UPSC MainsBOTANY-PAPER-II201212 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q4.

Give an experimental evidence to demonstrate that DNA is a genetic material.

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of the historical experiments that established DNA as the genetic material. The answer should chronologically outline the key experiments – Griffith’s transformation experiment, Avery-MacLeod-McCarty experiment, Hershey-Chase experiment – explaining their methodologies, observations, and conclusions. Emphasis should be placed on how each experiment built upon the previous one, ultimately providing conclusive evidence for DNA’s role. A clear and concise explanation of the principles behind each experiment is crucial.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The quest to identify the genetic material has been a cornerstone of biological research. For a long time, proteins were considered the prime candidates due to their structural diversity. However, a series of elegant experiments in the mid-20th century definitively demonstrated that it is, in fact, deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) that carries the hereditary information. These experiments, starting with the pioneering work of Frederick Griffith and culminating in the conclusive evidence provided by Hershey and Chase, revolutionized our understanding of genetics and laid the foundation for modern molecular biology. This answer will detail the experimental evidence supporting DNA as the genetic material.

Griffith’s Transformation Experiment (1928)

Frederick Griffith, while working with Streptococcus pneumoniae, observed a phenomenon called transformation. He used two strains of the bacteria: a virulent (S) strain with a polysaccharide capsule, causing pneumonia, and a non-virulent (R) strain lacking the capsule. His experiment involved the following:

  • Injection of S strain: Mice died.
  • Injection of R strain: Mice lived.
  • Injection of heat-killed S strain: Mice lived.
  • Injection of a mixture of heat-killed S strain and live R strain: Mice died, and live S strain bacteria were recovered.

Griffith concluded that some “transforming principle” from the heat-killed S strain had converted the R strain into the virulent S strain. However, he didn’t identify the nature of this principle.

Avery-MacLeod-McCarty Experiment (1944)

Building on Griffith’s work, Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod, and Maclyn McCarty aimed to identify the “transforming principle.” They systematically isolated different components from heat-killed S strain bacteria and tested their ability to transform R strain bacteria.

Their experimental setup involved three sets of experiments:

  • Treatment with protease (enzyme that degrades proteins): Transformation occurred.
  • Treatment with RNase (enzyme that degrades RNA): Transformation occurred.
  • Treatment with DNase (enzyme that degrades DNA): Transformation did not occur.

This experiment demonstrated that DNA, and not protein or RNA, was the transforming principle responsible for the genetic change. This was a crucial step in establishing DNA as the genetic material, although some scientists remained skeptical.

Hershey-Chase Experiment (1952)

Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase provided the most convincing evidence that DNA, not protein, is the genetic material. They used bacteriophages (viruses that infect bacteria) to demonstrate this. Bacteriophages consist of only DNA and protein.

Their experiment utilized radioactive isotopes:

  • 32P (radioactive phosphorus): Used to label DNA, as phosphorus is present in DNA but not in protein.
  • 35S (radioactive sulfur): Used to label protein, as sulfur is present in protein but not in DNA.

The experiment proceeded as follows:

  • Bacteriophages were grown in media containing 32P and 35S to label their DNA and protein, respectively.
  • The labeled phages were allowed to infect E. coli bacteria.
  • After infection, the phage particles were removed by agitation, and the bacterial cells were analyzed.

Results:

  • The bacterial cells contained most of the 32P (DNA) inside.
  • The bacterial cells contained very little 35S (protein).

This conclusively showed that DNA, not protein, enters the bacterial cells during infection and is therefore the genetic material. This experiment effectively resolved the debate and solidified DNA’s role as the carrier of genetic information.

Further Evidence

Later, Chargaff’s rules (1950) regarding the base composition of DNA (A=T and G=C) and the X-ray diffraction studies by Rosalind Franklin and Maurice Wilkins (1952) provided further insights into the structure of DNA, ultimately leading to the discovery of the double helix structure by Watson and Crick (1953).

Conclusion

The experimental evidence, starting with Griffith’s transformation experiment and culminating in the definitive Hershey-Chase experiment, unequivocally established DNA as the genetic material. These experiments not only revolutionized our understanding of heredity but also paved the way for the development of molecular biology, genetic engineering, and modern biotechnology. The identification of DNA as the genetic material remains a cornerstone of biological science, continuing to drive advancements in medicine, agriculture, and our understanding of life itself.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Genetic Material
A substance capable of carrying information from one generation to the next, and of directing the synthesis of proteins, ultimately determining the characteristics of an organism.
Transformation
A process where exogenous genetic material is introduced into a bacterial cell, resulting in a change in its genetic characteristics.

Key Statistics

The human genome contains approximately 3 billion base pairs of DNA.

Source: National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI) - as of knowledge cutoff 2023

Approximately 99% of the genetic material in humans is identical across individuals.

Source: Genome.gov - as of knowledge cutoff 2023

Examples

Sickle Cell Anemia

Sickle cell anemia is a genetic disorder caused by a mutation in the gene encoding hemoglobin. This demonstrates how a change in DNA sequence can lead to a specific phenotypic effect.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why were proteins initially considered the likely genetic material?

Proteins were thought to be the genetic material due to their complex structures and diverse functions. It was believed that DNA was too simple to carry the vast amount of genetic information required for life.

Topics Covered

BiologyGeneticsDNA StructureMolecular BiologyGenetic Code