UPSC MainsGENERAL-STUDIES-PAPER-III201412 Marks200 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q18.

How does illegal transborder migration pose a threat to India's security? Discuss the strategies to curb this, bringing out the factors which give impetus to such migration.

How to Approach

This question requires a multi-faceted answer. First, define illegal transborder migration and its scope. Then, detail the security threats it poses – focusing on internal security, economic security, and potential for exploitation by state/non-state actors. Finally, discuss strategies to curb it, linking them to the root causes of migration. Structure the answer into Introduction, Body (Threats & Strategies), and Conclusion. Include relevant examples and data to strengthen the response.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Illegal transborder migration, referring to the movement of individuals across international borders in violation of immigration laws, is a growing concern globally and particularly for India. Driven by a complex interplay of economic disparities, political instability, and social factors, it presents a significant challenge to India’s security apparatus. Recent instances of Rohingya refugee influx and increased border skirmishes highlight the urgency of addressing this issue. While humanitarian concerns are paramount, the potential for security breaches necessitates a comprehensive and robust response.

Threats Posed by Illegal Transborder Migration

Illegal migration poses a multi-dimensional threat to India’s security:

  • Internal Security: Infiltration can lead to demographic changes in sensitive border areas, potentially altering the socio-political landscape and fueling local tensions. The presence of undocumented migrants can also strain law enforcement resources and create opportunities for criminal activities.
  • Economic Security: Influx of cheap labor can depress wages and displace local workers, leading to economic hardship and social unrest. It also puts a strain on public resources like healthcare and education.
  • Exploitation & Radicalization: Vulnerable migrants are susceptible to exploitation by human traffickers, criminal gangs, and extremist organizations. This can lead to radicalization and the potential for terrorist activities. The porous Indo-Bangladesh border is particularly vulnerable to this.
  • Spread of Diseases: Unscreened migrants can carry infectious diseases, posing a public health risk.
  • Border Disputes & Cross-Border Crime: Increased migration can exacerbate existing border disputes and facilitate cross-border crime, including smuggling of arms, drugs, and counterfeit currency.

Factors Impetus to Illegal Transborder Migration

Several factors contribute to illegal transborder migration towards India:

  • Economic Disparity: Significant wage gaps between India and neighboring countries like Bangladesh, Myanmar, and Nepal drive economic migration.
  • Political Instability & Persecution: Political unrest, ethnic conflicts, and religious persecution in countries like Myanmar (Rohingya crisis) and Bangladesh force people to seek refuge in India.
  • Natural Disasters: Floods, cyclones, and other natural disasters displace populations, leading to migration.
  • Porous Borders: India shares long and often porous borders with several countries, making it difficult to effectively monitor and control migration.
  • Lack of Documentation: Many migrants lack proper documentation, making them vulnerable to exploitation and hindering their integration into society.

Strategies to Curb Illegal Transborder Migration

A multi-pronged strategy is required to effectively curb illegal transborder migration:

  • Border Management: Strengthening border infrastructure, including fencing, surveillance technology (drones, sensors), and increased patrolling. The Border Area Development Programme (BADP) needs to be effectively implemented.
  • International Cooperation: Bilateral agreements with neighboring countries to address the root causes of migration, facilitate safe and orderly migration, and enhance border cooperation. The India-Bangladesh border management agreement is a key example.
  • Identification & Deportation: Establishing a robust system for identifying and deporting illegal migrants, while ensuring due process and respecting human rights.
  • Addressing Root Causes: Investing in development assistance to neighboring countries to address economic disparities and political instability.
  • Awareness Campaigns: Raising awareness among vulnerable populations about the risks of illegal migration and the dangers of human trafficking.
  • Strengthening Law Enforcement: Enhancing the capacity of law enforcement agencies to combat human trafficking and cross-border crime.
  • National Register of Citizens (NRC): While controversial, the NRC exercise in Assam aimed to identify illegal immigrants. Its implementation and legal challenges require careful consideration.

Strategy Implementation Agency Challenges
Border Fencing BSF Difficult terrain, cost, environmental concerns
Bilateral Agreements MEA, MHA Political sensitivities, lack of trust
Deportation MHA, State Police Human rights concerns, legal challenges

Conclusion

Illegal transborder migration presents a complex security challenge for India, demanding a holistic and nuanced approach. While strengthening border security is crucial, addressing the underlying socio-economic and political factors driving migration is equally important. Effective international cooperation, coupled with a humane and rights-based approach to migration management, is essential to mitigate the threats and harness the potential benefits of migration. A long-term solution requires a collaborative effort involving various stakeholders, including government agencies, civil society organizations, and international partners.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Human Trafficking
The recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of the threat or use of force, or other forms of coercion, for the purpose of exploitation.
Demographic Change
Alterations in the composition of a population, including size, age structure, and distribution, often resulting from migration patterns.

Key Statistics

As per the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) data, 2022, a total of 63,896 cases of crimes against women were registered under the Immoral Trafficking Act.

Source: NCRB, 2022

According to a 2021 report by the United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UNDESA), India is projected to surpass China as the world’s most populous country by 2023.

Source: UNDESA, 2021

Examples

Rohingya Refugee Crisis

The influx of Rohingya refugees from Myanmar into India, particularly in Jammu and Kashmir and Delhi, has raised concerns about potential security risks and strain on resources.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a refugee and an illegal immigrant?

A refugee is someone who has been forced to flee their country due to persecution, war, or violence, and is entitled to international protection. An illegal immigrant is someone who enters a country without proper authorization.

Topics Covered

SecuritySocial IssuesInternational RelationsBorder SecurityMigration PolicyHuman TraffickingNational Security