UPSC MainsENGLISH-COMPULSORY20155 Marks
Q24.

Mortal

How to Approach

This question, simply stating "Mortal," requires a creative and philosophical approach. As it's a standalone word, the answer should explore its multifaceted meaning within the context of human existence, societal implications, and potentially, its relevance to governance and ethics. The answer should avoid being overly abstract and aim for a nuanced understanding. Structure: Define 'mortal', explore its philosophical and societal implications, connect it to concepts like legacy, governance, and the human condition, and conclude with a reflective statement.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The word "mortal" fundamentally defines the human condition – subject to death. Derived from the Latin ‘mortalis’, meaning relating to death, it stands in stark contrast to the concept of immortality. Acknowledging our mortality is a cornerstone of many philosophical and religious beliefs, shaping our values, motivations, and the pursuit of meaning in life. Beyond its literal definition, ‘mortal’ carries profound implications for how we perceive time, legacy, and our responsibilities to future generations. This exploration delves into the multifaceted nature of mortality and its resonance within the broader human experience.

The Philosophical Dimensions of Mortality

The awareness of mortality has been a central theme in philosophical thought for millennia. Existentialist philosophers like Martin Heidegger emphasized that acknowledging our ‘being-towards-death’ is crucial for authentic living. This awareness compels us to confront the finitude of existence and to prioritize what truly matters. Epicureanism, conversely, argued that the fear of death is irrational, as death is simply the cessation of sensation and therefore cannot be experienced. These contrasting viewpoints highlight the complex relationship humans have with their own mortality.

Societal Implications of Mortality

Mortality profoundly shapes societal structures and norms. The inevitability of death drives the creation of institutions like families, religions, and legal systems, all designed to provide meaning, continuity, and a sense of order in the face of impermanence. The desire for legacy – to leave a lasting impact on the world – motivates individuals to contribute to art, science, and social progress. Furthermore, the concept of mortality underpins ethical considerations surrounding end-of-life care, inheritance laws, and the value we place on human life.

Mortality and Governance

The transient nature of power and leadership, inherent in mortality, has significant implications for governance. Effective governance requires a long-term perspective, yet leaders are inevitably constrained by their own limited lifespans. This necessitates the creation of robust institutions, transparent processes, and a commitment to the rule of law to ensure continuity and accountability. The pursuit of short-term gains at the expense of long-term sustainability can be seen as a failure to adequately account for the implications of mortality. Consider the challenges of climate change, where addressing the issue requires sacrifices today for the benefit of future generations – a direct confrontation with the temporal limitations imposed by our mortality.

The Human Condition and the Acceptance of Mortality

Many cultures and religions offer frameworks for coping with mortality. Buddhism, for example, emphasizes the impermanence of all things (anicca) as a path to liberation from suffering. Similarly, Stoicism encourages acceptance of what is beyond our control, including death. The ability to confront mortality with equanimity is often seen as a sign of wisdom and maturity. However, the denial of mortality – through pursuits like immortality projects or the avoidance of difficult conversations about death – can also be a powerful force in human behavior.

Mortality in the Age of Technological Advancement

Recent advancements in biotechnology and artificial intelligence raise new questions about mortality. While extending lifespan is a legitimate scientific pursuit, the prospect of radical life extension or even digital immortality raises ethical and societal dilemmas. Would such advancements exacerbate existing inequalities? What would be the psychological and social consequences of significantly extending the human lifespan? These are questions that demand careful consideration as we navigate the evolving relationship between technology and mortality.

Philosophical School of Thought View on Mortality Implications
Existentialism Acknowledging mortality is essential for authentic living. Focus on individual responsibility and creating meaning in a finite existence.
Epicureanism Fear of death is irrational; death is simply the cessation of sensation. Emphasis on maximizing pleasure and minimizing pain in the present life.
Stoicism Acceptance of mortality as a natural part of the universe. Cultivation of inner peace and resilience in the face of adversity.

Conclusion

The concept of "mortal" is far more than a simple biological fact; it is a fundamental truth that shapes our individual lives, our societies, and our governance structures. Acknowledging our mortality compels us to prioritize what truly matters, to strive for meaningful connections, and to act responsibly towards future generations. While technological advancements may offer the potential to extend lifespan, they do not diminish the ultimate reality of impermanence. Ultimately, embracing our mortality can be a catalyst for living a more authentic, purposeful, and compassionate life.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Anicca
A Buddhist term signifying impermanence, the doctrine that all of existence is in a constant state of flux.

Key Statistics

Globally, approximately 58.3 million people died in 2019 (pre-pandemic), representing a global mortality rate of 7.5 per 1,000 population.

Source: World Health Organization (WHO), 2019

According to a 2023 study by Chapman University, death is consistently ranked as one of the top five most feared things by Americans.

Source: Chapman University Survey of American Fears (2023)

Examples

The Pyramids of Giza

The construction of the Pyramids of Giza in ancient Egypt demonstrates a profound preoccupation with mortality and the desire for immortality through lasting monuments.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the fear of death natural?

Yes, terror management theory suggests that the awareness of mortality creates existential anxiety, which humans attempt to manage through cultural beliefs and self-esteem.