Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
John Locke, a prominent figure of British Empiricism, sought to understand the origins of human knowledge. In his *An Essay Concerning Human Understanding* (1689), he distinguished between ‘primary’ and ‘secondary’ qualities of objects. Primary qualities – solidity, extension, figure, motion, and number – are inherent in the object itself and are mathematically measurable. However, Locke recognized that our sensory experience is not limited to these objective properties. This led him to introduce the concept of ‘secondary qualities’ – colour, taste, smell, sound, and texture – which are not inherent in the object but are powers to produce sensations in us. The introduction of secondary qualities was not merely descriptive but a logically necessary step in Locke’s attempt to reconcile our subjective experience with an objective reality.
The Problem of Representing Reality
Locke’s philosophical project aimed to determine the extent to which our knowledge accurately reflects the external world. He argued against innate ideas, positing that all knowledge originates from experience. However, if knowledge comes solely from experience, how can we be sure that our perceptions correspond to the actual properties of objects? Locke identified two types of qualities to address this issue.
Primary Qualities: Objective and Resembling
Primary qualities, according to Locke, are intrinsic to objects and exist independently of any perceiver. These qualities are mathematically measurable and are, therefore, capable of accurately representing the object as it truly is. For example, the size and shape of a table are primary qualities. Locke believed that our perceptions of primary qualities *resemble* the qualities themselves, providing a reliable basis for knowledge.
Secondary Qualities: Subjective and Causing Sensations
However, Locke observed that qualities like colour, taste, and smell vary depending on the perceiver. A red apple appears red to a normal observer, but might not be perceived as such by someone with colour blindness. These qualities are not inherent in the apple itself; rather, they are the *powers* of the apple to produce sensations in our minds. This is where the logical necessity arises. Locke couldn’t simply dismiss these sensations as illusory because they are a fundamental part of our experience.
The Logical Necessity of Secondary Qualities
Locke introduced secondary qualities to explain how our minds interact with the world and how sensations arise. He argued that these qualities are not resemblances of anything existing in the objects themselves, but rather are produced by the interaction of our sensory organs with the primary qualities of objects.
- Powers to Produce Sensations: Secondary qualities are not properties *of* the object, but powers *in* the object to cause certain sensations in us. For example, redness isn’t a property of the apple, but its power to reflect light in a way that stimulates our visual system.
- Subjectivity of Experience: Recognizing the subjective nature of these sensations was crucial. Locke acknowledged that different perceivers might experience different sensations from the same object, depending on their individual constitutions.
- Completing the Picture: Without secondary qualities, Locke’s account of experience would be incomplete. Our everyday experience is filled with colour, taste, and smell, and to ignore these would be to ignore a significant part of reality as we perceive it.
Illustrative Example: Heat
Locke uses the example of heat to illustrate this point. He argues that heat is not a quality inherent in an object, but rather the power of that object to produce a sensation of warmth in us. The object possesses particles in rapid motion (a primary quality), and this motion causes a sensation of heat when it interacts with our sensory organs. The sensation itself is a secondary quality.
Therefore, the introduction of secondary qualities wasn’t a concession to skepticism, but a logical consequence of Locke’s commitment to empiricism and his attempt to provide a coherent account of how we acquire knowledge about the world. It allowed him to acknowledge the subjective element in our experience without abandoning the possibility of objective knowledge based on primary qualities.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Locke’s introduction of secondary qualities was a logically necessary step in his epistemological framework. It allowed him to account for the richness and diversity of our sensory experience while maintaining a distinction between the objective reality of primary qualities and the subjective nature of our perceptions. By framing secondary qualities as powers to produce sensations, Locke bridged the gap between the external world and the internal world of the mind, offering a nuanced and influential account of human knowledge.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.