UPSC MainsMEDICAL-SCIENCE-PAPER-I201415 Marks
Q24.

A young female has consumed carbolic acid accidentally. How will you establish the diagnosis and treat the patient? Describe the expected post-mortem findings in the event of death of such a patient.

How to Approach

This question requires a systematic approach covering diagnosis, treatment, and post-mortem findings in carbolic acid poisoning. The answer should demonstrate understanding of the pathophysiology, clinical presentation, and management principles. Structure the answer into three main sections: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Post-Mortem Findings. Within each section, detail the specific steps and expected observations. Focus on the corrosive nature of carbolic acid and its systemic effects.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Carbolic acid (phenol) is a highly corrosive substance commonly found in disinfectants and cleaning agents. Accidental ingestion, even in small amounts, can cause severe damage to the gastrointestinal tract and systemic toxicity. Prompt diagnosis and aggressive treatment are crucial for improving patient outcomes. The severity of poisoning depends on the concentration of phenol, the amount ingested, and the duration before intervention. This answer will detail the diagnostic approach, treatment protocol, and expected post-mortem findings in a case of carbolic acid ingestion.

Diagnosis

Establishing a diagnosis of carbolic acid poisoning requires a rapid and thorough assessment. Key steps include:

  • History: Obtain a detailed history from the patient (if conscious) or bystanders regarding the substance ingested, the amount, and the time of ingestion. Look for characteristic odor on breath or clothing.
  • Clinical Examination: Assess the patient’s airway, breathing, and circulation (ABC). Look for signs of oral burns, dysphagia, and abdominal pain. Neurological examination is crucial to assess for seizures or altered mental status.
  • Laboratory Investigations:
    • Complete Blood Count (CBC): To assess for anemia or infection.
    • Electrolytes, BUN, Creatinine: To evaluate renal function.
    • Arterial Blood Gas (ABG): To assess acid-base balance and oxygenation.
    • Electrocardiogram (ECG): To monitor for cardiac arrhythmias.
    • Gastric Lavage: Considered if ingestion was recent (within 1 hour) and the patient is protected from aspiration. *Caution: Contraindicated if esophageal perforation is suspected.*
    • Endoscopy: Essential to assess the extent of esophageal and gastric burns.
  • Toxicology Screen: While not always immediately available, a toxicology screen can confirm the presence of phenol.

Treatment

Treatment of carbolic acid poisoning is primarily supportive and aimed at minimizing absorption and mitigating systemic effects. The following steps are crucial:

  • Decontamination:
    • Do NOT induce vomiting: Vomiting can cause further esophageal damage.
    • Gastric Lavage: As mentioned above, consider only if early and with airway protection.
    • Activated Charcoal: Generally *not* effective for phenol due to its corrosive nature and poor adsorption.
    • Dilution: Administer milk or water (15-30 ml/kg) to dilute the acid, *unless* there is evidence of esophageal perforation.
  • Airway Management: Secure the airway with endotracheal intubation if there is evidence of airway compromise (e.g., stridor, hoarseness, respiratory distress).
  • Cardiovascular Support: Monitor for hypotension and arrhythmias. Administer intravenous fluids and vasopressors as needed. Phenol can cause myocardial depression and arrhythmias.
  • Renal Support: Monitor urine output and renal function. Consider hemodialysis if renal failure develops.
  • Burn Management: Treat esophageal and gastric burns with appropriate supportive care, including pain management and nutritional support (parenteral nutrition may be required).
  • Specific Antidotes: There is no specific antidote for phenol poisoning.

Post-Mortem Findings

In the event of death, the post-mortem examination will reveal characteristic findings:

  • Oral Cavity: Burns and ulceration of the lips, tongue, and oral mucosa.
  • Esophagus: Severe corrosive damage, often with perforation. The esophagus may be friable and easily ruptured.
  • Stomach: Corrosive damage to the gastric mucosa, with ulceration and potential perforation. A characteristic odor of phenol may be present.
  • Intestines: Damage may extend to the duodenum and small intestine, though typically less severe than in the esophagus and stomach.
  • Kidneys: Acute tubular necrosis due to myoglobinuria (from muscle damage) and direct toxic effects.
  • Heart: Myocardial damage and arrhythmias may be present.
  • Lungs: Pulmonary edema may be present due to aspiration or systemic effects.
  • Histopathology: Microscopic examination will reveal coagulative necrosis of the affected tissues.

The presence of a characteristic almond-like odor may also be noted during the autopsy, although this is not always present.

Conclusion

Carbolic acid poisoning is a life-threatening emergency requiring immediate and aggressive management. Early diagnosis, meticulous decontamination, and supportive care are crucial for improving patient survival. Post-mortem findings are typically characterized by severe corrosive damage to the upper gastrointestinal tract and systemic organ damage. Prevention through safe storage and handling of phenol-containing products remains the most effective strategy.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Phenol
Phenol (carbolic acid) is an aromatic organic compound with the chemical formula C6H5OH. It is a colorless to white crystalline solid with a distinct odor and is highly corrosive.
Coagulative Necrosis
A form of cell death characterized by preservation of tissue architecture, typically caused by ischemia or chemical injury (like phenol). The affected tissues appear firm and pale.

Key Statistics

According to data from the National Poison Data System (NPDS) in the US, phenol exposures account for approximately 1-2% of all poisoning cases annually. (Data as of 2022)

Source: National Poison Data System (NPDS)

The mortality rate in severe phenol poisoning cases can be as high as 30-50%, particularly if esophageal perforation occurs. (Based on literature review up to 2023)

Source: Literature review of case reports and studies

Examples

Lysol Poisoning

Historically, Lysol, a disinfectant containing phenol, was a common household product. Numerous cases of accidental and intentional poisoning occurred, leading to stricter regulations regarding its concentration and labeling.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is activated charcoal useful in carbolic acid poisoning?

Generally, no. Activated charcoal is not effective for phenol poisoning because phenol is corrosive and poorly adsorbed by charcoal. It may delay gastric emptying and worsen the situation.

Topics Covered

ToxicologyEmergency MedicinePoisoningCarbolic AcidTreatment