UPSC MainsGEOGRAPHY-PAPER-II201415 Marks
Q23.

Differentiate between the 'intensity' and 'magnitude' of an earthquake and explain its varying impact in different parts of India.

How to Approach

This question requires a clear understanding of seismological concepts – intensity and magnitude – and their differential impact across India. The answer should begin by defining both terms, highlighting their differences. Then, it should analyze how varying geological structures, population density, building codes, and disaster preparedness influence the impact of earthquakes in different regions of India (e.g., Himalayan region, Indo-Gangetic Plain, Peninsular India). A structured approach using regional examples will be beneficial.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Earthquakes are among the most devastating natural hazards, posing a significant threat to life and property. Understanding the characteristics of earthquakes, particularly the distinction between ‘intensity’ and ‘magnitude’, is crucial for effective disaster management. India, being situated in a seismically active region, is vulnerable to frequent earthquakes. Recent events like the Sikkim earthquake (2011) and the Gujarat earthquake (2001) underscore the need for a nuanced understanding of earthquake impacts. This answer will differentiate between earthquake intensity and magnitude and explain how their effects vary across different parts of India.

Differentiating Intensity and Magnitude

While often used interchangeably, ‘intensity’ and ‘magnitude’ represent distinct aspects of an earthquake.

  • Magnitude: This is a quantitative measure of the energy released at the earthquake’s source (hypocenter). It is typically measured using the Richter scale (though the Moment Magnitude Scale is now preferred for larger earthquakes). It’s a single value for each earthquake.
  • Intensity: This is a qualitative measure of the shaking felt at a specific location. It depends on factors like magnitude, distance from the epicenter, local geological conditions, and building construction. Intensity is assessed using scales like the Modified Mercalli Intensity Scale, which assigns Roman numerals (I to XII) based on observed effects.

Therefore, magnitude describes the *size* of the earthquake, while intensity describes its *effects* at a given place.

Varying Impact of Earthquakes in Different Parts of India

India’s diverse geological landscape and varying levels of preparedness lead to significantly different earthquake impacts across its regions.

1. Himalayan Region (Seismic Zone V)

This region, including states like Jammu & Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Sikkim, and parts of Arunachal Pradesh, is the most seismically active due to the ongoing collision of the Indian and Eurasian plates.

  • Geology: Highly fractured and unstable geological formations amplify seismic waves.
  • Building Construction: Traditional construction methods, often using stone and wood, are vulnerable to collapse.
  • Impact: High intensity earthquakes are frequent, leading to widespread damage and landslides. The 2015 Nepal earthquake had significant repercussions in bordering Indian states.

2. Indo-Gangetic Plain (Seismic Zone III & IV)

This densely populated region, encompassing states like Punjab, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, and Bihar, is susceptible to moderate to high-intensity earthquakes.

  • Geology: Alluvial soil amplifies seismic waves, increasing the risk of liquefaction and ground failure.
  • Building Construction: Multi-story buildings constructed without adhering to seismic-resistant building codes are particularly vulnerable.
  • Impact: High population density exacerbates the impact, leading to a large number of casualties. The 1934 Bihar earthquake (8.0 magnitude) caused widespread devastation.

3. Peninsular India (Seismic Zone II & III)

States like Maharashtra, Gujarat, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, and Andhra Pradesh experience relatively fewer earthquakes compared to the Himalayan region, but are still vulnerable.

  • Geology: Stable, ancient crystalline rocks generally reduce seismic wave amplification. However, intraplate faults exist.
  • Building Construction: Modern construction practices are more common, but older buildings may lack seismic resistance.
  • Impact: Earthquakes in this region, while less frequent, can still cause significant damage due to high population density and industrial infrastructure. The 2001 Gujarat earthquake (7.7 magnitude) demonstrated the vulnerability of even relatively stable regions.

4. Coastal Regions (Seismic Zone III & IV)

Coastal areas are vulnerable to tsunamis triggered by underwater earthquakes, in addition to the direct effects of ground shaking.

  • Geology: Sedimentary deposits and proximity to the sea increase the risk of liquefaction and tsunami inundation.
  • Impact: The 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami highlighted the vulnerability of coastal communities.
Region Seismic Zone Geological Characteristics Building Vulnerability Typical Impact
Himalayan Region V Fractured, unstable Traditional, vulnerable High intensity, landslides
Indo-Gangetic Plain III-IV Alluvial soil, liquefaction risk Non-seismic resistant buildings Widespread damage, high casualties
Peninsular India II-III Stable crystalline rocks Variable, older buildings vulnerable Localized damage, infrastructure disruption

Conclusion

In conclusion, while earthquake magnitude represents the energy released, intensity reflects the actual impact experienced at a location. India’s varied geological settings and construction practices result in significantly different earthquake impacts across its regions. Strengthening seismic monitoring networks, enforcing stringent building codes, promoting disaster preparedness, and investing in public awareness campaigns are crucial for mitigating earthquake risks and building a more resilient India. A holistic approach integrating scientific understanding with effective governance is essential for minimizing the devastating consequences of these natural disasters.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Hypocenter
The point within the Earth where an earthquake rupture starts. It is also known as the focus.
Seismic Zone
Areas categorized based on their susceptibility to earthquakes, ranging from Zone II (least vulnerable) to Zone V (most vulnerable).

Key Statistics

Approximately 59% of India’s land area is vulnerable to earthquakes of moderate to high intensity (National Disaster Management Authority, NDMA, 2019).

Source: NDMA

India experiences approximately 20,000 earthquakes annually, most of which are of low intensity (Earthquake Monitoring Research Centre, 2023 - knowledge cutoff).

Source: Earthquake Monitoring Research Centre

Examples

Latur Earthquake (1993)

The 1993 Latur earthquake in Maharashtra (6.4 magnitude) demonstrated that even regions considered relatively stable can experience devastating earthquakes, highlighting the need for preparedness across the country.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can earthquakes be predicted?

Currently, accurate earthquake prediction remains a significant scientific challenge. While scientists can identify areas prone to earthquakes and assess long-term seismic risk, predicting the exact time, location, and magnitude of an earthquake is not yet possible.

Topics Covered

GeographyDisaster ManagementSeismologyIndian GeographyDisaster Mitigation