UPSC MainsENGLISH-LITERATURE-PAPER-I201415 Marks
Q22.

Pride and Prejudice is on the surface a novel depicting genteel life, but the motive force is a desperate man-hunt for social survival. Examine.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of *Pride and Prejudice*. The approach should be to initially acknowledge the novel’s depiction of genteel society, then systematically dismantle that surface reading to reveal the underlying anxieties about economic and social survival driving the characters’ actions. Focus on marriage as a key economic transaction, the limited opportunities for women, and the societal pressures surrounding status and inheritance. Structure the answer by examining character motivations through this lens, providing specific examples from the text.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Jane Austen’s *Pride and Prejudice*, published in 1813, is often celebrated for its witty portrayal of English landed gentry and the intricacies of courtship. However, to view it solely as a romantic comedy or a depiction of genteel life is to overlook a crucial undercurrent: the pervasive anxiety surrounding economic security and social standing in a society where inheritance laws and limited opportunities for women made marriage a near-necessity for survival. This essay will argue that beneath the veneer of polite society, *Pride and Prejudice* is fundamentally a novel driven by a desperate, often unspoken, man-hunt for social and economic survival.

The Economic Imperative of Marriage

The novel’s central plot revolves around the marriage prospects of the Bennet sisters. Their mother, Mrs. Bennet, is relentlessly focused on securing advantageous matches for her daughters, not out of romantic inclination, but out of sheer economic necessity. The Bennet estate is entailed, meaning it can only be inherited by a male heir – Mr. Collins. This precarious situation leaves the Bennet women vulnerable to poverty and social ruin upon their father’s death. Marriage, therefore, isn’t presented as a matter of love, but as a pragmatic solution to a looming economic crisis.

Character Motivations as Driven by Survival

Each character’s actions can be interpreted through the lens of social and economic survival:

  • Elizabeth Bennet: While initially rejecting Mr. Darcy based on pride and prejudice, her eventual acceptance stems, in part, from recognizing the security and elevated social status his wealth and position offer. Her initial resistance highlights the tension between genuine affection and societal expectations.
  • Mr. Darcy: His initial disdain for Elizabeth is rooted in her family’s lower social standing and lack of fortune. His eventual proposal is not merely a declaration of love, but also a calculated move to elevate his social standing by associating with a respectable, though less wealthy, family.
  • Charlotte Lucas: Her pragmatic marriage to Mr. Collins, despite his obsequiousness and lack of charm, is a stark illustration of the desperation women faced. Charlotte prioritizes security and a home over romantic fulfillment, recognizing her limited options as a woman of modest means.
  • Mr. Wickham: He represents the predatory side of this social survival game. He attempts to exploit the vulnerabilities of young women like Lydia Bennet for financial gain, demonstrating the lengths to which some will go to secure their own position.
  • Lady Catherine de Bourgh: Her attempts to prevent Elizabeth and Darcy’s marriage are driven by a desire to maintain the social hierarchy and ensure her daughter’s (Anne’s) advantageous match with Darcy.

Social Hierarchy and the Pursuit of Status

Austen meticulously depicts the rigid social hierarchy of Regency England. Status, determined by wealth, lineage, and connections, dictated one’s opportunities and social acceptance. Characters constantly assess each other based on these criteria. The novel highlights the anxieties of those attempting to climb the social ladder, like the Bingley sisters, and the desperation of those trying to maintain their position, like Lady Catherine. The balls and social gatherings are not merely opportunities for romance, but rather marketplaces where social capital is exchanged and assessed.

The Limited Opportunities for Women

The novel underscores the severely limited opportunities available to women in the early 19th century. Without independent wealth or a male relative to provide for them, women were largely dependent on marriage for economic security. This dependence created a sense of urgency and vulnerability, driving many of the characters’ actions. The lack of viable career options for women meant that marriage was not simply a personal choice, but a social and economic imperative. This is particularly evident in the desperation of Mrs. Bennet and the pragmatic decision of Charlotte Lucas.

Inheritance Laws and Entailment

The system of entailment, as exemplified by the Bennet estate, played a significant role in shaping the characters’ motivations. Entailment restricted inheritance to male heirs, leaving women and daughters vulnerable to financial hardship. This legal framework created a sense of urgency and desperation, particularly for families like the Bennets, where the lack of a male heir threatened their social and economic standing. The knowledge of the entailment hangs over the entire narrative, influencing the characters’ decisions and actions.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while *Pride and Prejudice* presents a charming depiction of English society, a closer examination reveals a more complex and unsettling reality. The novel’s surface-level focus on romance and social etiquette masks a deeper exploration of the anxieties surrounding economic security and social survival. Marriage is not portrayed as a purely romantic endeavor, but as a strategic transaction driven by necessity and societal pressures. Austen’s masterful portrayal of these underlying motivations elevates the novel beyond a simple love story, establishing it as a keen social commentary on the precarious position of women and the relentless pursuit of status in Regency England.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Entailment
A legal restriction on the inheritance of property, typically ensuring it passes only to male heirs, preventing it from being divided or sold.
Primogeniture
The right of the eldest son to inherit all of his parent’s property, a common practice in Regency England that exacerbated the economic vulnerability of daughters.

Key Statistics

In the early 19th century, approximately 70% of the English population lived in poverty or near-poverty. (Source: Asa Briggs, *Victorian People*, 1954)

Source: Asa Briggs, *Victorian People*, 1954

The average income for a woman in England in the early 19th century was approximately one-third that of a man. (Source: Deborah Nord, *The Victorian Mind*, 1999)

Source: Deborah Nord, *The Victorian Mind*, 1999

Examples

The plight of the Brontë sisters

The Brontë sisters, like the Bennet sisters, faced limited opportunities due to their gender and social standing. They relied on writing as a means of potential income, highlighting the economic constraints placed upon women in the 19th century.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was Austen herself affected by these economic pressures?

Yes, Austen’s family experienced financial difficulties after her father’s death, and she and her sister Cassandra relied on the generosity of their brothers for support. This personal experience likely informed her portrayal of the economic anxieties faced by women in her novels.

Topics Covered

LiteratureNovelSociety19th CenturySocial ClassMarriage