UPSC MainsPHILOSOPHY-PAPER-II201610 Marks150 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q16.

“World-religion is a spiritualistic and humanistic composite.” Evaluate.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of ‘world-religion’ as a philosophical concept. The approach should involve defining world-religion, exploring its spiritualistic elements (transcendence, faith, ethics), and its humanistic aspects (reason, social justice, human dignity). The answer should evaluate the claim by presenting arguments for and against the composite nature, referencing relevant philosophical traditions and historical developments. A balanced structure, acknowledging complexities, is crucial.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The term ‘world-religion’ often refers to major religious traditions – Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism, Judaism, and others – that have spread globally and significantly impacted diverse cultures. However, philosophically, it signifies more than just geographical reach. It represents a convergence of spiritual yearning and human ethical concerns. The assertion that world-religion is a “spiritualistic and humanistic composite” suggests a harmonious blend of faith-based transcendence and reason-driven moral action. This evaluation necessitates examining whether this composite truly reflects the nature of these religions, or if inherent tensions exist between these two facets.

Spiritualistic Foundations of World Religions

The ‘spiritualistic’ component of world-religions centers around the belief in a reality beyond the material world. This often manifests as:

  • Transcendence: Most world-religions posit a higher power, ultimate reality (Brahman in Hinduism, God in Abrahamic faiths, Nirvana in Buddhism), or a state of being beyond ordinary experience.
  • Faith & Revelation: Reliance on faith, divine revelation (e.g., the Bible, the Quran, the Vedas), or mystical experience as sources of knowledge.
  • Ritual & Worship: Practices like prayer, meditation, sacrifice, and pilgrimage aimed at connecting with the divine or achieving spiritual liberation.
  • Ethics rooted in the Divine: Moral codes often derive from divine commandments or principles (Ten Commandments, Islamic Sharia, Buddhist precepts).

For example, the concept of *moksha* in Hinduism, liberation from the cycle of rebirth, is fundamentally spiritualistic, requiring detachment from worldly desires and realization of one’s true self.

Humanistic Dimensions of World Religions

Alongside the spiritual, world-religions exhibit strong ‘humanistic’ elements, emphasizing human value and social responsibility:

  • Emphasis on Compassion & Empathy: Core teachings often promote compassion, kindness, and empathy towards all beings (e.g., the Golden Rule found in various religions).
  • Social Justice & Equality: Many religions advocate for social justice, equality, and the alleviation of suffering (e.g., Islamic *Zakat*, Buddhist emphasis on non-violence and social harmony).
  • Ethical Reasoning & Moral Development: Religions provide frameworks for ethical decision-making and moral development, encouraging individuals to act responsibly.
  • Human Dignity & Worth: The inherent dignity and worth of every human being is often affirmed, regardless of social status or background.

The teachings of Jesus Christ, focusing on love, forgiveness, and service to others, exemplify the humanistic dimension of Christianity. Similarly, the Buddhist concept of *metta* (loving-kindness) promotes universal compassion.

Evaluating the Composite Nature: Tensions and Synergies

While the spiritualistic and humanistic aspects often complement each other, tensions can arise:

Aspect Synergy Tension
Faith vs. Reason Faith can inspire ethical action; reason can clarify religious principles. Blind faith can lead to intolerance; rationalism can reject spiritual experience.
Transcendence vs. Immanence Focus on the divine can motivate social engagement. Overemphasis on the afterlife can devalue earthly concerns.
Dogma vs. Individualism Shared beliefs can foster community. Rigid dogma can stifle individual freedom and critical thinking.

However, many religious thinkers have attempted to reconcile these tensions. For instance, Liberation Theology in Latin America integrates Christian faith with a commitment to social justice, demonstrating a harmonious blend of spiritual and humanistic concerns. Similarly, the Baháʼí Faith explicitly promotes the unity of religion and science.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the assertion that world-religion is a “spiritualistic and humanistic composite” holds considerable validity. While inherent tensions exist between faith and reason, transcendence and immanence, the most impactful world-religions consistently demonstrate a dynamic interplay between these elements. The enduring appeal of these traditions lies precisely in their ability to address both the deepest spiritual longings of humanity and its practical needs for ethical guidance and social cohesion. Moving forward, fostering interfaith dialogue and emphasizing shared humanistic values will be crucial for navigating a complex and interconnected world.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Transcendence
The state of being beyond the range of normal or merely physical human experience.
Immanence
The state of being present everywhere at the same time; inherent in all things.

Key Statistics

As of 2020, approximately 84% of the world’s population identified with a religious group.

Source: Pew Research Center, “Religion in the World” (2020)

Globally, Christianity has the largest number of adherents (approximately 2.4 billion), followed by Islam (approximately 1.9 billion).

Source: Statista, “Number of Christians worldwide from 2010 to 2020” (2023)

Examples

The Dalai Lama

The Dalai Lama exemplifies the integration of spiritual practice (Buddhist meditation) with a commitment to human rights, peace, and compassion.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a person be spiritual without being religious?

Yes, spirituality refers to a personal search for meaning and purpose, while religion involves a specific system of beliefs and practices. One can be spiritual without adhering to any organized religion.

Topics Covered

ReligionPhilosophyWorld ReligionSpiritualityHumanismComparative Religion