UPSC MainsGEOLOGY-PAPER-II201520 Marks
Q9.

What are the different discontinuities within the earth picked up by seismic waves? What are the petrological explanations for each of these discontinuities?

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of Earth's internal structure and how seismic waves interact with different layers. The answer should begin by explaining how seismic waves are used to identify discontinuities. Then, it should systematically discuss each major discontinuity (Mohorovičić, Gutenberg, Lehmann, and others), detailing their depth and the petrological changes that cause them. Focus on mineral phase transitions and compositional changes. A clear, structured approach with specific depths and mineral compositions is crucial for a high score.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The Earth’s interior, inaccessible for direct observation, is primarily investigated through the study of seismic waves generated by earthquakes and controlled explosions. These waves, as they propagate through the Earth, undergo refraction and reflection at boundaries between layers with differing physical properties, creating what are known as seismic discontinuities. These discontinuities represent significant changes in composition, density, or phase of Earth materials. Understanding these discontinuities is fundamental to deciphering the Earth’s internal structure and its dynamic processes. This answer will detail the major seismic discontinuities and their corresponding petrological explanations.

Seismic Discontinuities and Petrological Explanations

Seismic discontinuities are surfaces within the Earth where seismic wave velocities change abruptly. These changes are caused by variations in density, composition, and phase of the Earth’s materials. The primary discontinuities are:

1. Mohorovičić Discontinuity (Moho)

Depth: Approximately 5-70 km (thinner under oceans, thicker under continents). Seismic Characteristic: A sharp increase in P-wave velocity from ~6.8 km/s to ~8.0 km/s and a significant increase in S-wave velocity. Petrological Explanation: The Moho marks the boundary between the crust and the mantle. Above the Moho lies the relatively less dense, silica-rich crust (granitic composition for continents, basaltic for oceans). Below the Moho lies the denser, iron and magnesium-rich mantle, primarily composed of peridotite. The change in composition and density causes the velocity increase. The transition from hydrated crustal rocks to anhydrous mantle rocks also contributes.

2. Gutenberg Discontinuity

Depth: Approximately 2900 km. Seismic Characteristic: A dramatic decrease in P-wave velocity and the complete disappearance of S-waves. Petrological Explanation: This discontinuity marks the boundary between the mantle and the outer core. The mantle is primarily solid, while the outer core is liquid, composed mainly of iron and nickel. S-waves cannot propagate through liquids, explaining their disappearance. The decrease in P-wave velocity is due to the change in density and the transition from solid silicate materials to liquid metallic iron.

3. Lehmann Discontinuity

Depth: Approximately 2200 km. Seismic Characteristic: A slight increase in P-wave velocity and a subtle change in S-wave velocity. Petrological Explanation: This discontinuity represents the boundary between the upper and lower mantle. It is associated with a phase transition in silicate minerals, specifically the transition from a spinel structure to a perovskite + magnesiowüstite structure. This phase transition is driven by increasing pressure and temperature with depth. The change in mineral structure leads to a change in density and seismic velocity.

4. D'' (D double prime) Discontinuity

Depth: Approximately 2700-2900 km (at the base of the lower mantle). Seismic Characteristic: Complex and variable, with both velocity increases and decreases, and evidence of highly scattered seismic waves. Petrological Explanation: This region is characterized by post-perovskite phase transitions of silicate minerals, along with the accumulation of subducted slabs and potentially iron-rich post-perovskite. The complexity of the D'' layer is attributed to the dynamic interaction between the mantle and the core, including thermal plumes and compositional heterogeneity. The presence of partially molten material is also suggested.

5. Inner Core Boundary

Depth: Approximately 5150 km. Seismic Characteristic: A sharp increase in P-wave velocity. Petrological Explanation: This boundary marks the transition from the liquid outer core to the solid inner core. Despite the high temperature, the immense pressure at this depth forces iron into a solid state. The alignment of iron atoms under extreme pressure contributes to the increased velocity. The inner core is believed to be primarily composed of iron with some nickel and trace elements.

Discontinuity Depth (km) Seismic Characteristic Petrological Explanation
Mohorovičić 5-70 Increase in P & S wave velocity Crust-Mantle boundary; Silica-rich to Iron-Magnesium rich
Gutenberg 2900 Decrease in P wave velocity, S waves disappear Mantle-Outer Core boundary; Solid Silicate to Liquid Iron-Nickel
Lehmann 2200 Slight increase in P & S wave velocity Upper-Lower Mantle boundary; Spinel to Perovskite + Magnesiowüstite
D'' 2700-2900 Complex velocity changes Post-perovskite phase transitions, subducted slabs
Inner Core Boundary 5150 Increase in P wave velocity Liquid Outer Core to Solid Inner Core; Iron phase transition

Conclusion

Seismic discontinuities provide invaluable insights into the Earth’s layered structure and the physical and chemical processes occurring within. These boundaries are not simply sharp transitions but rather complex zones of change, influenced by mineral phase transitions, compositional variations, and dynamic interactions between different layers. Continued research using advanced seismological techniques and high-pressure mineral physics experiments is crucial for refining our understanding of the Earth’s deep interior and its evolution.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Seismic Waves
Vibrations that travel through Earth carrying the energy released during an earthquake. There are two main types: body waves (P and S) and surface waves (Love and Rayleigh).
Phase Transition
A physical process where a substance changes from one state of matter (solid, liquid, gas) to another, or between different crystalline structures within a solid, due to changes in temperature or pressure.

Key Statistics

The Earth's radius is approximately 6,371 kilometers (3,959 miles).

Source: USGS (United States Geological Survey) - as of 2023

The Earth's core is estimated to comprise about 32.5% of the Earth's mass.

Source: Columbia University, Earth Institute - as of 2023

Examples

Iceland's Moho

Iceland provides a unique opportunity to study the Moho due to its relatively thin crust. Deep drilling projects in Iceland have directly sampled rocks from just above the Moho, providing valuable petrological data.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of the D'' layer?

The D'' layer is considered a crucial region for understanding mantle dynamics, including the fate of subducted slabs and the exchange of material between the mantle and the core. It's a zone of intense activity and heterogeneity.