UPSC MainsGEOLOGY-PAPER-I201212 Marks150 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q19.

Criteria for selecting suitable building stone

How to Approach

This question requires a focused answer outlining the key properties and tests considered when selecting building stones. The answer should be structured around physical, chemical, and geological characteristics. A systematic approach, perhaps categorizing criteria, will be beneficial. Mentioning specific stone types and their suitability based on these criteria will enhance the response. Focus on durability, strength, and aesthetic qualities.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Building stones have been fundamental to construction throughout history, offering durability and aesthetic appeal. Selecting a suitable building stone is a crucial aspect of civil engineering, impacting the longevity and structural integrity of any edifice. The criteria for selection are multifaceted, encompassing physical, chemical, geological, and aesthetic considerations. A thorough evaluation ensures the stone can withstand environmental stresses, maintain its structural properties, and contribute to the overall architectural design. The choice depends on the intended application – whether it’s for load-bearing walls, cladding, paving, or decorative purposes.

Physical Properties

Physical properties are paramount in determining a stone’s suitability for construction. These include:

  • Strength: Compressive strength is a primary factor. Stones like granite and basalt exhibit high compressive strength, making them ideal for load-bearing structures. Sandstone and limestone have lower strengths and are better suited for cladding or paving.
  • Durability: Resistance to weathering, erosion, and abrasion is crucial. This is assessed through tests like freeze-thaw resistance and abrasion tests.
  • Hardness: Measured using Mohs scale, hardness indicates resistance to scratching and wear.
  • Porosity & Absorption: Lower porosity and water absorption are desirable to prevent damage from freeze-thaw cycles and chemical attack.
  • Specific Gravity: Affects the weight of the structure.

Chemical Properties

Chemical composition influences a stone’s resistance to environmental degradation:

  • Resistance to Acids: Limestone and marble are susceptible to acid rain, requiring protective coatings in polluted environments. Granite and sandstone are more resistant.
  • Presence of Deleterious Substances: The presence of iron pyrite can lead to oxidation and staining. Organic matter can cause discoloration and decay.

Geological Properties

The geological structure and formation of the stone are vital:

  • Grain Size & Texture: Fine-grained stones are generally stronger and more durable than coarse-grained ones.
  • Bedding Planes & Joints: The orientation and spacing of bedding planes and joints influence the stone’s strength and susceptibility to splitting.
  • Freedom from Cracks & Voids: These weaken the stone and provide pathways for water penetration.
  • Type of Stone: Different stone types possess inherent characteristics. Igneous rocks (granite, basalt) are generally strong and durable. Sedimentary rocks (sandstone, limestone) are more porous and less durable. Metamorphic rocks (marble, slate) exhibit varying properties depending on their parent rock and degree of metamorphism.

Testing Procedures

Several tests are employed to evaluate these properties:

Test Purpose
Compressive Strength Test Determines the stone’s ability to withstand compressive loads.
Water Absorption Test Measures the percentage of water absorbed by the stone.
Acid Resistance Test Evaluates the stone’s resistance to acid attack.
Freeze-Thaw Test Assesses the stone’s durability under repeated freezing and thawing cycles.

The Indian Standards (IS) provide guidelines for testing and specifying building stones (e.g., IS 1725-1985 for granite, IS 1726-1985 for sandstone).

Conclusion

Selecting suitable building stone requires a holistic assessment of its physical, chemical, and geological properties. Prioritizing strength, durability, and resistance to environmental factors is crucial for ensuring the longevity and structural integrity of constructions. Employing standardized testing procedures and adhering to relevant Indian Standards are essential for making informed decisions. The optimal choice depends on the specific application and environmental conditions, balancing performance with aesthetic considerations.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Compressive Strength
The capacity of a material or structure to withstand axially directed compressive loads. It is typically measured in megapascals (MPa) or pounds per square inch (psi).
Porosity
A measure of the void space in a material, expressed as a percentage of the total volume. Higher porosity generally leads to lower strength and increased water absorption.

Key Statistics

India is the 5th largest producer of stone and stone products in the world, accounting for approximately 4% of global production (2022 data, Ministry of Mines).

Source: Ministry of Mines, Government of India

Rajasthan accounts for over 80% of India’s total stone production, particularly sandstone and marble (as of 2021-22).

Source: Rajasthan Mines and Minerals Department

Examples

Taj Mahal - Marble Degradation

The Taj Mahal, constructed from white marble, is experiencing degradation due to acid rain and air pollution. This highlights the vulnerability of certain stones to environmental factors and the need for protective measures.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between sandstone and limestone?

Sandstone is a sedimentary rock composed of sand-sized grains, making it more porous and less durable than limestone, which is formed from calcium carbonate and is generally denser.

Topics Covered

GeographyEngineeringGeologyMaterial ScienceCivil Engineering