indicating a shift in media habits and increased reliance on online sources.

Source: Newslaundry, 2023

Examples

Anna Hazare Movement (2011)

The anti-corruption movement led by Anna Hazare in 2011 effectively utilized media, particularly television and social media, to mobilize public support and pressure the government to enact the Lokpal Bill. This demonstrated the media’s power to amplify citizen voices and influence policy.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does social media differ from traditional media in its role as a 'parliament of citizens'?

Social media allows for direct citizen participation and bypasses traditional gatekeepers of information, fostering a more decentralized and interactive public sphere. However, it also presents challenges related to misinformation and echo chambers.

Topics Covered

PolityMediaCurrent AffairsFreedom of PressPublic SphereDemocracy