UPSC MainsSOCIOLOGY-PAPER-II201410 Marks150 Words
Q1.

Gandhi's efforts on communal harmony

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of Gandhi’s multifaceted approach to communal harmony, moving beyond a simple recounting of events. The answer should focus on the strategies employed, the challenges faced, and the limitations of his efforts. Structure the answer chronologically, highlighting key movements and instances where Gandhi actively worked towards bridging communal divides. Mention the historical context of rising communalism and the political factors influencing it. Focus on specific examples like the Khilafat Movement, the Non-Cooperation Movement, and his fasts.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Mahatma Gandhi’s life was deeply intertwined with the struggle for India’s independence, but equally central to his philosophy was the pursuit of communal harmony. In a nation characterized by religious diversity, Gandhi recognized the dangers of communalism and dedicated himself to fostering unity between Hindus and Muslims, and other religious groups. His efforts weren’t merely reactive responses to communal riots, but proactive attempts to build trust and understanding. The rise of Hindu and Muslim nationalism in the early 20th century, coupled with British ‘divide and rule’ policies, created a volatile environment that Gandhi sought to navigate through his principles of *Sarvodaya* and non-violent resistance. This note will explore the various facets of Gandhi’s endeavors to promote communal harmony in pre-independent India.

Early Efforts and the Khilafat Movement (1919-1924)

Gandhi’s initial foray into actively addressing communal issues came with his support for the Khilafat Movement. Recognizing the anxieties of Indian Muslims regarding the post-World War I treatment of the Ottoman Caliphate, he saw an opportunity to forge a Hindu-Muslim alliance against British rule. He wholeheartedly supported the movement, believing it was a just cause and a test of Hindu-Muslim unity. This collaboration, however, was short-lived. The Chauri Chaura incident in 1922 and the subsequent withdrawal of the Non-Cooperation Movement created fissures, and the eventual collapse of the Khilafat Movement exposed the fragility of the alliance.

Promoting Inter-Religious Dialogue and Shared Spaces

Gandhi consistently emphasized the essential unity of religions. He believed that all religions had a core of truth and encouraged interfaith dialogue. He regularly included prayers from all religions in his ashram activities and encouraged participation from people of all faiths. He actively promoted the use of shared spaces for worship and communal gatherings. For example, he insisted on the inclusion of verses from the Quran and the Bible alongside Hindu scriptures in his daily prayers at Sabarmati Ashram.

Addressing Communal Riots and Fasts

Throughout the 1920s and 30s, India witnessed a series of communal riots. Gandhi responded to these outbreaks with a combination of appeals for peace, personal visits to affected areas, and, most dramatically, fasts. His fasts were not intended as coercion, but as a moral appeal to both communities to renounce violence and embrace reconciliation.

  • 1924 – Kohat Fast: Gandhi undertook a five-day fast to quell communal violence in Kohat (now in Pakistan).
  • 1927 – Calcutta Fast: He fasted for 21 days in Calcutta to restore peace after widespread communal riots.
  • 1932 – Yeravda Fast: This fast was against the British government’s Communal Award, which provided separate electorates for ‘Depressed Classes’ (Dalits). While not directly addressing Hindu-Muslim conflict, it demonstrated his opposition to any form of division based on religious or social identity.

The Political Context and Limitations

Gandhi’s efforts were constantly challenged by the growing influence of communal political organizations like the Hindu Mahasabha and the Muslim League. The League, under the leadership of Muhammad Ali Jinnah, increasingly advocated for separate political representation for Muslims, culminating in the demand for Pakistan. The Hindu Mahasabha, on the other hand, promoted a Hindu nationalist agenda. Gandhi’s attempts to bridge the gap between these opposing forces were often met with resistance and suspicion. The British government’s policies, often perceived as favoring one community over another, further exacerbated the situation.

Post-Partition and Legacy

The Partition of India in 1947 was a devastating blow to Gandhi’s vision of a united and harmonious India. He spent the final months of his life attempting to quell the violence that erupted during Partition, traveling to riot-affected areas and appealing for peace. His assassination in 1948, by a Hindu nationalist, underscored the deep-seated communal tensions that continued to plague the nation. Despite the tragic outcome, Gandhi’s legacy as a champion of communal harmony remains profound. His principles of non-violence, tolerance, and interfaith understanding continue to inspire efforts to build a more inclusive and peaceful society.

Year Event Gandhi’s Response
1922 Chauri Chaura Incident Withdrew Non-Cooperation Movement, highlighting the need for non-violent methods.
1924 Kohat Riots Five-day fast to restore peace.
1932 Communal Award Fasted against separate electorates for ‘Depressed Classes’.
1947 Partition of India Traveled to riot-affected areas, appealed for peace.

Conclusion

Gandhi’s efforts to foster communal harmony were a constant struggle against deeply entrenched prejudices and political machinations. While he achieved some successes in bringing communities together, particularly during the Khilafat Movement and through his personal appeals, the forces of communalism ultimately proved too strong. His legacy, however, remains a powerful reminder of the importance of tolerance, understanding, and non-violent resistance in building a cohesive and peaceful society. In contemporary India, his principles are more relevant than ever, offering a framework for addressing the challenges of religious diversity and promoting social harmony.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Sarvodaya
A social philosophy propounded by Gandhi, meaning ‘the welfare of all’. It emphasizes the upliftment of all sections of society, particularly the marginalized and downtrodden.
Communalism
A political ideology that emphasizes religious identity over national identity, often leading to tensions and conflicts between different religious communities.

Key Statistics

According to data from the Home Ministry (as of 2022, knowledge cutoff), communal incidents in India saw a significant increase in the years leading up to 2022, highlighting the ongoing challenges to communal harmony.

Source: Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India (2022)

According to the 2011 Census of India (knowledge cutoff), Hinduism constitutes approximately 79.8% of the population, while Islam constitutes approximately 14.2%, highlighting the significant religious diversity of the country.

Source: Census of India, 2011

Examples

Noakhali Relief Work

In 1946, Gandhi undertook a peace mission to Noakhali (now in Bangladesh), which had been ravaged by communal violence. He spent four months in the area, walking from village to village, preaching peace and reconciliation, and helping to rebuild trust between Hindus and Muslims.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did Gandhi support the Khilafat Movement despite his opposition to religious politics?

Gandhi saw the Khilafat Movement as an opportunity to unite Hindus and Muslims against a common enemy – the British. He believed that supporting the movement would demonstrate Hindu solidarity with Muslims and strengthen the broader struggle for independence. He prioritized national unity over ideological purity.

Topics Covered

HistorySociologyIndian CultureIndian NationalismSocial MovementsCommunalism