UPSC MainsGEOGRAPHY-PAPER-II201415 Marks
Q5.

Discuss the problems and prospects of National Waterway No. 1.

How to Approach

This question requires a balanced discussion of the challenges and opportunities associated with National Waterway No. 1 (NW-1). The answer should begin by briefly describing NW-1, then systematically analyze the problems related to its development (technical, financial, environmental, logistical) and subsequently discuss its prospects (economic benefits, connectivity, trade). A structured approach, utilizing headings and subheadings, will enhance clarity. Include relevant data, schemes, and examples to support the arguments.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

National Waterways (NWs) are navigable rivers and canals crucial for transportation, offering a cost-effective and environmentally sustainable alternative to road and rail. National Waterway No. 1 (NW-1), declared in 1985, is the longest waterway in India, stretching 1620 km along the Ganga-Bhagirathi-Hooghly river system, from Allahabad (Prayagraj) to Haldia. Despite its potential, NW-1 faces significant hurdles in realizing its full potential. The recent focus on ‘Jal Marg Vikas Project’ aims to address these issues and unlock the economic benefits of this vital waterway. This answer will discuss the problems and prospects of NW-1, providing a comprehensive overview of its current status and future outlook.

Problems Facing National Waterway No. 1

Despite being the longest NW in India, NW-1 faces numerous challenges hindering its efficient operation and development.

1. Navigational Challenges

  • Shallow Draft & Fluctuating Water Levels: The Ganga river experiences significant seasonal variations in water levels, leading to a shallow draft (depth of water required for a vessel to float). This restricts the movement of larger vessels, especially during the dry season.
  • Siltation: Heavy siltation in the riverbed reduces the navigable depth and requires frequent dredging.
  • Riverbank Erosion: Erosion along the riverbanks poses a threat to infrastructure and navigation.
  • Obstacles: Presence of bridges with low vertical clearance, unplanned structures, and natural obstacles like sandbanks impede smooth navigation.

2. Infrastructure Deficiencies

  • Limited Terminals: Insufficient number of well-equipped terminals for cargo handling and passenger movement. As of 2023, only a few terminals like Varanasi, Sahibganj, and Haldia are operational.
  • Lack of Navigation Aids: Inadequate navigational aids like buoys, beacons, and electronic charts hamper safe and efficient navigation.
  • Connectivity Issues: Poor last-mile connectivity to road and rail networks limits the seamless transfer of cargo.

3. Financial Constraints

  • High Dredging Costs: Maintaining a navigable depth requires continuous dredging, which is expensive and environmentally sensitive.
  • Investment Requirements: Developing infrastructure, procuring vessels, and implementing the Jal Marg Vikas Project require substantial financial investment.
  • Private Sector Participation: Attracting private sector investment has been challenging due to perceived risks and uncertainties.

4. Environmental Concerns

  • Dredging Impacts: Dredging can disrupt aquatic ecosystems, affect water quality, and impact biodiversity.
  • Pollution: Industrial and domestic effluents discharged into the Ganga pollute the waterway and pose health risks.
  • Impact on River Ecology: Increased vessel traffic can disturb the river's natural flow and affect aquatic life.

Prospects of National Waterway No. 1

Despite the challenges, NW-1 holds immense potential for economic development and improved connectivity.

1. Economic Benefits

  • Reduced Transportation Costs: Water transport is significantly cheaper than road and rail, reducing logistics costs for businesses.
  • Trade Facilitation: NW-1 can facilitate the movement of bulk cargo like coal, cement, food grains, and fertilizers, boosting trade and commerce.
  • Industrial Development: Development of industrial clusters along the waterway can stimulate economic growth and create employment opportunities.
  • Tourism Potential: Cruise tourism on the Ganga can generate revenue and promote cultural heritage.

2. Connectivity Enhancement

  • Linking Major Ports: NW-1 connects major ports like Haldia and Kolkata with inland destinations, improving connectivity and reducing transit times.
  • Multi-Modal Transport: Integration with road and rail networks through intermodal terminals creates a seamless transportation system.
  • Regional Development: Improved connectivity can spur economic development in the hinterland regions along the Ganga basin.

3. Jal Marg Vikas Project (JMVP)

Launched in 2014, the JMVP is a World Bank-funded project aimed at developing NW-1. Key components include:

  • Dredging: Ensuring a navigable depth of 3 meters.
  • Terminal Development: Constructing multi-modal terminals at strategic locations.
  • Navigation Aids: Installing modern navigation aids.
  • Riverbank Protection: Implementing measures to prevent erosion.

4. Government Initiatives

  • Sagarmala Programme: Synergizes with the Sagarmala Programme to promote port-led development and enhance connectivity.
  • Inland Waterways Authority of India (IWAI): IWAI is responsible for the development and regulation of NWs in India.
Parameter Current Status (as of late 2023) Target (JMVP)
Navigable Depth Varies significantly; often less than 2 meters 3 meters
Operational Terminals Varanasi, Sahibganj, Haldia (limited capacity) More than 20 multi-modal terminals
Cargo Traffic Relatively low; around 3-5 million tonnes annually 80-100 million tonnes annually

Conclusion

National Waterway No. 1 presents a significant opportunity to transform India’s transportation landscape. While challenges related to navigability, infrastructure, and environmental sustainability remain, the Jal Marg Vikas Project and supportive government policies are paving the way for its development. Realizing the full potential of NW-1 requires sustained investment, effective implementation of the JMVP, and a holistic approach that addresses environmental concerns and ensures seamless connectivity with other modes of transport. A successful NW-1 will not only boost economic growth but also contribute to a more sustainable and efficient transportation system for India.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Draft
The vertical distance between the waterline and the lowest point of the hull of a ship; crucial for determining if a waterway is navigable for a particular vessel.
Multi-Modal Terminal
A transport hub that facilitates the transfer of goods between different modes of transport, such as waterways, roads, and railways, creating a seamless logistics chain.

Key Statistics

The Inland Waterways Authority of India (IWAI) estimates that utilizing NW-1 to its full potential could reduce logistics costs by 15-20%.

Source: IWAI Annual Report (2022-23)

As of 2023, the total cargo movement on all National Waterways in India is approximately 95 million tonnes, with NW-1 accounting for a significant portion.

Source: Ministry of Ports, Shipping and Waterways (Data as of November 2023)

Examples

Varanasi Terminal

The Varanasi Multi-Modal Terminal, inaugurated in 2018, is a key component of the JMVP. It facilitates the movement of cargo between Varanasi and Kolkata, reducing transit time and costs for local businesses.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is dredging a continuous requirement on NW-1?

The Ganga river carries a significant amount of silt, especially during the monsoon season. This silt deposits in the riverbed, reducing the navigable depth. Continuous dredging is necessary to maintain a minimum draft for vessel movement.

Topics Covered

GeographyEconomyTransportationInfrastructureWater Resources