UPSC MainsSOCIOLOGY-PAPER-II201130 Marks
Q10.

What are the linkage points between globalisation and the growth of the informal sector? How have these affected the nature and functioning of the working class?

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of the interplay between globalisation, the informal sector, and the working class. The answer should begin by defining globalisation and the informal sector, then explore the linkages between them – focusing on how globalisation’s pressures and opportunities have fuelled the growth of informality. It should then analyze the impact on the working class, considering changes in employment patterns, working conditions, and social security. A structure following 'Linkages -> Impact on Working Class -> Nuances' is recommended.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Globalisation, characterized by increased interconnectedness through trade, investment, and migration, has profoundly reshaped economies worldwide. Simultaneously, the informal sector – encompassing economic activities operating outside formal regulations and protections – remains a significant feature of developing nations like India. The relationship between these two is complex and often paradoxical. While globalisation promises formal employment and economic growth, it has also inadvertently contributed to the expansion of the informal sector, particularly affecting the nature and functioning of the working class. This growth is not merely a residual phenomenon but a dynamic response to the pressures and opportunities created by global economic integration.

Linkages between Globalisation and the Growth of the Informal Sector

Several key linkages explain the growth of the informal sector in the context of globalisation:

  • Increased Competition & Cost Reduction: Globalisation intensifies competition, forcing firms to reduce costs. Outsourcing, subcontracting, and casualisation of labour are common strategies, leading to a rise in informal employment.
  • Trade Liberalisation & Agricultural Distress: Trade liberalisation often exposes domestic industries, particularly agriculture, to global competition. This can lead to job losses in the formal sector and push workers into informal activities for survival. The agricultural sector, facing competition from subsidized imports, has seen a significant increase in informal employment.
  • Structural Adjustment Policies: Structural adjustment programs (SAPs) imposed by international financial institutions (like the IMF and World Bank) often involve privatization, deregulation, and austerity measures. These policies can lead to public sector job losses and a decline in social safety nets, pushing more people into the informal sector.
  • Rise of Global Value Chains (GVCs): GVCs often rely on informal suppliers and subcontractors, particularly in developing countries, to reduce costs and maintain flexibility. This creates a demand for informal labour.
  • Technological Change & Digital Platforms: While technology can create formal employment, it also facilitates the growth of the ‘gig economy’ and platform work, which often lacks the protections and benefits of formal employment.

Impact on the Nature and Functioning of the Working Class

Globalisation-induced growth of the informal sector has significantly altered the nature and functioning of the working class:

  • Precarious Employment: Informal workers face precarious employment conditions – lacking job security, benefits (health insurance, pensions), and legal protection.
  • Wage Stagnation & Declining Bargaining Power: Increased competition and the availability of cheap labour in the informal sector suppress wages and weaken the bargaining power of workers.
  • Erosion of Labour Standards: The informal sector is often characterized by poor working conditions, long hours, and unsafe environments. Labour laws are often poorly enforced in these settings.
  • Increased Vulnerability: Informal workers are more vulnerable to economic shocks, such as recessions or natural disasters, as they lack social safety nets.
  • Changes in Skill Requirements: Globalisation demands new skills, but informal workers often lack access to training and education, leading to skill gaps and limited opportunities for upward mobility.
  • Rise of Self-Employment & Entrepreneurship (of Necessity): Many workers are forced into self-employment in the informal sector due to a lack of formal employment opportunities. This often involves low-income activities and limited growth potential.

Nuances and Regional Variations

The impact of globalisation on the informal sector and the working class is not uniform across regions. Several nuances exist:

  • Regional Disparities: The growth of the informal sector is more pronounced in regions with weaker institutional capacity and limited access to education and infrastructure.
  • Sectoral Differences: The impact varies across sectors. For example, the garment industry and construction are particularly reliant on informal labour.
  • Gendered Impacts: Women are disproportionately represented in the informal sector, often facing lower wages and greater vulnerability.
  • Role of Migration: Migration, both internal and international, can contribute to the growth of the informal sector as migrants often take up informal jobs due to limited opportunities in the formal sector.

Data on Informal Employment: According to the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS) 2022-23, approximately 88.6% of the workforce in India is employed in the informal sector. (Source: Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, 2023 - Knowledge Cutoff)

Conclusion

The relationship between globalisation and the informal sector is a complex one, marked by both opportunities and challenges. While globalisation has the potential to create formal employment and economic growth, it has also inadvertently contributed to the expansion of informality, particularly impacting the working class through precarious employment, wage stagnation, and increased vulnerability. Addressing this requires a multi-pronged approach, including strengthening labour laws, investing in education and skills development, promoting social protection, and fostering inclusive growth strategies that benefit all segments of the workforce. A focus on formalizing the informal sector, while acknowledging its inherent complexities, is crucial for ensuring equitable and sustainable development.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Globalisation
The process of increasing interconnectedness and interdependence of countries through trade, investment, migration, and cultural exchange.
Informal Sector
The part of the economy that is not taxed or monitored by the government; it includes activities that are not formally registered and operate outside the legal framework.

Key Statistics

The share of the informal sector in India’s GDP was approximately 52% in 2018.

Source: National Statistical Office (NSO), 2019 - Knowledge Cutoff

Examples

Garment Industry in Bangladesh

The garment industry in Bangladesh, a major exporter to global markets, relies heavily on informal labour, characterized by low wages, poor working conditions, and limited worker rights. This exemplifies how GVCs can contribute to informality.

Street Vendors in India

Street vending is a significant part of the informal economy in India, providing livelihoods for millions but lacking formal recognition and protection. The Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014, aims to address some of these issues.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the informal sector always negative?

No, the informal sector provides livelihoods for millions, fosters entrepreneurship, and contributes to economic activity. However, its lack of regulation and protection creates vulnerabilities for workers and hinders economic development.

Topics Covered

EconomySociologyGlobalisation, Labour Market, Informal Economy, Economic Development