UPSC MainsGEOLOGY-PAPER-II201510 Marks
Q2.

Explain the phenomenon of twinning and discuss the twinning in feldspars with neat sketches.

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of crystal twinning, its causes, and specifically how it manifests in feldspar minerals. The answer should begin with a clear definition of twinning, explaining its atomic basis. Then, it should delve into the types of twinning, focusing on the common twinning laws observed in feldspars (e.g., Albite, Carlsbad, Pericline). Neat sketches are crucial for illustrating the different twin planes and morphologies. The answer should be structured logically, starting with the general concept and then narrowing down to the specifics of feldspar twinning.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Crystal twinning is a common phenomenon in minerals where two or more individual crystals are intergrown in a symmetrical manner. This occurs due to developmental errors during crystal growth, often related to changes in temperature, pressure, or chemical environment. Twinning results from a symmetry operation, leading to a composite crystal with a specific twin law. Feldspars, a group of aluminosilicate minerals, are particularly prone to twinning due to their triclinic or monoclinic crystal systems and the complexities of their structure. Understanding twinning in feldspars is crucial for mineral identification, understanding their formation conditions, and interpreting the geological history of rocks in which they occur.

Understanding Crystal Twinning

Twinning arises from the repetition of a structural unit across a specific plane, known as the twin plane. This plane is often a plane of symmetry within the crystal structure. The twin law describes the relationship between the two intergrown crystal individuals. Twinning can be classified as:

  • Contact Twinning: The twin individuals are joined along a planar surface.
  • Penetration Twinning: The twin individuals interpenetrate each other.
  • Polysynthetic Twinning: Multiple twin planes are present, creating a lamellar or striated appearance.

Twinning in Feldspars

Feldspars exhibit various types of twinning, primarily due to their structural characteristics. The most common types are Albite, Carlsbad, and Pericline twinning. These are named after the feldspar species in which they were first observed.

Albite Twinning

Albite twinning is the most common type of twinning in plagioclase feldspars (NaAlSi3O8 – CaAl2Si2O8). It occurs on the {010} plane, which is a plane parallel to the cleavage planes. The twin law is such that the 'b' crystallographic axis is perpendicular to the twin plane. This results in a simple, mirror-image reflection across the {010} plane.

Albite Twinning

(Image: Albite Twinning - showing the {010} twin plane)

Carlsbad Twinning

Carlsbad twinning is characteristic of orthoclase feldspars (KAlSi3O8) and sanidine. It occurs on the {001} plane. The twin law involves a 180° rotation about the 'c' crystallographic axis, combined with reflection across the {001} plane. This results in a more complex intergrowth, often appearing as a wedge-shaped twin.

Carlsbad Twinning

(Image: Carlsbad Twinning - showing the {001} twin plane)

Pericline Twinning

Pericline twinning is also found in orthoclase feldspars, but it is less common than Carlsbad twinning. It occurs on the {001} plane, similar to Carlsbad, but the twin law involves a 180° rotation about the 'b' crystallographic axis. This results in a twin that appears as a simple reflection across the {001} plane, but with a different orientation than Carlsbad twins.

Pericline Twinning

(Image: Pericline Twinning - showing the {001} twin plane)

Factors Influencing Twinning in Feldspars

  • Cooling Rate: Rapid cooling during crystallization favors twinning as it hinders the perfect arrangement of atoms.
  • Stress: Tectonic stresses can induce twinning in feldspars, even after crystallization.
  • Chemical Composition: The relative proportions of Na, Ca, and K in feldspars influence their twinning tendency.

The presence and type of twinning in feldspars can be used to infer the P-T conditions during their formation and the tectonic history of the rocks they are found in.

Conclusion

In conclusion, crystal twinning is a significant structural feature in minerals, particularly feldspars. The Albite, Carlsbad, and Pericline twin laws are characteristic of different feldspar groups and provide valuable insights into their formation conditions and geological history. Recognizing these twin types, aided by careful observation and sketches, is a fundamental skill for geologists studying igneous and metamorphic rocks. Further research into the mechanisms controlling twinning can enhance our understanding of crystal growth and deformation processes within the Earth's crust.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Twin Law
A twin law is a geometrical description of the orientation relationship between the two intergrown crystal individuals in a twin. It specifies the plane of symmetry (twin plane) and the symmetry operation (rotation, reflection, or inversion) that relates the two parts of the twin.
Polysynthetic Twinning
Polysynthetic twinning refers to the repeated occurrence of twin planes throughout a crystal, creating a lamellar or striated texture. This is common in minerals like plagioclase feldspar and is often associated with deformation.

Key Statistics

Feldspars constitute approximately 60% of the Earth's crust.

Source: Mason, B. (1966). Principles of Igneous and Metamorphic Petrology. Prentice-Hall.

The abundance of K-feldspar (orthoclase, microcline, sanidine) in granitic rocks can range from 30-60% by volume.

Source: Winter, J. D. (2014). Fundamentals of Igneous and Metamorphic Petrology. Pearson Education.

Examples

Twinning in Granite

Granite, a common igneous rock, often contains plagioclase feldspar exhibiting Albite twinning. The presence of these twins can indicate rapid cooling of the magma and the stresses experienced during the rock's formation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between contact and penetration twinning?

Contact twinning involves the twin individuals being joined along a planar surface, while penetration twinning involves the twin individuals intergrowing and partially overlapping each other.