UPSC MainsECONOMICS-PAPER-II201510 Marks150 Words
Q3.

What specific trade policies during the British period led to the decline of Indian industry? Explain.

How to Approach

This question requires a focused answer detailing the specific trade policies implemented by the British East India Company and the British Crown that systematically undermined Indian industries. The answer should move beyond general statements and highlight specific policies like tariff structures, restrictions on Indian exports, and promotion of British manufactured goods. A chronological approach, starting with the early Company policies and progressing to those of the Crown, would be effective. Mentioning the impact on specific industries (textiles, iron, shipbuilding) will add depth.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The British colonial period witnessed a significant de-industrialization of India, reversing its position as a major manufacturing hub. Prior to British rule, India possessed thriving industries, particularly in textiles, iron, and shipbuilding, and enjoyed a favorable balance of trade. However, a series of deliberately crafted trade policies implemented by the British East India Company and later the British Crown systematically dismantled these industries, transforming India into a supplier of raw materials and a market for British manufactured goods. This decline wasn’t accidental; it was a direct consequence of policies designed to benefit British economic interests.

Early Policies of the East India Company (1757-1857)

Initially, the East India Company focused on trade, but its policies gradually shifted towards maximizing profits for Britain. Key policies included:

  • Destruction of Local Manufacturing: The Company actively suppressed local manufacturing to create a monopoly for British goods. Artisans were often forced to work exclusively for the Company at low wages, or their workshops were destroyed.
  • High Tariffs on Indian Exports: Heavy tariffs were imposed on Indian exports to Europe, making them uncompetitive. For example, tariffs on Indian cotton textiles were significantly higher than those on British textiles.
  • Duty-Free Import of British Goods: British manufactured goods were allowed to be imported into India virtually duty-free, flooding the Indian market and undercutting local producers.
  • Control over Internal Trade: The Company established monopolies over key commodities like salt, opium, and indigo, further restricting Indian traders and producers.

Policies After the Sepoy Mutiny of 1857 (Crown Rule)

After the Sepoy Mutiny, the British Crown took direct control of India, and trade policies continued to favor British interests.

  • Free Trade Policy (1870s onwards): While ostensibly promoting ‘free trade’, this policy primarily benefited Britain. Indian raw materials were exported cheaply, while finished British goods were imported without significant tariffs. This led to a massive trade imbalance.
  • Railways and Infrastructure: The development of railways, while providing some benefits, primarily facilitated the transportation of raw materials from the Indian hinterland to ports for export to Britain and the distribution of British manufactured goods across India.
  • Decline of Traditional Industries: The influx of cheap British goods led to the decline of traditional Indian industries. The textile industry, once a global leader, was particularly hard hit. For example, the handloom weaving industry in Bengal suffered immensely.

Impact on Specific Industries

Industry Pre-British Status Impact of British Policies
Textiles Global leader in cotton and silk textiles; exported worldwide. Decline due to competition from cheaper, machine-made British textiles; unemployment of millions of weavers.
Iron & Steel India produced high-quality wrought iron; known for Damascus steel. Decline due to lack of protection and competition from British iron and steel; loss of traditional skills.
Shipbuilding India had a thriving shipbuilding industry. Decline due to discriminatory policies favoring British shipbuilders; loss of naval power.

Discriminatory Freight Policies: Indian ships were often excluded from carrying goods between Britain and its colonies, further hindering Indian trade.

Conclusion

The British trade policies during their rule in India were instrumental in the decline of Indian industries. These policies, ranging from high tariffs on Indian exports and duty-free imports of British goods to the suppression of local manufacturing, systematically dismantled India’s industrial base. This de-industrialization had long-lasting consequences, contributing to widespread poverty and economic dependence that persisted long after independence. Understanding these historical policies is crucial for comprehending the structural challenges facing the Indian economy today.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

De-industrialization
The process of social and economic change where an industrial society transforms into a post-industrial society, often involving a decline in manufacturing and a rise in the service sector. In the Indian context, it refers to the decline of traditional industries under British rule.
Balance of Trade
The difference between the value of a country's exports and its imports. A favorable balance of trade means exports exceed imports, while an unfavorable balance means imports exceed exports. British policies created a consistently unfavorable balance of trade for India.

Key Statistics

Between 1815 and 1835, the share of Indian textiles in the British market fell from 50% to 16%.

Source: Habib, Irfan. *An Atlas of Mughal India* (1982)

India’s share of world GDP fell from 22.6% in 1700 to 3.8% in 1900.

Source: Angus Maddison, *Contours of the World Economy, 1–2030 AD* (2007)

Examples

The Dacca Muslin Industry

The Dacca muslin industry, renowned for its fine textiles, was completely destroyed by the competition from British machine-made cloth. Weavers were forced to abandon their craft, leading to widespread poverty in the region.

Frequently Asked Questions

Were there any attempts by Indians to resist these policies?

Yes, there were several instances of resistance, including protests by weavers, attempts to establish indigenous industries, and advocacy for protective tariffs. However, these efforts were largely suppressed by the British authorities.

Topics Covered

HistoryEconomyColonialismTradeIndustrial Decline