UPSC MainsECONOMICS-PAPER-I201420 Marks
Q24.

Distinguish between single and double factor terms of trade. Explain how far terms of trade of a developing economy would change with technological advancement and economic growth.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of international trade concepts and their application to developing economies. The answer should begin by clearly defining single and double factor terms of trade, highlighting their differences. Subsequently, it needs to analyze how technological advancements and economic growth impact these terms, considering both positive and negative effects. The answer should incorporate relevant examples and demonstrate an understanding of the complexities involved, particularly for developing nations. A structured approach – definition, explanation, impact analysis, and conclusion – is recommended.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Terms of Trade (TOT) represent the relative price of a country’s exports in terms of its imports. It’s a crucial indicator of a nation’s economic well-being. A favorable TOT implies that a country can obtain more imports for a given quantity of exports, boosting its purchasing power. However, the calculation and interpretation of TOT can vary. While a simple calculation exists, economists often distinguish between single and double factor terms of trade to provide a more comprehensive picture. Understanding these distinctions and how they are affected by technological progress and economic growth is vital, especially for developing economies striving for sustainable development.

Understanding Single and Double Factor Terms of Trade

The terms of trade can be calculated in two ways: single factor and double factor.

Single Factor Terms of Trade

This is the simpler calculation, focusing solely on price indices. It is calculated as:

Single Factor Terms of Trade = (Index Number of Export Prices / Index Number of Import Prices) x 100

It measures the percentage change in the relative prices of exports and imports. For example, if the index of export prices increases by 10% while the index of import prices remains constant, the single factor terms of trade improve by 10%.

Double Factor Terms of Trade

The double factor terms of trade consider not only price changes but also changes in the volume of exports and imports. It is calculated as:

Double Factor Terms of Trade = (Value of Exports / Value of Imports) x 100

This provides a more accurate representation of a country’s purchasing power as it accounts for the quantity of goods traded. A rise in export volume, even with stable prices, can improve the double factor terms of trade.

Impact of Technological Advancement and Economic Growth on Terms of Trade of a Developing Economy

Technological advancement and economic growth can significantly alter a developing economy’s terms of trade, with both positive and negative consequences.

Positive Impacts

  • Increased Productivity & Export Competitiveness: Technological advancements can boost productivity in export-oriented industries, leading to lower production costs and increased competitiveness in global markets. This can increase export volumes and potentially improve both single and double factor terms of trade. For example, the Green Revolution in India (1960s-1970s) increased agricultural productivity, boosting rice and wheat exports.
  • Diversification of Exports: Technology can facilitate the diversification of exports beyond primary commodities towards higher-value manufactured goods and services. This reduces dependence on volatile commodity prices and improves terms of trade. Countries like Vietnam have successfully diversified their exports through technological upgrades in manufacturing.
  • Reduced Import Dependence: Economic growth driven by technological innovation can lead to import substitution, reducing reliance on imported goods and improving the terms of trade. Development of domestic pharmaceutical industries in India is a prime example.

Negative Impacts

  • Dutch Disease: Rapid economic growth in one sector (often resource-based) due to technological advancements can lead to the appreciation of the real exchange rate, making other export sectors less competitive. This phenomenon, known as “Dutch Disease,” can worsen the terms of trade for non-booming sectors.
  • Increased Demand for Imports: Economic growth often leads to increased demand for capital goods, intermediate inputs, and consumer goods, potentially increasing import volumes and worsening the terms of trade if export growth doesn’t keep pace.
  • Technological Dependence & Intellectual Property Costs: Developing countries often rely on imported technology, leading to payments for intellectual property rights and royalties, which can negatively impact the balance of payments and terms of trade.
  • Commodity Price Volatility: While technology can improve productivity, many developing economies remain heavily reliant on commodity exports. Global commodity price fluctuations, often driven by factors beyond their control, can significantly impact their terms of trade, even with technological improvements.

Specific Considerations for Developing Economies

Developing economies often face unique challenges. Their terms of trade are frequently vulnerable to:

  • Primary Commodity Dependence: Many developing countries rely heavily on exporting primary commodities, which are subject to price volatility and declining terms of trade over the long run (Prebisch-Singer hypothesis).
  • Limited Bargaining Power: Developing countries often have limited bargaining power in international trade negotiations, hindering their ability to secure favorable terms of trade.
  • Infrastructure Deficiencies: Poor infrastructure can limit the benefits of technological advancements and hinder export competitiveness.

Table: Impact of Technological Advancement & Economic Growth on Terms of Trade

Factor Positive Impact Negative Impact
Productivity Increased export competitiveness, higher export volumes May not offset increased import demand
Diversification Shift to higher-value exports, reduced commodity dependence Requires significant investment and skill development
Exchange Rate Can remain competitive with productivity gains Potential for real exchange rate appreciation ("Dutch Disease")
Technology Access Improved production processes, new export opportunities Dependence on imported technology, royalty payments

Conclusion

In conclusion, the impact of technological advancement and economic growth on the terms of trade of a developing economy is complex and multifaceted. While technology offers opportunities to enhance productivity, diversify exports, and reduce import dependence, it also presents challenges like Dutch Disease, increased import demand, and technological dependence. Successfully navigating these complexities requires strategic investments in education, infrastructure, and research & development, alongside policies that promote export diversification and strengthen bargaining power in international trade. A nuanced understanding of both single and double factor terms of trade is crucial for formulating effective trade policies and achieving sustainable economic development.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Prebisch-Singer Hypothesis
This hypothesis states that the terms of trade for primary commodity-exporting countries tend to deteriorate over time relative to those of industrialized countries.
Real Exchange Rate
The real exchange rate is the exchange rate adjusted for differences in price levels between countries. It reflects the relative purchasing power of currencies.

Key Statistics

In 2022, India's merchandise exports were valued at $451.07 billion, while imports were $709.64 billion, resulting in a trade deficit of $258.57 billion. (Source: Department of Commerce, Government of India - Knowledge Cutoff 2023)

Source: Department of Commerce, Government of India

According to UNCTAD, Least Developed Countries (LDCs) experienced a decline in their terms of trade by approximately 1% per year between 2000 and 2018. (Source: UNCTAD, Trade and Development Report 2019 - Knowledge Cutoff 2023)

Source: UNCTAD

Examples

Bangladesh's Garment Industry

Bangladesh's ready-made garment (RMG) industry has experienced significant growth due to technological upgrades and access to global markets. This has boosted export earnings and improved the country's terms of trade, although it remains vulnerable to global demand fluctuations.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does exchange rate policy affect terms of trade?

A devaluation of a country's currency can improve its terms of trade by making its exports cheaper and imports more expensive. However, it can also lead to inflation and reduce purchasing power.