UPSC MainsENGLISH-LITERATURE-PAPER-I201710 Marks150 Words
Q1.

The influence of Renaissance on at least two plays of Shakespeare ?

How to Approach

This question requires demonstrating an understanding of Renaissance humanism and its manifestation in Shakespeare’s plays. The answer should focus on identifying key Renaissance ideas (like individualism, human potential, classical learning) and illustrating how these are reflected in the themes, characters, and dramatic techniques of at least two plays. A structured approach – introducing the Renaissance, then analyzing specific plays – is crucial. Focus on textual evidence to support claims.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The Renaissance, a transformative period in European history spanning roughly from the 14th to the 17th centuries, marked a revival of interest in classical art, literature, and philosophy. This ‘rebirth’ fostered a new humanist perspective, emphasizing human potential, individual achievement, and earthly life, shifting focus away from solely religious dogma. William Shakespeare, writing during the English Renaissance, profoundly absorbed these intellectual currents, weaving them into the fabric of his dramatic works. This answer will explore the influence of Renaissance thought on *Hamlet* and *The Merchant of Venice*, demonstrating how these plays embody key Renaissance ideals.

Renaissance Humanism and its Core Tenets

Renaissance humanism wasn’t a rejection of religion, but rather a broadening of intellectual horizons. Key tenets included:

  • Individualism: Emphasis on the unique worth and potential of the individual.
  • Human Potential: Belief in the capacity of humans to achieve greatness in various fields.
  • Classical Learning: Revival of interest in Greek and Roman literature, philosophy, and art.
  • Secularism: A growing focus on worldly matters alongside religious concerns.

Influence on *Hamlet*

Shakespeare’s *Hamlet* (c. 1600-1601) is deeply imbued with Renaissance introspection and philosophical questioning. The play’s protagonist, Prince Hamlet, embodies the Renaissance ‘thinking man’ grappling with existential dilemmas.

The ‘To be or not to be’ Soliloquy

The famous soliloquy exemplifies Renaissance humanism’s focus on individual agency and the contemplation of life’s meaning. Hamlet’s consideration of suicide isn’t simply a religious transgression, but a rational weighing of the burdens of existence against the unknown of the afterlife. This reflects a shift towards individual responsibility and a questioning of traditional authority.

Humanism and the Ideal Renaissance Prince

Hamlet’s intellectual curiosity, his pursuit of knowledge, and his artistic sensibilities (he’s a scholar and appreciates theatre) align with the Renaissance ideal of the ‘universal man’. However, his inability to act decisively, his melancholic temperament, and his moral complexities also represent a darker side of Renaissance individualism – the potential for paralysis and self-destruction.

Influence on *The Merchant of Venice*

*The Merchant of Venice* (c. 1596-1598) showcases Renaissance concerns with commerce, wealth, and social status, alongside explorations of justice, mercy, and prejudice.

The Rise of Merchant Class & Economic Humanism

The play’s focus on Antonio, a merchant, and the bustling world of Venetian trade reflects the growing economic power of the merchant class during the Renaissance. This economic activity is linked to a form of ‘economic humanism’ – the belief that human ingenuity and enterprise could improve the material conditions of life. The play’s exploration of loans, contracts, and financial risk demonstrates a Renaissance fascination with the practicalities of commerce.

Portia and the Classical Ideal of Female Education

Portia’s intelligence, eloquence, and legal acumen are remarkable for the period. Her ability to disguise herself as a male lawyer and successfully defend Antonio in court demonstrates a Renaissance appreciation for female intellectual capacity, albeit within the constraints of societal norms. Her education and wit align with the humanist emphasis on cultivating the mind, regardless of gender. The play subtly challenges conventional gender roles, reflecting Renaissance debates about women’s education.

Comparison Table

Play Renaissance Influence Specific Example
Hamlet Individualism, Existentialism, Human Potential “To be or not to be” soliloquy – contemplation of life and death
The Merchant of Venice Economic Humanism, Classical Learning, Social Mobility Portia’s legal expertise and disguise – showcasing female intellect

Conclusion

In conclusion, Shakespeare’s plays are not merely dramatic narratives but profound reflections of the intellectual and cultural ferment of the Renaissance. *Hamlet* and *The Merchant of Venice*, among others, demonstrate how Renaissance humanism – with its emphasis on individualism, human potential, and classical learning – shaped Shakespeare’s characters, themes, and dramatic techniques. Shakespeare’s genius lay in his ability to both embrace and critique these Renaissance ideals, creating works that continue to resonate with audiences centuries later.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Humanism
A philosophical stance emphasizing the value and agency of human beings, individually and collectively, and generally preferring critical thinking and evidence (rationalism, empiricism) over established doctrine or faith.
Secularism
Indifference to or rejection of religious belief and practice, or a focus on worldly matters rather than spiritual ones.

Key Statistics

During the Renaissance, literacy rates in Italian city-states rose from approximately 1% in 1300 to around 10-15% by 1500.

Source: Burckhardt, Jacob. *The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy* (1860).

The number of books printed in Europe increased from approximately 20 million in the 15th century to over 200 million in the 16th century, largely due to the invention of the printing press by Johannes Gutenberg in 1440.

Source: Eisenstein, Elizabeth L. *The Printing Revolution in Early Modern Europe* (1983).

Examples

Leonardo da Vinci

Leonardo da Vinci, a quintessential Renaissance figure, embodied the ideal of the ‘universal man’ through his mastery of painting, sculpture, architecture, science, engineering, and anatomy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was Shakespeare a devoutly religious writer?

Shakespeare’s religious beliefs are a matter of scholarly debate. While his plays contain numerous religious allusions, they also demonstrate a critical and questioning attitude towards religious dogma, reflecting the broader intellectual climate of the Renaissance.

Topics Covered

LiteratureHistoryShakespearean dramaRenaissance periodLiterary movements