UPSC MainsBOTANY-PAPER-I201212 Marks
Q7.

Differentiate between the following : (a) Polarity and Symmetry (b) Prions and Viroids (c) Rust and Smut diseases (d) Eusporangiate and Leptosporangiate ferns (e) Downy mildews and Powdery mildews.

How to Approach

This question requires a comparative understanding of fundamental concepts in botany and plant pathology. The approach should be to define each term in a pair, then clearly delineate their differences using specific characteristics. A tabular format can be used for clarity where appropriate. Focus on the underlying biological principles and practical implications of each distinction. The answer should demonstrate a strong grasp of botanical terminology and disease mechanisms.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Botany, the scientific study of plants, encompasses a vast array of concepts, from cellular structures to ecological interactions. Plant pathology, a specialized branch, focuses on the diseases affecting plants and the mechanisms behind them. Understanding the distinctions between key terms within these fields is crucial for accurate diagnosis, effective management, and furthering our knowledge of plant life. This answer will differentiate between the specified pairs, providing a comprehensive overview of their unique characteristics and significance.

(a) Polarity and Symmetry

Polarity refers to the inherent physiological differentiation of plant organs, particularly in relation to the direction of growth. It’s evident in the apical-basal axis of a plant, where the apex (shoot) and base (root) exhibit distinct developmental patterns. This is largely governed by auxin transport. Symmetry, on the other hand, describes the arrangement of similar parts around a central axis.

Polarity Symmetry
Directional growth; apical-basal axis. Arrangement of parts around an axis.
Physiological differentiation. Morphological arrangement.
Example: Apical dominance. Example: Radial symmetry in a flower.

(b) Prions and Viroids

Both prions and viroids are infectious agents, but they differ significantly in their composition. Prions are misfolded proteins that can induce normal proteins to adopt the same misfolded shape, leading to disease. They lack nucleic acid. Viroids are small, circular RNA molecules that do not encode proteins but can replicate within plant cells, causing disease.

Prions Viroids
Composed of misfolded proteins. Composed of small, circular RNA.
Affect animals (e.g., Mad Cow Disease). Affect plants (e.g., Potato Spindle Tuber Disease).
Lack nucleic acid. Contain RNA, but do not encode proteins.

(c) Rust and Smut Diseases

Both rust and smut are fungal diseases that affect plants, but they differ in their symptoms and the fungal structures they produce. Rust diseases are characterized by reddish-brown pustules on leaves and stems, containing urediniospores and teliospores. Smut diseases, conversely, cause black, powdery masses of spores (smut) that replace plant tissues, particularly in grains.

Rust Diseases Smut Diseases
Reddish-brown pustules. Black, powdery masses (smut).
Urediniospores and teliospores present. Smut spores replace plant tissues.
Example: Wheat stem rust. Example: Corn smut.

(d) Eusporangiate and Leptosporangiate Ferns

Ferns are classified based on their sporangium development. Eusporangiate ferns have large, thick-walled sporangia that develop from several initial cells, often with a substantial stalk. They are generally considered more primitive. Leptosporangiate ferns have smaller, thin-walled sporangia that develop from a single initial cell, typically with a delicate stalk. They represent the majority of modern ferns.

Eusporangiate Ferns Leptosporangiate Ferns
Large, thick-walled sporangia. Small, thin-walled sporangia.
Develop from multiple initial cells. Develop from a single initial cell.
More primitive. More advanced; majority of modern ferns.
Example: Equisetum (horsetails). Example: Dryopteris (wood fern).

(e) Downy Mildews and Powdery Mildews

Both downy and powdery mildews are fungal diseases affecting plants, but they differ in their appearance and the location of fungal growth. Downy mildews appear as yellowish spots on the upper leaf surface, with a downy growth of fungal spores on the underside. Powdery mildews appear as a white, powdery coating on the surface of leaves, stems, and flowers.

Downy Mildews Powdery Mildews
Yellowish spots on upper leaf surface. White, powdery coating on plant surfaces.
Downy growth on underside of leaves. Fungal growth remains on the surface.
Often caused by oomycetes (water molds). Caused by ascomycete fungi.
Example: Grape downy mildew. Example: Rose powdery mildew.

Conclusion

In conclusion, understanding the distinctions between these botanical and pathological terms is fundamental to comprehending plant biology and disease management. Polarity and symmetry describe plant structure, while prions and viroids represent unique infectious agents. Rust and smut diseases, along with downy and powdery mildews, exemplify the diverse challenges posed by plant pathogens. Recognizing these differences is crucial for accurate diagnosis, effective control strategies, and continued advancements in plant science.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Apical Dominance
The phenomenon where the apical bud inhibits the growth of lateral buds, resulting in a dominant central stem. This is regulated by auxin.
Oomycetes
A group of filamentous microorganisms, formerly classified as fungi, but now recognized as belonging to the Stramenopiles clade. Many oomycetes are plant pathogens, causing diseases like downy mildew and late blight.

Key Statistics

Global crop losses due to plant diseases are estimated at 40% annually, impacting food security worldwide.

Source: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), 2019 (Knowledge Cutoff)

Approximately 10,000 plant species are known to be affected by fungal diseases globally.

Source: Agrios, G. N. (2005). Plant Pathology. Academic Press. (Knowledge Cutoff)

Examples

Potato Famine (1845-1849)

The Irish Potato Famine was caused by the oomycete <i>Phytophthora infestans</i>, leading to widespread potato blight and devastating consequences for the Irish population.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a pathogen and a parasite?

A pathogen causes disease, while a parasite benefits by living on or in a host, potentially causing harm but not necessarily disease. Some pathogens are also parasites.

Topics Covered

BotanyPlant PathologyFungiVirusesDiseases