UPSC MainsZOOLOGY-PAPER-II201220 Marks
Q12.

Differentiate between principles and methods of DNA cloning and whole animal cloning.

How to Approach

This question requires a comparative analysis of two distinct cloning techniques: DNA cloning and whole animal cloning. The answer should begin by defining both techniques, outlining their underlying principles, and then detailing their respective methods. A tabular comparison highlighting key differences will be beneficial. Focus on the scale of cloning (gene vs. organism), the techniques employed (restriction enzymes, PCR vs. SCNT), and the applications of each. The answer should demonstrate a clear understanding of the biological processes involved.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Cloning, in its broadest sense, refers to the creation of a genetically identical copy of a biological entity. However, the term encompasses vastly different techniques depending on whether it involves replicating DNA fragments (DNA cloning) or entire organisms (whole animal cloning). DNA cloning, a cornerstone of molecular biology, has revolutionized genetic research and biotechnology. Whole animal cloning, a more recent development, gained prominence with the birth of Dolly the sheep in 1996, sparking ethical debates and offering potential applications in agriculture and conservation. Understanding the principles and methods underlying each technique is crucial for appreciating their distinct capabilities and limitations.

DNA Cloning: Principles and Methods

DNA cloning involves replicating a specific DNA fragment, typically a gene or a portion of a genome, within a host cell. The fundamental principle relies on the ability of DNA to replicate itself and the use of vectors to carry the desired DNA fragment into the host cell.

Principles of DNA Cloning:

  • Recombinant DNA Technology: Combining DNA from different sources to create a new DNA molecule.
  • Vectors: DNA molecules (plasmids, bacteriophages, viruses) used to carry foreign DNA into host cells.
  • Restriction Enzymes: Enzymes that cut DNA at specific recognition sequences, creating compatible ends for joining DNA fragments.
  • DNA Ligase: An enzyme that joins DNA fragments together by forming phosphodiester bonds.

Methods of DNA Cloning:

  1. Isolation of DNA: Obtaining the desired DNA fragment from a source organism.
  2. Digestion with Restriction Enzymes: Cutting both the DNA fragment and the vector with the same restriction enzyme.
  3. Ligation: Joining the DNA fragment and the vector using DNA ligase to form a recombinant DNA molecule.
  4. Transformation/Transfection: Introducing the recombinant DNA molecule into a host cell (e.g., bacteria, yeast).
  5. Selection: Identifying host cells that have successfully taken up the recombinant DNA molecule (often using antibiotic resistance genes).
  6. Amplification: Allowing the host cells to replicate, thereby amplifying the cloned DNA fragment.

Whole Animal Cloning: Principles and Methods

Whole animal cloning aims to create a genetically identical copy of an entire animal. The most common method, Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer (SCNT), involves transferring the nucleus of a somatic cell (any cell other than a sperm or egg cell) into an enucleated egg cell.

Principles of Whole Animal Cloning:

  • Totipotency: The ability of a single cell to develop into a complete organism. While most somatic cells lose totipotency, their nuclei retain the genetic information necessary for development.
  • Nuclear Reprogramming: The process of resetting the epigenetic state of the somatic cell nucleus to that of an embryonic nucleus.
  • Enucleation: Removing the nucleus from an egg cell.

Methods of Whole Animal Cloning (SCNT):

  1. Isolation of a Somatic Cell: Obtaining a somatic cell from the animal to be cloned.
  2. Enucleation of an Egg Cell: Removing the nucleus from an egg cell.
  3. Nuclear Transfer: Injecting the nucleus of the somatic cell into the enucleated egg cell.
  4. Stimulation of Cell Division: Triggering the egg cell to divide, mimicking fertilization.
  5. Embryo Implantation: Implanting the developing embryo into the uterus of a surrogate mother.
  6. Gestation and Birth: Allowing the embryo to develop to term and giving birth to a clone.

Comparative Analysis

Feature DNA Cloning Whole Animal Cloning
Scale of Cloning Gene/DNA fragment Entire organism
Key Techniques Restriction enzymes, PCR, ligation, transformation SCNT, nuclear reprogramming, embryo transfer
Starting Material DNA fragment Somatic cell & Egg cell
Host Cell Bacteria, yeast, mammalian cells Surrogate mother
Applications Gene therapy, protein production, genetic engineering, research Agriculture (livestock improvement), conservation of endangered species, biomedical research
Efficiency Relatively high Relatively low; often requires many attempts

Conclusion

In conclusion, DNA cloning and whole animal cloning represent distinct applications of cloning technology, differing significantly in their principles, methods, and applications. DNA cloning focuses on replicating specific genetic sequences for research and biotechnology, while whole animal cloning aims to create genetically identical organisms, offering potential benefits in agriculture and conservation but also raising ethical concerns. Continued advancements in reprogramming technologies may improve the efficiency of whole animal cloning, but ethical considerations will remain paramount.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Vector
A DNA molecule used as a vehicle to carry foreign genetic material into another cell, where it can be replicated.
SCNT
Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer - a cloning technique where the nucleus of a somatic cell is transferred into an enucleated egg cell.

Key Statistics

The success rate of SCNT in mammals is typically very low, often less than 5% (as of 2023 data, based on various research publications).

Source: National Geographic - Dolly the Sheep: The First Cloned Mammal (accessed Oct 26, 2023)

The global animal cloning market was valued at USD 4.4 billion in 2022 and is expected to reach USD 11.2 billion by 2030 (Source: Grand View Research, 2023).

Source: Grand View Research (accessed Oct 26, 2023)

Examples

Insulin Production

Human insulin is now routinely produced using DNA cloning technology. The human insulin gene is inserted into bacteria, which then produce large quantities of insulin for treating diabetes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the ethical concerns surrounding whole animal cloning?

Ethical concerns include animal welfare (high failure rates and potential health problems in clones), the potential for misuse (e.g., creating clones for organ harvesting), and the impact on genetic diversity.

Topics Covered

BiologyBiotechnologyDNA CloningAnimal CloningBiotechnology