Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
Derwent Whittlesey, in 1936, proposed a classification of agricultural regions based on prevailing farm practices, rather than just the crops grown. He identified eleven major agricultural regions – Pastoral Nomadism, Shifting Cultivation, Intensive Subsistence Agriculture (with wet rice dominant and non-rice farming), Monsoon Agriculture, Plantation Agriculture, Mediterranean Agriculture, Commercial Grain Farming, Livestock Ranching, Commercial Dairy Farming, Highland Farming, and Specialized Agriculture. While agricultural landscapes have evolved significantly since then, Whittlesey’s framework remains remarkably relevant in understanding the spatial organization of agricultural activities globally, providing a foundational understanding of regional agricultural characteristics.
Whittlesey’s Regions and Their Contemporary Relevance
Despite advancements in technology and globalization, Whittlesey’s regions continue to exhibit recognizable patterns, albeit with modifications.
1. Intensive Subsistence Agriculture (Wet Rice Dominant)
This region, characterized by high population density and small landholdings, remains dominant in East, South, and Southeast Asia. While mechanization has increased in some areas (e.g., use of tractors in Punjab, India), the fundamental practice of intensive rice cultivation persists. The Green Revolution (1960s onwards) increased yields but didn’t fundamentally alter the regional characteristics.
2. Plantation Agriculture
Regions dedicated to large-scale monoculture of crops like tea, coffee, rubber, and sugarcane, primarily in tropical areas, continue to exist. Though facing challenges from fluctuating commodity prices and labor issues, plantations remain significant in countries like India, Indonesia, and Brazil. Modern plantations are increasingly adopting sustainable practices and diversifying crops.
3. Commercial Grain Farming
The Prairies of North America, the Steppes of Eurasia, and the Pampas of Argentina continue to be major producers of wheat, corn, and other grains. While technology has dramatically increased yields (e.g., genetically modified crops, precision farming), the core function of large-scale grain production for the global market remains unchanged. However, climate change is posing a significant threat to these regions.
4. Livestock Ranching
Large-scale cattle ranching persists in regions like Argentina, Brazil, and parts of the United States. While ranching practices have evolved (e.g., feedlots, improved breeding techniques), the fundamental characteristic of extensive grazing remains. Deforestation associated with ranching is a major environmental concern.
5. Pastoral Nomadism
Although shrinking in extent due to land alienation and settlement policies, pastoral nomadism continues in parts of Africa, the Middle East, and Central Asia. Herding communities still rely on seasonal migration with livestock, though increasingly facing challenges from climate change, conflict, and limited access to resources. Government interventions often aim to sedentarize these communities, with mixed results.
6. Mediterranean Agriculture
Regions bordering the Mediterranean Sea, as well as parts of California, Chile, and South Africa, continue to specialize in horticulture (fruits, vegetables, olives, grapes) and viticulture. Irrigation and modern farming techniques have expanded production, but the climate and characteristic crops remain central to the region’s agricultural identity.
Modifications and Challenges
While Whittlesey’s regions remain relevant, several factors have led to modifications:
- Globalization: Increased trade and interconnectedness have led to the introduction of new crops and farming techniques in many regions.
- Technological Advancements: Mechanization, irrigation, fertilizers, and genetic engineering have increased productivity and altered land use patterns.
- Climate Change: Shifting rainfall patterns, increased temperatures, and extreme weather events are impacting agricultural productivity and forcing adaptation strategies.
- Urbanization: Expansion of urban areas is encroaching on agricultural land, leading to land-use conflicts.
| Whittlesey’s Region | Contemporary Modification |
|---|---|
| Shifting Cultivation | Decreasing area due to deforestation and government policies; intensification of practices where it persists. |
| Commercial Dairy Farming | Increased scale of operations, automation, and focus on value-added products. |
| Highland Farming | Terracing and irrigation techniques adapted to address slope and water availability. |
Conclusion
Whittlesey’s agricultural regions, though formulated nearly a century ago, provide a valuable framework for understanding the spatial distribution of agricultural activities. While globalization, technological advancements, and climate change have introduced modifications, the core principles of his classification – based on prevailing farm practices – remain remarkably relevant. The framework continues to be useful for regional planning, agricultural policy formulation, and understanding the complex interplay between human activities and the environment. Recognizing these enduring patterns is crucial for addressing contemporary challenges in food security and sustainable agriculture.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.