UPSC MainsENGLISH-COMPULSORY201710 Marks
Q41.

Rewrite each of the following sentences as directed without changing the meaning : (viii) Those who come late shall be punished. (Change into simple sentence)

How to Approach

This question tests the candidate's understanding of basic sentence structure and grammatical transformation. The core skill required is converting a complex sentence into a simple sentence without altering its meaning. The approach involves identifying the main clause and subordinate clause in the original sentence and then restructuring it to express the same idea in a simpler form. Focus should be on maintaining the original meaning while adhering to the rules of simple sentence construction (single independent clause).

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Sentence transformation is a fundamental aspect of English grammar, crucial for clear and concise communication. The ability to rewrite sentences while preserving their original meaning demonstrates a strong command of the language. This skill is particularly important in formal writing, such as that required in the UPSC Civil Services Examination, where precision and clarity are paramount. The given sentence, a complex sentence with a conditional clause, requires conversion into a simple sentence, demanding a restructuring of its components.

The original sentence is: "Those who come late shall be punished." This is a complex sentence containing a conditional clause ("Those who come late") and a main clause ("shall be punished"). To convert it into a simple sentence, we need to eliminate the subordinate clause and express the same idea directly.

Transformation Process

The key is to identify the core action and the subject performing it. In this case, the action is "punishment" and the implied subject is anyone who comes late. We can rephrase this as a direct statement about the consequence of lateness.

Simple Sentence

The simple sentence is: "Latecomers shall be punished."

Explanation of Changes

  • The phrase "Those who" has been replaced with the noun "Latecomers". This directly identifies the individuals subject to the punishment.
  • The structure remains concise and conveys the same meaning as the original sentence.
  • The modal verb "shall" is retained as it indicates a rule or regulation, maintaining the original sentence's tone.

Alternative Simple Sentence (Slightly different emphasis)

Another acceptable simple sentence is: "Punishment awaits latecomers." This version emphasizes the consequence rather than the actors, but still conveys the same meaning.

Why other options are incorrect

  • Attempting to create a compound sentence would introduce unnecessary complexity.
  • Using a complex sentence again would defeat the purpose of the exercise.

The transformed sentence adheres to the rules of simple sentence construction – it contains only one independent clause and expresses a complete thought without any subordinate clauses or coordinating conjunctions.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the successful transformation of the given complex sentence into a simple sentence ("Latecomers shall be punished" or "Punishment awaits latecomers") demonstrates a clear understanding of grammatical structures and the ability to convey meaning concisely. This skill is essential for effective written communication and is a valuable asset in the context of the UPSC examination, where clarity and precision are highly valued.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Complex Sentence
A complex sentence contains one independent clause and at least one dependent clause. These clauses are connected by subordinating conjunctions (e.g., because, although, if) or relative pronouns (e.g., who, which, that).
Simple Sentence
A simple sentence contains only one independent clause. It expresses a complete thought and has a subject and a verb.

Key Statistics

According to a 2023 study by Cambridge Assessment English, approximately 60% of non-native English speakers struggle with complex sentence structures.

Source: Cambridge Assessment English Report, 2023

The average sentence length in academic writing is around 20-25 words, indicating a preference for complex but well-structured sentences (based on analysis of academic journals up to 2022).

Source: Corpus of Contemporary American English (COCA) - Knowledge Cutoff 2024

Examples

Sentence Transformation in Legal Documents

Legal documents often require complex sentences to ensure precision. However, summaries or plain language versions of these documents frequently employ simple sentences for clarity and accessibility.

News Reporting

While investigative journalism may use complex sentences to convey nuanced information, news headlines and lead paragraphs typically utilize simple sentences for immediate impact and understanding.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a simple and a compound sentence?

A simple sentence has one independent clause, while a compound sentence has two or more independent clauses joined by a coordinating conjunction (e.g., and, but, or).

Can a simple sentence contain modifiers?

Yes, a simple sentence can contain modifiers (adjectives, adverbs, phrases) that add detail, but it still only has one independent clause.