UPSC MainsECONOMICS-PAPER-II201710 Marks150 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q19.

Do you think the recent appreciation of Indian currency is harming India's exports? Can it have a beneficial side too? Explain in brief.

How to Approach

The question requires a balanced assessment of the impact of Indian Rupee (INR) appreciation on exports. The answer should begin by acknowledging the generally negative correlation between currency appreciation and exports. However, it must also explore potential benefits, such as cheaper imports of raw materials and capital goods. Structure the answer by first explaining the negative impacts, then the positive impacts, and finally, provide a nuanced conclusion. Include relevant data and examples to support the arguments.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The Indian Rupee has witnessed appreciation against major global currencies, particularly the US Dollar, in recent times, driven by factors like strong foreign portfolio inflows, narrowing trade deficit, and global risk aversion. While a strengthening Rupee reflects India’s economic resilience, it raises concerns about the competitiveness of Indian exports. Historically, a stronger domestic currency makes exports more expensive for foreign buyers, potentially impacting export volumes and revenue. This necessitates a careful examination of whether the recent appreciation is indeed harming India’s exports and if any beneficial side effects exist.

Harmful Effects on Exports

Currency appreciation directly impacts export competitiveness. When the INR appreciates, Indian goods become relatively more expensive for buyers in other countries, leading to:

  • Reduced Export Volume: Higher prices can decrease demand for Indian exports, especially in price-sensitive markets. Sectors like textiles, leather goods, and gems & jewellery, which rely heavily on price competitiveness, are particularly vulnerable.
  • Lower Export Revenue: Even if export volumes remain stable, exporters receive fewer dollars (or other foreign currencies) for each unit sold, reducing their revenue in INR terms.
  • Impact on MSMEs: Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs), which often have limited hedging capabilities, are disproportionately affected by currency fluctuations.
  • Increased Trade Deficit (potentially): While a stronger Rupee can reduce import costs, if export growth slows significantly, it could widen the trade deficit.

For instance, in 2023-24, India’s engineering goods exports faced headwinds due to the appreciating Rupee, impacting their growth rate (EEPC India data). The pharmaceutical sector, while less price-sensitive, also experiences some impact on profitability.

Beneficial Side Effects

Despite the challenges, Rupee appreciation can also offer certain benefits:

  • Cheaper Imports: A stronger Rupee reduces the cost of imported raw materials, intermediate goods, and capital goods. This benefits industries that rely heavily on imports, such as electronics manufacturing and automobile production.
  • Reduced Inflation: Lower import costs can help contain inflationary pressures in the economy.
  • Increased Purchasing Power: A stronger Rupee increases the purchasing power of Indian consumers, allowing them to buy more imported goods.
  • Attracts Foreign Investment: A stable and appreciating currency can signal economic strength and attract foreign direct investment (FDI).
  • Reduced External Debt Burden: For companies with external debt denominated in foreign currencies, a stronger Rupee reduces the burden of repayment.

The IT sector, which earns a significant portion of its revenue in foreign currencies, benefits from a stronger Rupee as it reduces the cost of domestic operations. Similarly, the automobile industry benefits from cheaper imports of components.

Mitigating Factors & Government Response

The extent to which Rupee appreciation harms exports depends on several mitigating factors:

  • Global Demand: Strong global demand can offset the negative impact of a stronger Rupee.
  • Hedging Strategies: Exporters who effectively hedge their currency risk can minimize the impact of fluctuations.
  • Government Policies: The government can implement policies to support exporters, such as export incentives and infrastructure development.

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) often intervenes in the foreign exchange market to manage volatility and prevent excessive appreciation. The government also provides export promotion schemes like the Remission of Duties and Taxes on Exported Products (RoDTEP) scheme to offset the impact of taxes and duties on exports.

Impact of Rupee Appreciation Positive Effects Negative Effects
Imports Cheaper raw materials & capital goods -
Exports - Reduced competitiveness, lower revenue
Inflation Reduced inflationary pressure -
Investment Attracts FDI -

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the recent appreciation of the Indian Rupee poses challenges to export competitiveness, particularly for price-sensitive sectors and MSMEs, it also offers potential benefits through cheaper imports and reduced inflation. The overall impact depends on a complex interplay of global demand, hedging strategies, and government policies. A nuanced approach involving proactive export promotion measures, effective currency management by the RBI, and continued focus on enhancing the competitiveness of Indian industries is crucial to maximize the benefits and mitigate the risks associated with a strengthening Rupee.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Real Effective Exchange Rate (REER)
REER is the weighted average of bilateral exchange rates, adjusted for relative price levels of the home and trading partner countries. It provides a more comprehensive measure of a country’s exchange rate competitiveness than the nominal exchange rate.
Hedging
Hedging is a risk management strategy used to offset potential losses from adverse currency movements. Exporters can use financial instruments like forward contracts and options to lock in exchange rates and protect their revenue.

Key Statistics

India’s merchandise exports were valued at $451.03 billion in FY23 (April-March), showing a decline of 0.74% compared to FY22.

Source: Department of Commerce, Government of India (as of knowledge cutoff - 2024)

India’s trade deficit widened to $26.81 billion in November 2023, partly attributed to the impact of a stronger Rupee on export competitiveness.

Source: Commerce Ministry data (as of knowledge cutoff - 2024)

Examples

Textile Industry Impact

The textile industry, a major export earner for India, faced significant challenges in 2023 due to the appreciating Rupee. This led to reduced orders from key markets like the US and Europe, forcing some manufacturers to offer discounts to maintain market share.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Rupee appreciation always lead to a decline in exports?

Not necessarily. The impact depends on factors like global demand, the elasticity of demand for Indian exports, and the extent to which exporters can hedge their currency risk. A strong Rupee can be offset by other positive factors.

Topics Covered

EconomyInternational TradeFinanceExchange RateExportsTrade Balance