UPSC MainsAGRICULTURE-PAPER-II201612 Marks
Q13.

Discuss the importance of gene pyramiding and gene introgression in developing disease-resistant cultivars.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of plant breeding techniques and their application in disease resistance. The approach should begin by defining gene pyramiding and gene introgression. Then, explain the mechanisms involved and their advantages over traditional breeding. Illustrate with examples of successful implementation and discuss the challenges involved. Finally, highlight the role of modern biotechnological tools in enhancing these processes. A tabular comparison of the two techniques would enhance clarity and demonstrate understanding.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The escalating threat of crop diseases poses a significant challenge to global food security. Traditional breeding methods, while valuable, often face limitations in conferring durable disease resistance. In response, advanced plant breeding strategies like gene pyramiding and gene introgression have emerged as crucial tools. Gene pyramiding involves stacking multiple resistance genes within a single cultivar, while gene introgression introduces beneficial genes from wild relatives into cultivated varieties. These techniques are increasingly vital in the face of evolving pathogen populations and the need for sustainable agricultural practices. The success of these strategies relies on a deep understanding of genetics and the application of innovative biotechnological tools.

Understanding Gene Pyramiding and Gene Introgression

Disease resistance in plants is often governed by multiple genes, each conferring a partial level of resistance. Pathogens, however, can evolve to overcome these individual resistance genes. Therefore, a more robust approach is to combine several resistance genes, a strategy that falls under two main categories: gene pyramiding and gene introgression.

Gene Pyramiding

Gene pyramiding is the process of combining several genes conferring resistance to the same pathogen within a single plant cultivar. This creates a significantly higher barrier for the pathogen to overcome. It can be achieved through conventional breeding, marker-assisted selection (MAS), or genetic engineering.

  • Mechanism: It involves identifying plants possessing different resistance genes (R-genes) and crossing them to create progeny with multiple R-genes.
  • Advantages: Increased resistance durability, reduced selection pressure on the pathogen.
  • Challenges: Linkage drag (undesirable traits linked to resistance genes), difficulty in combining genes with different genetic backgrounds.

Example: The development of wheat varieties resistant to stem rust, a devastating fungal disease, involved pyramiding multiple R-genes. The CIMMYT (International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center) has been instrumental in developing such varieties through MAS.

Gene Introgression

Gene introgression, also known as backcrossing, involves introducing genes from wild relatives or landraces into cultivated varieties. Wild relatives often possess valuable traits, including disease resistance, that are absent in cultivated forms.

  • Mechanism: A wild relative with a desirable resistance gene is crossed with the cultivated variety. The resulting progeny are then repeatedly backcrossed to the cultivated variety, while selecting for the presence of the resistance gene. This process gradually eliminates the undesirable traits from the wild relative while retaining the desired resistance gene.
  • Advantages: Access to a wider pool of resistance genes, introduction of other beneficial traits (e.g., drought tolerance).
  • Challenges: Genetic incompatibility between the cultivated and wild varieties, linkage drag, time-consuming process.

Example: Introgression of resistance to bacterial blight in rice from the wild species Oryza rufipogon has been successful in developing resistant rice varieties. This involved multiple generations of backcrossing and selection.

Comparison: Gene Pyramiding vs. Gene Introgression

Feature Gene Pyramiding Gene Introgression
Source of Genes Within the same species or closely related species Wild relatives or landraces (often more distantly related)
Mechanism Direct combination of existing resistance genes Introducing genes from a different genetic background through backcrossing
Complexity Can be complex due to linkage drag and genetic incompatibility Highly complex and time-consuming due to multiple backcrosses
Genetic Diversity Introduced Limited Potentially higher
Techniques Used Conventional breeding, MAS, genetic engineering Conventional breeding, MAS

The Role of Modern Biotechnological Tools

Modern biotechnological tools significantly enhance the efficiency and precision of both gene pyramiding and gene introgression.

  • Marker-Assisted Selection (MAS): Allows breeders to identify plants carrying specific resistance genes without needing to observe the phenotype (visible trait). This speeds up the breeding process and reduces linkage drag.
  • Genome Editing (CRISPR-Cas9): Enables precise modification of genes, including the introduction or modification of resistance genes. While still subject to regulatory scrutiny, it holds immense potential for accelerating the development of disease-resistant cultivars.
  • Genotyping-by-Sequencing (GBS): Facilitates the identification of genetic markers linked to resistance genes, enabling more efficient MAS.

Challenges and Future Directions

Despite their promise, gene pyramiding and gene introgression face challenges. The emergence of new pathogen races necessitates continuous monitoring and breeding efforts. Public acceptance of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) remains a barrier in some regions. Future research should focus on identifying novel resistance genes, developing more efficient breeding techniques, and ensuring equitable access to disease-resistant cultivars for farmers worldwide. The National Biofortification Mission (NBBM) in India aims to enrich crops with micronutrients, highlighting the broader goal of enhancing crop quality and resilience.

Gene pyramiding and gene introgression are vital strategies in the ongoing battle against crop diseases, offering a more durable approach than relying on single resistance genes. While conventional breeding forms the foundation, the integration of modern biotechnological tools like MAS and genome editing promises to accelerate the development of disease-resistant cultivars. Addressing challenges related to genetic diversity, regulatory hurdles, and equitable access will be crucial for ensuring food security and sustainable agriculture in the face of evolving pathogen threats.

Conclusion

Gene pyramiding and gene introgression are vital strategies in the ongoing battle against crop diseases, offering a more durable approach than relying on single resistance genes. While conventional breeding forms the foundation, the integration of modern biotechnological tools like MAS and genome editing promises to accelerate the development of disease-resistant cultivars. Addressing challenges related to genetic diversity, regulatory hurdles, and equitable access will be crucial for ensuring food security and sustainable agriculture in the face of evolving pathogen threats.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

R-gene
Resistance genes, genes that confer resistance to specific pathogens in plants. These genes typically encode proteins involved in recognizing and responding to pathogen effectors.
Linkage Drag
The unintentional inheritance of undesirable traits from the donor parent during breeding, which are genetically linked to the desired gene.

Key Statistics

Stem rust disease can cause yield losses of up to 30-70% in susceptible wheat varieties, highlighting the critical need for effective resistance strategies.

Source: CIMMYT reports

The use of marker-assisted selection (MAS) can reduce the breeding cycle time by 5-10 years compared to traditional phenotypic selection.

Source: FAO

Examples

CIMMYT’s role in wheat disease resistance

CIMMYT has been instrumental in developing and distributing rust-resistant wheat varieties to developing countries, contributing significantly to global food security. Their breeding programs heavily utilize MAS.

Rice Bacterial Blight Resistance

The introgression of bacterial blight resistance from <i>Oryza rufipogon</i> has been successfully implemented in several rice varieties across Asia, significantly reducing crop losses.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between gene pyramiding and simply using multiple varieties?

Using multiple varieties (sequential deployment) relies on pathogen populations lacking virulence to all varieties simultaneously. Gene pyramiding creates a single, inherently more resistant variety, reducing the risk of pathogen overcoming resistance through adaptation.

Why is introgression more challenging than gene pyramiding?

Introgression involves crossing more distantly related genetic material, leading to greater genetic incompatibility and requiring numerous backcrosses to eliminate unwanted traits from the donor parent.

Topics Covered

AgricultureGeneticsPlant BreedingCrop protection, breeding strategies, genetic diversity, disease management