UPSC MainsGEOLOGY-PAPER-II20137 Marks
Q7.

With suitable examples, discuss the causes behind and effects of pleochroism and birefringence in minerals.

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of optical properties of minerals. The approach should involve defining pleochroism and birefringence, explaining their causes at the atomic level (linking to crystal structure and chemical composition), and illustrating with examples. Structure the answer by first defining the terms, then detailing the causes of each, followed by their effects and illustrative mineral examples. Focus on how these properties are used in mineral identification.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Optical mineralogy is a crucial branch of geology, enabling the identification and characterization of minerals based on their interaction with light. Two fundamental optical properties are pleochroism and birefringence. Pleochroism refers to the phenomenon where a mineral exhibits different colors when viewed from different crystallographic directions, while birefringence is the splitting of a single ray of light into two rays as it passes through the mineral, resulting in double refraction. Both properties are directly related to the mineral’s crystal structure and chemical composition, providing valuable diagnostic tools for geologists.

Pleochroism: Causes and Effects

Pleochroism arises from selective absorption of light wavelengths depending on the direction of light propagation through the mineral. This selective absorption is a consequence of variations in the electronic structure of the mineral along different crystallographic axes.

Causes of Pleochroism

  • Unequal Absorption of Light: Minerals containing transition metal ions (like iron, chromium, vanadium, titanium) exhibit strong pleochroism. These ions have partially filled d-orbitals, which can absorb specific wavelengths of light. The amount of absorption varies depending on the orientation of the light relative to the d-orbital arrangement.
  • Crystal Structure: The crystal structure dictates the arrangement of atoms and the symmetry of the mineral. Minerals with lower symmetry (e.g., monoclinic, triclinic) tend to show more pronounced pleochroism because the electronic environment around the transition metal ions is less uniform in all directions.
  • Chemical Composition: The presence and oxidation state of transition metal ions significantly influence pleochroism. For example, Fe2+ and Fe3+ will exhibit different pleochroic colors.

Effects and Examples of Pleochroism

  • Color Change: The most obvious effect is the change in color observed when a mineral is rotated under polarized light or viewed from different angles.
  • Mineral Identification: Pleochroism is a key diagnostic property used in thin section petrography to identify minerals.
  • Examples:
    • Biotite Mica: Exhibits pleochroism ranging from dark brown to yellowish-brown.
    • Andalusite: Shows distinct pleochroic colors of yellowish-green, reddish-brown, and colorless.
    • Tourmaline: Can display a wide range of pleochroic colors, often used in gemology.

Birefringence: Causes and Effects

Birefringence, also known as double refraction, occurs when a mineral splits a single ray of light into two rays, each traveling at a different velocity. This happens because the refractive index of the mineral varies with the direction of light propagation.

Causes of Birefringence

  • Anisotropy: Birefringence is a direct result of the mineral’s anisotropic nature – meaning its physical properties vary with direction. This anisotropy arises from the non-cubic crystal systems (orthorhombic, monoclinic, triclinic, hexagonal, tetragonal).
  • Refractive Index Variation: The refractive index (a measure of how much light bends when entering a material) is different for different crystallographic directions. This difference (Δn) is the birefringence value.
  • Crystal Structure & Composition: The arrangement of atoms and the chemical composition influence the refractive indices and, consequently, the birefringence.

Effects and Examples of Birefringence

  • Double Images: When looking through a birefringent mineral at an object, two slightly displaced images are observed.
  • Interference Colors: Under polarized light, birefringence produces interference colors, which are bands of color that vary with the mineral’s thickness and orientation. These colors are used for mineral identification and analysis.
  • Examples:
    • Calcite (CaCO3): Exhibits strong birefringence, easily demonstrated by placing a clear calcite crystal over printed text.
    • Quartz (SiO2): Shows moderate birefringence, producing interference colors under polarized light.
    • Feldspars: Display varying degrees of birefringence depending on their composition and crystal structure.
Property Pleochroism Birefringence
Cause Selective absorption of light based on crystallographic direction Variation in refractive index with crystallographic direction (anisotropy)
Effect Change in color with viewing angle Splitting of light into two rays; double refraction; interference colors
Related to Transition metal ions, crystal symmetry Crystal structure, non-cubic systems

Conclusion

Both pleochroism and birefringence are fundamental optical properties of minerals, stemming from their internal atomic structure and chemical composition. These properties are not merely aesthetic curiosities; they are powerful tools for mineral identification, particularly in petrographic analysis. Understanding the causes and effects of these phenomena is essential for geologists studying rock formation, mineral resources, and the Earth’s dynamic processes. Continued advancements in optical microscopy and spectroscopic techniques will further refine our ability to utilize these properties for detailed mineral characterization.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Refractive Index
A measure of how much light bends when entering a material. It is the ratio of the speed of light in a vacuum to the speed of light in the substance.
Anisotropy
The property of being directionally dependent; having different properties in different directions. In the context of minerals, it refers to variations in optical, physical, or chemical properties depending on the crystallographic direction.

Key Statistics

Approximately 90% of all known minerals exhibit birefringence (Deer, Howie & Zussman, 1992).

Source: Deer, W. A., Howie, R. A., & Zussman, J. (1992). An Introduction to the Rock-Forming Minerals. Longman Scientific & Technical.

The maximum birefringence observed in minerals is around 0.4 (e.g., some varieties of nepheline), while the minimum is close to zero in isotropic minerals like garnet (Klein & Dutrow, 2007).

Source: Klein, C., & Dutrow, B. (2007). Manual of Mineral Science. John Wiley & Sons.

Examples

Iceland Spar

Iceland Spar (a variety of calcite) is renowned for its exceptionally strong birefringence. It was historically used to create Nicol prisms, essential components in early polarising microscopes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does temperature affect birefringence?

Generally, increasing temperature decreases birefringence. This is because thermal expansion alters the crystal lattice and reduces the difference in refractive indices.

Topics Covered

GeologyMineralogyOpticsOptical MineralogyCrystallographyLight Interaction