UPSC MainsENGLISH-LITERATURE-PAPER-I201515 Marks
Q23.

In Tom Jones, Fielding's scathing satire is reserved for the London upper classes. Discuss.

How to Approach

This question requires a focused analysis of Henry Fielding’s *Tom Jones*. The approach should involve demonstrating an understanding of satire as a literary device and then specifically illustrating how Fielding employs it to critique the London upper classes. The answer needs to move beyond simply stating that satire exists, and instead, provide concrete examples from the novel to support the claim. A good structure would be to first define Fielding’s satirical style, then analyze specific characters and episodes that target the upper classes, and finally, contrast this with how other social groups are portrayed.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Henry Fielding’s *Tom Jones* (1749) is widely regarded as a foundational text of the English novel, celebrated for its expansive scope, realistic characters, and, crucially, its pervasive satire. While the novel offers a panoramic view of 18th-century English society, the assertion that Fielding reserves his most “scathing satire” for the London upper classes is a compelling one. Fielding’s satire isn’t merely humorous; it’s a pointed critique of hypocrisy, pretension, and the moral failings of those in positions of power and privilege. This essay will explore how Fielding systematically dismantles the pretensions of the aristocracy and gentry through characterization, plot development, and narrative voice, demonstrating that his harshest judgments are indeed directed towards the London elite.

Fielding’s Satirical Techniques

Fielding’s satire operates on multiple levels. He employs irony, caricature, and mock-epic techniques to expose the flaws of his characters. His narrative voice is often intrusively authorial, directly addressing the reader and offering commentary that undermines the actions and motivations of the characters. This direct address isn’t simply a stylistic choice; it’s a crucial element of his satirical project, allowing him to guide the reader’s judgment and expose the absurdity of the social world he depicts.

Targeting the London Upper Classes: Characters and Episodes

Lady Bellaston

Lady Bellaston is perhaps the most prominent target of Fielding’s satire within the London upper class. She embodies the superficiality, sexual licentiousness, and manipulative nature of aristocratic women. Her elaborate schemes to seduce Tom, her disregard for social conventions, and her ultimate exposure as a fraud are all presented with a biting irony. Fielding doesn’t simply condemn her immorality; he exposes the societal structures that enable and encourage such behavior. Her salon is a microcosm of London society, filled with gossips, schemers, and those seeking social advancement through any means necessary.

Lord Fellamar and the Political World

Lord Fellamar represents the corruption and self-interest that plague the political sphere. His concern is not with the welfare of the nation but with maintaining his own power and influence. The scenes depicting political maneuvering in London are filled with caricatures of ambitious politicians and their sycophantic followers. Fielding satirizes the patronage system and the lack of genuine meritocracy within the government. The episode involving the attempted elopement of Mrs. Waters and Tom, and the subsequent involvement of Lord Fellamar’s agents, highlights the lengths to which the upper classes will go to protect their reputations and maintain social order – even if it means sacrificing justice and morality.

The Contrast with Rural Society

Fielding’s satire is particularly effective because it’s presented in contrast to his portrayal of rural society. While not idealized, the countryside is depicted as a place of greater authenticity and genuine human connection. Characters like Allworthy, despite his own flaws, represent a moral compass that is largely absent in London. The simplicity of rural life is contrasted with the artificiality and complexity of the London social scene. This contrast reinforces the idea that the corruption and hypocrisy are concentrated within the upper classes of the capital.

Episodes of Social Climbing and Pretension

Numerous episodes in *Tom Jones* satirize the relentless pursuit of social status and the pretension of the upper classes. The attempts of various characters to infiltrate higher social circles, often through marriage or patronage, are consistently exposed as shallow and self-serving. The dinners, balls, and assemblies depicted in the novel are not celebrations of social harmony but rather arenas for competition, gossip, and the display of wealth and status. Fielding’s descriptions of fashion, manners, and social rituals are laced with irony, highlighting the absurdity of these conventions.

Nuances and Exceptions

While the focus is heavily on the London upper classes, it’s important to acknowledge that Fielding’s satire isn’t entirely exclusive. He also critiques the hypocrisy and failings of other social groups, including the clergy and the lower classes. However, the scale and intensity of his satire are demonstrably greater when directed towards those in positions of power and privilege. The consequences of their actions are also far-reaching, impacting the lives of many others. Furthermore, Fielding often displays a degree of sympathy for characters from lower social strata, recognizing their vulnerability and lack of opportunity.

Social Group Level of Satire Examples
London Upper Classes Scathing, Intense Lady Bellaston, Lord Fellamar, Social Climbers
Clergy Moderate, Critical Thwackum’s pedantry, Partridge’s charlatanism
Lower Classes Sympathetic, Limited Tom Jones’s early life, Molly Seagrim’s plight

Conclusion

In conclusion, while *Tom Jones* offers a broad social panorama, Fielding’s most pointed and scathing satire is undeniably reserved for the London upper classes. Through carefully crafted characters, ironic episodes, and a consistently critical narrative voice, he exposes the hypocrisy, corruption, and moral failings of the aristocracy and gentry. The contrast with the relative authenticity of rural life further emphasizes the depth of his critique. Fielding’s satire isn’t simply a matter of amusement; it’s a powerful indictment of a society riddled with inequality and moral decay, making *Tom Jones* a timeless and relevant work of social commentary.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Satire
A literary technique employing humor, irony, exaggeration, or ridicule to expose and criticize people's stupidity or vices, particularly in the context of contemporary politics and other topical issues.
Caricature
The use of exaggeration to create a humorous or satirical effect, often by distorting physical features or personality traits.

Key Statistics

In 1750, approximately 1% of the English population belonged to the aristocracy and gentry, controlling a disproportionate amount of land and wealth.

Source: Wrigley, E.A. (2004). *England and the Industrial Revolution*. Oxford University Press.

By the mid-18th century, London’s population had grown to over 630,000, making it one of the largest cities in Europe and a center of social and economic activity.

Source: Defoe, Daniel. *A Tour Through the Whole Island of Great Britain* (1724-1727).

Examples

Jonathan Swift’s *Gulliver’s Travels*

Like Fielding, Swift used satire to critique the political and social structures of his time. *Gulliver’s Travels* satirizes the English court and human nature through fantastical voyages and encounters.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Fielding offer any positive portrayals of the upper classes?

While Fielding primarily satirizes the upper classes, characters like Allworthy demonstrate that he acknowledges the potential for virtue and good judgment within that social group, though even Allworthy is not without his flaws.

Topics Covered

LiteratureNovelSatireTom JonesSatireLondonUpper ClassesSocial Commentary