UPSC MainsHISTORY-PAPER-I201420 Marks
Q3.

Review critically the evolution of different schools of art in the Indian subcontinent between the second century BCE and the third century CE, and evaluate the socio-religious factors responsible for it.

How to Approach

This question requires a chronological and thematic understanding of Indian art schools from the 2nd century BCE to the 3rd century CE. The answer should trace the evolution of major schools like Gandhara, Mathura, and Sanchi/Bharhut, highlighting their distinct characteristics. Crucially, it demands a critical analysis of the socio-religious factors – Buddhism, Jainism, and early Hinduism – that shaped these artistic expressions. Structure the answer chronologically, dedicating sections to each school, followed by a discussion of the influencing factors. Include comparative analysis where possible.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The period between the 2nd century BCE and the 3rd century CE witnessed a flourishing of artistic activity in the Indian subcontinent, largely spurred by the patronage of the Mauryan, Shunga, Satavahana, and Kushan empires, and crucially, the rise of new religious ideologies. This era saw the emergence of distinct art schools, each reflecting a unique blend of indigenous traditions and foreign influences. The art of this period wasn’t merely aesthetic; it served as a powerful medium for propagating religious doctrines and reinforcing socio-political ideologies. A critical review of these schools necessitates understanding their stylistic evolution alongside the socio-religious context that fostered them.

Early Developments: The Mauryan Period & Proto-Art (2nd Century BCE)

The Mauryan period, particularly under Ashoka, laid the foundation for monumental art. The use of polished Mauryan stone pillars, like those at Sarnath and Lauriya Nandangarh, demonstrate early sculptural skill. However, this art was largely didactic, focusing on conveying Ashokan edicts rather than elaborate artistic expression. The Yaksha and Yakshini figures found at these sites represent early examples of Indian sculpture, influenced by indigenous folk traditions.

The Sanchi & Bharhut Schools (2nd-1st Century BCE)

Emerging as early centers of Buddhist art, Sanchi and Bharhut represent the earliest phase of stone sculpture associated with Buddhism.

  • Sanchi: Characterized by its stupas (Great Stupa I), toranas (gateways), and railings, Sanchi exhibits a relatively conservative style. The carvings depict Jataka tales and scenes from the Buddha’s life, with a focus on narrative clarity and symbolic representation.
  • Bharhut: Bharhut, while also Buddhist, displays a more dynamic and vigorous style. The figures are more robust and the compositions more crowded. It also features more explicit depictions of violence and eroticism compared to Sanchi.
These schools were patronized by the Shunga dynasty and merchant guilds, reflecting the growing influence of Buddhism and commercial activity.

The Gandhara School (1st Century BCE – 3rd Century CE)

Located in present-day Pakistan and Afghanistan, the Gandhara school represents a unique fusion of Greco-Roman, Persian, and Indian artistic traditions.

  • Influence: The Hellenistic influence is evident in the realistic depiction of human figures, drapery, and facial features. Gandhara art often portrays the Buddha in a human form with curly hair, a muscular physique, and Roman-style clothing.
  • Material: Gandhara primarily used schist, a grey stone, allowing for intricate carvings.
  • Key Features: Emphasis on realism, narrative detail, and the depiction of the Buddha as a god-like figure.
The Kushan empire played a crucial role in the development of Gandhara art, providing both patronage and a cosmopolitan environment.

The Mathura School (1st Century BCE – 3rd Century CE)

Contemporaneous with Gandhara, the Mathura school developed in the region around Mathura, Uttar Pradesh. It differed significantly from Gandhara in its aesthetic and philosophical approach.

  • Indigenous Roots: Mathura art drew heavily on indigenous traditions, particularly the Yaksha and Yakshini cults.
  • Stylistic Features: Figures are characterized by their robust physicality, sensuality, and a focus on volume and mass. The Buddha is depicted with a heavier build and simpler drapery.
  • Material: Red sandstone was the primary medium.
The Mathura school was patronized by the Kushans and local rulers, and it played a vital role in the development of early Hindu iconography, alongside Buddhist imagery.

Comparative Analysis: Gandhara vs. Mathura

Feature Gandhara School Mathura School
Influence Greco-Roman, Persian Indigenous (Yaksha-Yakshini)
Style Realistic, refined Robust, sensual
Material Schist Red Sandstone
Buddha’s Depiction Human-like, draped Heavier build, simpler drapery

Socio-Religious Factors

The evolution of these art schools was deeply intertwined with socio-religious factors:

  • Buddhism: The rise of Buddhism provided the primary impetus for early art, particularly at Sanchi, Bharhut, and Gandhara. Art served as a tool for propagating Buddhist teachings and creating sacred spaces.
  • Jainism: While less prominent in monumental art, Jainism influenced sculptural styles, particularly in Mathura, where Jain Tirthankaras were depicted alongside Buddhist and Hindu deities.
  • Early Hinduism: The Mathura school witnessed the emergence of early Hindu iconography, with representations of deities like Vishnu, Shiva, and Durga. This reflects the growing popularity of devotional Hinduism.
  • Patronage: Royal patronage (Ashoka, Kushans, Shungas) and the support of merchant guilds and wealthy individuals were crucial for funding artistic projects.
  • Trade & Cultural Exchange: The Silk Road facilitated cultural exchange between India, Central Asia, and the Roman world, contributing to the stylistic diversity of Gandhara art.

Conclusion

The art schools that flourished between the 2nd century BCE and the 3rd century CE represent a pivotal period in the history of Indian art. The distinct characteristics of Sanchi, Bharhut, Gandhara, and Mathura reflect a complex interplay of indigenous traditions, foreign influences, and evolving religious beliefs. These schools not only produced remarkable works of art but also laid the foundation for subsequent artistic developments in the Indian subcontinent, shaping the visual landscape of Indian culture for centuries to come. The study of these schools provides invaluable insights into the socio-religious and political dynamics of ancient India.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Stupa
A Stupa is a dome-shaped structure erected as a Buddhist shrine. It typically houses relics of the Buddha or other important Buddhist figures. It symbolizes the Buddha’s enlightened mind.
Torana
A Torana is a decorative gateway typically found at the entrance of a Buddhist stupa. It is often elaborately carved with symbolic motifs and scenes from Buddhist mythology.

Key Statistics

The Great Stupa at Sanchi is estimated to have been initially constructed in the 3rd century BCE by Emperor Ashoka, with significant additions and renovations over the following centuries.

Source: Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) reports (knowledge cutoff 2023)

Approximately 80% of the sculptures at Bharhut depict Jataka tales, highlighting the importance of narrative art in early Buddhist sculpture.

Source: Percy Brown, Indian Sculpture and Painting (1965)

Examples

Kanishka’s Patronage of Gandhara Art

The Kushan emperor Kanishka (c. 127-151 CE) was a major patron of Buddhist art in Gandhara. His reign saw the construction of numerous monasteries and stupas, and the flourishing of Gandhara sculpture. The Bamiyan Buddhas, tragically destroyed in 2001, were a prime example of Kanishka’s patronage.

Frequently Asked Questions

How did the Gandhara school differ from other contemporary Indian art schools?

The Gandhara school was unique due to its strong Hellenistic influence, resulting in a more realistic and naturalistic style compared to the more stylized and symbolic art of schools like Sanchi and Mathura. It also utilized different materials (schist) and depicted the Buddha in a distinctly Greco-Roman manner.

Topics Covered

HistoryArt & CultureAncient ArtSculpturePaintingReligious Influence