UPSC MainsPUBLIC-ADMINISTRATION-PAPER-I201720 Marks
Q13.

Liberalisation, privatisation and globalisation have transformed the nature of development administration." Discuss.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of the evolution of development administration in India post-1991. The answer should trace the shift from a state-led, welfare-oriented approach to a market-driven, efficiency-focused one. Key areas to cover include the impact on administrative structures, functions, and ethics. Structure the answer chronologically, outlining the pre-liberalisation scenario, the changes brought about by LPG reforms, and the resultant transformation in development administration. Include examples of specific sectors and policies.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Development administration, historically focused on state-led economic planning and social welfare, underwent a significant metamorphosis with the initiation of economic reforms in 1991. The adoption of Liberalisation, Privatisation, and Globalisation (LPG) marked a paradigm shift, moving away from a restrictive, centrally controlled system towards a more open, competitive, and market-oriented economy. This transition fundamentally altered the role of public administration, demanding a reorientation of its functions, structures, and ethos. The reforms aimed to enhance efficiency, promote private sector participation, and integrate India with the global economy, thereby reshaping the very nature of development administration.

Pre-Liberalisation Development Administration (Before 1991)

Prior to 1991, development administration in India was largely characterized by a strong state presence. The Planning Commission (established in 1950) played a central role in formulating five-year plans, directing resource allocation, and overseeing development projects. The administrative system was heavily bureaucratic, with a focus on regulation, control, and public sector dominance. Key features included:

  • Import Substitution Industrialisation (ISI): Emphasis on domestic production and protection from foreign competition.
  • Public Sector Enterprises (PSEs): Dominance of state-owned enterprises in key sectors like steel, energy, and banking.
  • Licence Raj: Extensive licensing requirements for businesses, leading to bureaucratic delays and corruption.
  • Welfare State Orientation: Focus on social welfare programs and poverty alleviation.

The LPG Reforms and their Impact

The economic crisis of 1991 prompted the Indian government to undertake sweeping economic reforms, commonly known as LPG. These reforms had a profound impact on development administration:

Liberalisation

Liberalisation involved dismantling regulatory controls, reducing tariffs, and easing restrictions on foreign investment. This led to:

  • Deregulation: Reduction in the number of industries requiring licenses.
  • Trade Liberalisation: Lowering of import tariffs and removal of export restrictions.
  • Increased Competition: Entry of private players into various sectors.

Privatisation

Privatisation involved transferring ownership and control of PSEs to the private sector. This aimed to improve efficiency, reduce fiscal burden, and promote competition. Methods included:

  • Disinvestment: Selling of government equity in PSEs.
  • Strategic Sale: Transfer of management control to private investors.
  • Closure: Winding up of loss-making PSEs.

Globalisation

Globalisation involved integrating the Indian economy with the global market. This led to:

  • Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): Increased inflow of foreign capital.
  • International Trade: Expansion of exports and imports.
  • Technological Transfer: Adoption of new technologies from abroad.

Transformation in Development Administration

The LPG reforms triggered a significant transformation in development administration:

  • Shift in Role: From a direct provider of goods and services to a facilitator and regulator.
  • Emphasis on Efficiency: Focus on cost-effectiveness, performance measurement, and accountability.
  • Decentralisation: Transfer of powers and responsibilities to lower levels of government (73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendment Acts, 1992-93).
  • Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs): Increased collaboration between the public and private sectors in infrastructure development and service delivery.
  • E-Governance: Adoption of information and communication technology (ICT) to improve transparency, efficiency, and citizen participation. (National e-Governance Plan launched in 2006)

Sectoral Impacts

The impact of LPG varied across different sectors:

Sector Pre-LPG Post-LPG
Telecom State monopoly (BSNL) Private sector participation, increased competition, mobile revolution
Banking Dominance of public sector banks Entry of private banks, financial sector reforms, improved efficiency
Infrastructure Public sector investment PPP models, private sector investment, increased capacity

Challenges and Concerns

Despite the benefits, the LPG reforms also posed challenges:

  • Increased Inequality: Widening gap between the rich and the poor.
  • Job Losses: Restructuring of PSEs led to unemployment.
  • Regional Disparities: Uneven distribution of benefits across different regions.
  • Corruption: Increased opportunities for corruption in the private sector.
  • Erosion of Welfare State: Reduced emphasis on social welfare programs.

Conclusion

Liberalisation, privatisation, and globalisation have undeniably transformed the nature of development administration in India. The shift from a state-controlled to a market-driven approach has brought about increased efficiency, competition, and economic growth. However, it has also created new challenges related to inequality, unemployment, and regional disparities. Moving forward, a balanced approach is needed, one that leverages the benefits of market forces while ensuring social justice and inclusive development. Strengthening regulatory mechanisms, investing in human capital, and promoting equitable distribution of resources are crucial for harnessing the full potential of the reformed development administration.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Liberalisation
The process of reducing restrictions on economic activity, such as trade, investment, and regulation, to promote competition and efficiency.
Privatisation
The transfer of ownership, management, or control of a public sector enterprise to the private sector.

Key Statistics

India's GDP growth rate increased from an average of 5.6% in the 1980s to 6.8% in the 1990s and further to 8.2% in the 2000s after the LPG reforms.

Source: World Bank Data (as of knowledge cutoff - 2023)

FDI inflows into India increased from US$ 0.2 billion in 1990-91 to US$ 84.8 billion in 2021-22, demonstrating the impact of globalisation on investment.

Source: Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT), Government of India (as of knowledge cutoff - 2023)

Examples

Air India Privatisation

The privatisation of Air India in January 2022, after decades of losses and government support, exemplifies the shift towards reducing the public sector's role and improving efficiency through private management. The Tata Group reacquired the airline.

Frequently Asked Questions

How did globalisation affect the role of the civil services?

Globalisation demanded a more skilled and adaptable civil service capable of navigating international trade agreements, attracting foreign investment, and managing cross-border issues. It also required greater emphasis on transparency, accountability, and ethical conduct.

Topics Covered

Public AdministrationEconomyDevelopment PolicyPublic Sector ReformGlobalisation