Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
‘Smart Cities’ represent an urban development vision integrating information and communication technologies (ICT) and various data to improve operational efficiency, share information with citizens, and enhance quality of life. India launched the Smart Cities Mission in 2015, aiming to develop 100 smart cities across the country. However, this focus on urban areas raises concerns about widening the gap with rural India. The question of whether prioritizing smart cities will exacerbate existing rural-urban differences, and the potential of initiatives like the Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas (PURA) and RURBAN Mission to bridge this divide, are crucial for balanced and inclusive development.
Understanding ‘Smart Cities’
Smart Cities are built on the principles of sustainability, economic development, and improved quality of life through the application of technology. Key components include smart governance, smart infrastructure (transport, energy, water), smart environment, and smart people (citizen engagement). The Smart Cities Mission in India focuses on retrofitting existing cities, redeveloping areas, and developing new greenfield cities.
Relevance for Urban Development in India
India faces significant urban challenges: rapid urbanization, inadequate infrastructure, pollution, traffic congestion, and service delivery deficits. Smart City initiatives offer potential solutions:
- Improved Infrastructure: Smart grids, intelligent traffic management systems, and efficient water distribution networks can enhance urban infrastructure.
- Enhanced Service Delivery: E-governance platforms, online citizen services, and data-driven decision-making can improve public service delivery.
- Sustainable Development: Focus on renewable energy, waste management, and green buildings promotes environmental sustainability.
- Economic Growth: Attracting investment, fostering innovation, and creating employment opportunities.
However, the implementation faces challenges like high costs, data privacy concerns, lack of skilled manpower, and potential for digital exclusion.
Will it Increase Rural-Urban Differences?
The exclusive focus on Smart Cities can potentially widen rural-urban disparities. Concentrating resources and investment in urban areas may lead to:
- Migration: Improved opportunities in smart cities can accelerate rural-urban migration, straining urban infrastructure and depleting rural areas of skilled labor.
- Economic Disparity: The economic benefits of smart city development may not trickle down to rural areas, exacerbating income inequality.
- Digital Divide: Limited access to technology and digital literacy in rural areas can further marginalize rural populations.
According to the 2011 Census, approximately 68.84% of India’s population resides in rural areas. Neglecting rural development in favor of smart cities could create a two-tiered system, hindering inclusive growth.
The Case for ‘Smart Villages’ – PURA and RURBAN Mission
Recognizing the need for balanced development, the concept of ‘Smart Villages’ gains prominence. This involves leveraging technology to improve rural livelihoods, infrastructure, and quality of life.
PURA (Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas)
Launched in 2003 by Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, PURA aimed to provide urban-like amenities and infrastructure in rural areas, focusing on four components: physical, electronic, knowledge, and institutional connectivity. While the initial implementation faced challenges, the core idea remains relevant.
RURBAN Mission (Synergizing Rural and Urban Development)
Launched in 2016, the RURBAN Mission aims to stimulate local economic development, enhance livelihood opportunities, and improve the quality of life in rural areas by leveraging technology and infrastructure development. It focuses on cluster-based development, identifying 300 rural clusters across the country.
Comparison of PURA and RURBAN:
| Feature | PURA | RURBAN |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Providing urban amenities | Cluster-based integrated development |
| Approach | Individual village-centric | Cluster of villages |
| Scale | Limited scale | Larger scale, 300 clusters |
| Implementation | Challenges in coordination | More structured implementation |
Smart Villages, through initiatives like RURBAN, can address rural challenges by promoting rural entrepreneurship, skill development, and access to markets. This can reduce migration pressure and foster inclusive growth.
Conclusion
While Smart Cities hold promise for improving urban living, a balanced approach is crucial. Prioritizing urban development at the expense of rural areas risks exacerbating existing inequalities. The ‘Smart Villages’ concept, embodied in missions like PURA and RURBAN, offers a viable pathway to bridge the rural-urban divide by leveraging technology and infrastructure to enhance rural livelihoods and quality of life. A holistic strategy that integrates both Smart Cities and Smart Villages is essential for achieving sustainable and inclusive development in India.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.