Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
The statement "Either of these three answers is incorrect" presents a grammatical and logical challenge. While seemingly straightforward, the phrasing contains an error related to the use of 'either' and the subsequent verb agreement. The core issue lies in the mismatch between the quantifier 'either' and the plural noun 'answers', leading to an incorrect grammatical construction. This type of question assesses a candidate’s attention to detail and their grasp of fundamental English grammar rules, crucial for effective communication in the UPSC examination.
Identifying the Error
The primary error in the sentence is the incorrect use of 'either' with a plural noun ('answers'). 'Either' is used to refer to one of two options, implying a binary choice. When dealing with more than two options, 'one of' should be used. Furthermore, the verb 'is' does not agree with the implied plural subject ('one of the answers').
Correcting the Sentence
The sentence should be corrected to: "Either one of these three answers is incorrect" or, more naturally, "One of these three answers is incorrect." The latter option avoids the awkwardness of using 'either' with a plural noun and maintains grammatical correctness.
Detailed Explanation
- Quantifiers and Subject-Verb Agreement: Quantifiers like 'either', 'neither', 'each', and 'every' often lead to errors in subject-verb agreement. When these quantifiers are followed by 'of', the verb agrees with the noun that follows 'of'.
- 'Either' vs. 'One of': 'Either' implies a choice between two things. When there are more than two options, 'one of' is the appropriate quantifier.
- Sentence Structure: The original sentence attempts to combine the concept of a limited choice ('either') with a plural set of options ('three answers'), creating a logical inconsistency.
Illustrative Examples
Consider these examples to further clarify the correct usage:
- Correct: "Either John or Mary is going to the party." (Choice between two people)
- Correct: "One of the students is absent today." (Singular subject after 'one of')
- Incorrect: "Either of the students are absent today." (Incorrect verb agreement)
Potential UPSC Relevance
While this question appears simple, it highlights the importance of precise language in the UPSC examination. Candidates are expected to write clear, concise, and grammatically correct answers. Errors in grammar and sentence construction can detract from the overall quality of the response and potentially affect the score. The ability to identify and correct such errors demonstrates a strong command of the English language, a vital skill for effective communication in the civil services.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the sentence "Either of these three answers is incorrect" is flawed due to the incorrect usage of 'either' with a plural noun and the resulting subject-verb disagreement. Correcting it to "One of these three answers is incorrect" resolves both the grammatical and logical issues. This seemingly minor error underscores the importance of meticulous attention to detail and a strong foundation in English grammar for UPSC aspirants.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.