UPSC MainsGEOLOGY-PAPER-I201510 Marks150 Words
Q14.

Buttress dams.

How to Approach

This question requires a descriptive answer focusing on the engineering and geological aspects of buttress dams. The answer should define buttress dams, explain their components, types, advantages, disadvantages, and suitability. A comparative aspect with gravity dams can be included. The answer should be concise, sticking to the 150-word limit, and use geological terminology appropriately. Structure the answer by defining the dam, explaining its components, and then briefly touching upon its advantages and disadvantages.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Buttress dams are gravity dams that utilize buttresses to reduce the volume of concrete required. Unlike conventional gravity dams which resist water pressure through their weight, buttress dams transfer the load to a foundation through a series of supporting buttresses. These dams are particularly useful in situations where the foundation is strong but the available material for constructing a massive concrete structure is limited. They are a cost-effective alternative to gravity dams in suitable geological settings, especially in narrow canyons.

Components of a Buttress Dam

A typical buttress dam consists of three main components:

  • Deck: The upstream water-retaining surface, usually a thin concrete slab.
  • Buttresses: Inclined supports that transmit the water load to the foundation. These can be triangular, arched, or flat.
  • Foundation: The bedrock or competent soil layer that supports the entire structure.

Types of Buttress Dams

Buttress dams are classified based on the buttress design:

  • Triangular Buttress Dams: Most common type, offering good stability.
  • Arched Buttress Dams: Utilize arch action to further reduce concrete volume.
  • Flat Buttress Dams: Less common, suitable for wider valleys.

Advantages & Disadvantages

Advantages Disadvantages
Less concrete required than gravity dams. More susceptible to damage from erosion at the base.
Suitable for wide valleys with strong foundations. Requires a strong and stable foundation.
Easier to repair than gravity dams. More complex design and construction.

Geologically, the foundation must be competent and impermeable to prevent seepage and ensure stability. Site investigation is crucial before construction.

Conclusion

Buttress dams represent an efficient alternative to conventional gravity dams, particularly in areas with strong foundations and limited concrete resources. Their design necessitates careful geological investigation and construction techniques to ensure long-term stability and prevent seepage. While offering economic advantages, their susceptibility to erosion and complex construction require diligent monitoring and maintenance.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Seepage
The slow escape of a liquid or gas through a porous material. In dam construction, seepage refers to water leaking through the dam structure or its foundation.
Hydrostatic Pressure
The pressure exerted by a fluid at equilibrium due to the force of gravity. This is a key consideration in dam design, as the dam must withstand the hydrostatic pressure of the reservoir.

Key Statistics

Approximately 10% of the world’s large dams are buttress dams (as of 2023).

Source: International Commission on Large Dams (ICOLD)

The cost of constructing a buttress dam can be 20-30% lower than a comparable gravity dam, depending on site conditions (based on 2018 estimates).

Source: Bureau of Reclamation, USA

Examples

Bartlett Dam, Arizona

The Bartlett Dam in Arizona, USA, is a prominent example of a curved buttress dam, completed in 1939. It demonstrates the effectiveness of this design in narrow canyons with strong bedrock foundations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are buttress dams safer than gravity dams?

Neither type is inherently safer. Safety depends on proper design, construction, geological conditions, and maintenance. Buttress dams require more complex analysis and are potentially more vulnerable to foundation issues.

Topics Covered

Science & TechnologyGeographyCivil EngineeringWater ResourcesDam Construction