UPSC MainsHISTORY-PAPER-II201710 Marks150 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q17.

Critically examine the following statements in about 150 words each : "The roots of the Chartist movement in Great Britain were partly political and partly economic."

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of the Chartist movement. The approach should be to first define Chartism, then dissect its political demands (like universal male suffrage, secret ballot) and economic grievances (poverty, unemployment, poor working conditions). The answer should demonstrate how these two aspects were intertwined and mutually reinforcing, rather than separate. A chronological structure, highlighting key events and phases of the movement, will be effective. Focus on providing specific examples to illustrate the points.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The Chartist movement, flourishing in Britain from 1838 to 1848, was a working-class movement for political and social reform. Named after the People’s Charter of 1838, it aimed to secure political rights for the working classes, who were largely disenfranchised under the existing parliamentary system. However, to view Chartism solely as a political movement would be an oversimplification. The movement’s origins were deeply rooted in the socio-economic hardships faced by the working population during the Industrial Revolution, making it a complex interplay of political aspiration and economic desperation. This answer will critically examine the intertwined political and economic roots of the Chartist movement.

Political Roots of Chartism

The political landscape of early 19th-century Britain was characterized by limited suffrage. The Reform Act of 1832, while expanding the electorate, still excluded a significant portion of the male population, particularly the working class. This exclusion fueled resentment and a demand for greater political representation. The six key demands of the People’s Charter – universal male suffrage, secret ballot, equal electoral districts, payment of MPs, annual parliaments, and abolition of property qualifications for MPs – were all aimed at addressing this political disenfranchisement.

  • Universal Male Suffrage: The core demand, aiming to give the working class a voice in Parliament.
  • Secret Ballot: To protect voters from intimidation by employers and landlords.
  • Annual Parliaments: To make Parliament more responsive to the needs of the people.

Economic Roots of Chartism

The Industrial Revolution, while bringing economic growth, also created immense social and economic problems. The factory system led to harsh working conditions, long hours, low wages, and widespread unemployment. The Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834, intended to reduce the cost of poor relief, was widely seen as punitive and inhumane, further exacerbating the suffering of the working class. These economic hardships provided fertile ground for the growth of Chartism.

  • The Hungry Forties: A period of economic depression and food shortages in the 1840s, significantly boosting Chartist support.
  • Factory Conditions: Exploitation of workers, particularly women and children, fueled discontent.
  • Poor Law Amendment Act 1834: Created workhouses with deliberately harsh conditions, increasing desperation.

The Interplay of Political and Economic Factors

The political and economic roots of Chartism were not separate but deeply intertwined. Economic hardship fueled the demand for political reform, as the working class believed that gaining political rights was the only way to address their economic grievances. The Chartist movement provided a platform for articulating these grievances and mobilizing support for political change. For example, the Newport Rising of 1839, a key Chartist event, was sparked by economic distress and a desire for political representation.

Furthermore, the movement’s leaders often framed their political demands in economic terms. They argued that universal suffrage would allow the working class to elect representatives who would champion their interests and enact legislation to improve their living conditions. The Chartist newspapers and pamphlets frequently highlighted both political injustices and economic hardships, demonstrating the interconnectedness of the two issues.

Political Grievances Economic Grievances
Limited Suffrage Low Wages
Lack of Representation Poor Working Conditions
Intimidation of Voters Unemployment
Unequal Electoral Districts Harsh Poor Laws

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Chartist movement was undeniably rooted in both political and economic factors. While the desire for political rights – enshrined in the People’s Charter – was central to the movement’s aims, these demands were fundamentally driven by the economic hardships faced by the working class. The movement’s success lay in its ability to articulate and mobilize support around this intersection of political aspiration and economic desperation. Although Chartism ultimately failed to achieve its immediate goals, it laid the groundwork for future reforms and significantly contributed to the expansion of democracy in Britain.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Chartism
A working-class movement in Britain from 1838 to 1848 advocating for political and social reforms, primarily through the six points outlined in the People’s Charter.
Universal Male Suffrage
The principle that all adult men should have the right to vote, regardless of property ownership or other qualifications.

Key Statistics

By 1842, the National Charter Association claimed over 3 million supporters, demonstrating the widespread appeal of the movement.

Source: Ashton, T.S. (1964). The Economic Interpretation of the Chartists.

Between 1838 and 1848, over 3.3 million signatures were collected on Chartist petitions to Parliament, demonstrating the breadth of support for the movement.

Source: Royden Harrison, *The Condition of Labour 1800-1914* (1972)

Examples

The Newport Rising

In November 1839, Chartists led by John Frost marched on Newport, Wales, demanding the release of imprisoned Chartists. The uprising was brutally suppressed by the authorities, resulting in numerous deaths and arrests, highlighting the government’s response to Chartist agitation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the Chartist movement ultimately fail?

The Chartist movement failed due to a combination of factors, including internal divisions, government repression, and the improving economic conditions of the mid-1840s, which reduced the urgency of economic grievances.

Topics Covered

HistoryPolitical ScienceBritish HistoryChartismSocial Movements