UPSC MainsHISTORY-PAPER-I201415 Marks
Q5.

Do you think the Harappan civilization had a diversity of subsistence base?

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of the Harappan civilization's economy and resource management. The answer should move beyond a simplistic agricultural focus and demonstrate awareness of the diverse ecological zones within the Harappan sphere and how they were exploited. Structure the answer by first outlining the geographical diversity, then detailing the various subsistence strategies (agriculture, animal husbandry, fishing, trade, craft production), and finally, providing archaeological evidence to support the claim of diversity. A comparative approach, highlighting regional variations, will strengthen the response.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The Harappan Civilization (c. 3300-1700 BCE), also known as the Indus Valley Civilization, flourished across a vast geographical expanse encompassing modern-day Pakistan and northwest India. Traditionally, the Harappan economy was viewed primarily as agricultural. However, recent archaeological investigations reveal a far more complex picture, suggesting a diverse subsistence base adapted to the varied ecological zones within their territory. This answer will explore the evidence demonstrating the multifaceted nature of Harappan subsistence strategies, moving beyond a solely agrarian perspective to encompass animal husbandry, fishing, trade, and specialized craft production.

Geographical Diversity and its Impact

The Harappan civilization wasn't confined to a single ecological zone. Its settlements spanned from the Himalayan foothills to the Arabian Sea coast, encompassing diverse environments like alluvial plains, deserts, and semi-arid regions. This geographical diversity necessitated a varied subsistence base. The Indus River and its tributaries provided fertile land for agriculture, while the coastal areas offered opportunities for fishing and maritime trade. The presence of resources like timber, stone, and minerals in different regions further encouraged specialized production and exchange.

Agricultural Practices

Agriculture formed the cornerstone of the Harappan economy. Evidence from sites like Harappa and Mohenjo-daro reveals the cultivation of crops like wheat, barley, rice, sesame, peas, and cotton. The discovery of a ploughed field at Kalibangan (Rajasthan) suggests the use of agricultural tools. However, agricultural practices varied regionally. Rice cultivation was prominent in Gujarat and along the Ghaggar-Hakra river valley, while wheat and barley were more common in the Punjab region. The use of irrigation canals, though debated, is indicated by structures found at Dholavira and Lothal.

Animal Husbandry

Animal husbandry played a significant role in the Harappan economy. Archaeological evidence indicates the domestication of cattle (humped and non-humped), buffalo, sheep, goats, and pigs. Terracotta figurines depicting these animals are frequently found at Harappan sites. Cattle were likely used for draught purposes, milk production, and meat. The presence of bones of various animals suggests a diversified livestock rearing system. Evidence from Mehrgarh (pre-Harappan) shows early domestication of animals, laying the foundation for Harappan practices.

Fishing and Marine Resource Exploitation

Coastal settlements like Lothal, Balakot, and Sutkagendor demonstrate a significant reliance on marine resources. The discovery of a dockyard at Lothal provides concrete evidence of maritime activity and trade. Fish bones, shell artifacts, and depictions of boats on seals indicate the importance of fishing. The exploitation of marine resources extended to the collection of shell, chank, and other marine products for crafting ornaments and tools.

Craft Production and Specialization

The Harappan civilization was renowned for its craft specialization. Archaeological evidence reveals the presence of skilled artisans engaged in pottery making, bead making, metalworking (copper, bronze, and limited gold and silver), seal carving, and textile production. The standardized weights and measures suggest a regulated system of trade and exchange. Sites like Chanhudaro were specialized centers for bead making, while Mohenjo-daro and Harappa were hubs for metalworking. This specialization indicates a complex division of labor and a diversified economic system.

Trade and Exchange Networks

The Harappans engaged in extensive trade, both internal and external. Internal trade involved the exchange of goods between different settlements within the Harappan sphere. External trade connections have been established with Mesopotamia, Oman, and Central Asia. Harappan seals and artifacts have been found in Mesopotamian cities like Ur and Kish. In return, the Harappans likely received goods like copper, tin, and precious stones. The presence of lapis lazuli, a stone not found in the Indus Valley, indicates trade with Afghanistan and Central Asia.

Regional Variations in Subsistence

The subsistence base wasn't uniform across all Harappan settlements. For example, settlements in Gujarat relied heavily on marine resources and agriculture suited to the arid climate, while those in the Punjab region focused more on wheat and barley cultivation. The presence of different types of tools and artifacts at various sites further supports the idea of regional specialization and adaptation to local environmental conditions.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Harappan civilization demonstrably possessed a diverse subsistence base, extending far beyond a simple agricultural economy. The interplay of agriculture, animal husbandry, fishing, craft production, and trade, adapted to the varied ecological zones within their territory, created a resilient and complex economic system. Archaeological evidence from numerous sites confirms this diversity, challenging earlier, more limited interpretations of Harappan economic life. This multifaceted approach to resource management was crucial to the civilization’s longevity and widespread influence.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Topics Covered

HistoryArchaeologyIndus Valley CivilizationAgricultureTradeUrbanization