UPSC MainsSOCIOLOGY-PAPER-I201720 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q13.

Examine gender, ethnicity and race as major dimensions of social stratification.

How to Approach

This question requires a sociological understanding of social stratification and how gender, ethnicity, and race operate as its key dimensions. The answer should define social stratification, then systematically examine each dimension – gender, ethnicity, and race – detailing how they contribute to unequal access to resources and opportunities. Focus on theoretical perspectives (Marxist, Weberian, Functionalist) and provide real-world examples. A comparative approach highlighting intersections between these dimensions will strengthen the answer. Structure: Introduction, Gender as stratification, Ethnicity as stratification, Race as stratification, Intersections, Conclusion.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Social stratification refers to a system by which society ranks categories of people in a hierarchy. This ranking is based on differential access to valued resources like wealth, power, and prestige. While class, often linked to economic factors, is a significant component, stratification is multi-dimensional. Gender, ethnicity, and race are crucial axes along which societies are stratified, often intersecting with class to create complex systems of inequality. These dimensions aren’t merely individual characteristics but are socially constructed categories that carry inherent power dynamics and historical baggage, shaping life chances and opportunities. Understanding these dimensions is vital for analyzing social inequalities and formulating effective policies for social justice.

Gender as a Dimension of Social Stratification

Gender, as a social construct, profoundly impacts stratification. Historically and globally, patriarchal structures have systematically disadvantaged women, limiting their access to education, employment, political participation, and property ownership. This isn’t simply about biological differences but about socially assigned roles and expectations.

  • Marxist Perspective: Views gender inequality as rooted in the capitalist mode of production, where women’s labor is often undervalued or unpaid (reproductive labor).
  • Weberian Perspective: Highlights how gender intersects with class and status, creating different forms of life chances. A woman from a privileged class will experience gender inequality differently than one from a marginalized background.
  • Functionalist Perspective: (Though often criticized) suggests gender roles are functional for society, but fails to adequately explain the power imbalances inherent in these roles.

Examples: The gender pay gap (women earning less than men for comparable work), underrepresentation of women in leadership positions, and higher rates of gender-based violence are manifestations of gender-based stratification. In India, son preference leads to sex-selective abortions and skewed sex ratios, demonstrating a clear stratification based on gender.

Ethnicity as a Dimension of Social Stratification

Ethnicity refers to shared cultural practices, ancestry, language, and beliefs. Ethnic groups are often subjected to stratification based on perceived differences and historical power dynamics. This can manifest as discrimination, prejudice, and unequal access to resources.

  • Conflict Theory: Argues that ethnic stratification arises from competition for scarce resources between different ethnic groups.
  • Symbolic Interactionism: Focuses on how ethnic stereotypes and labels contribute to social inequality through everyday interactions.

Examples: The historical and ongoing discrimination against indigenous populations in many countries (e.g., Aboriginal Australians, Native Americans) exemplifies ethnic stratification. In India, caste, though officially outlawed, continues to operate as a form of ethnic stratification, impacting access to education, employment, and social mobility. The Rohingya crisis in Myanmar demonstrates extreme ethnic stratification leading to persecution and displacement.

Race as a Dimension of Social Stratification

Race, a socially constructed categorization based on perceived physical characteristics, has been a potent force in creating and maintaining social stratification. Historically, racial ideologies have been used to justify slavery, colonialism, and systemic discrimination.

  • Critical Race Theory: Examines how race and racism are embedded in legal systems and institutions, perpetuating racial inequality.
  • Postcolonial Theory: Analyzes the lasting effects of colonialism on racial hierarchies and power dynamics.

Examples: The transatlantic slave trade and its legacy of racial inequality in the Americas are prime examples of race-based stratification. Apartheid in South Africa was a legally enforced system of racial segregation and discrimination. Even in contemporary societies, racial minorities often face systemic disadvantages in areas like housing, education, and the criminal justice system. The Black Lives Matter movement highlights ongoing racial stratification and police brutality.

Intersections of Gender, Ethnicity, and Race

It’s crucial to recognize that these dimensions of stratification are not mutually exclusive; they intersect and create unique experiences of inequality. The concept of intersectionality, coined by Kimberlé Crenshaw, highlights how multiple social identities combine to create overlapping systems of discrimination or disadvantage.

Example: A Black woman may face discrimination based on both her race and her gender, experiencing a different form of inequality than a white woman or a Black man. Indigenous women often face heightened levels of violence and discrimination due to the intersection of their ethnicity, gender, and often, class.

Dimension Impact on Stratification Example
Gender Unequal access to resources, power imbalances, societal expectations. Gender pay gap, underrepresentation in STEM fields.
Ethnicity Discrimination, prejudice, limited opportunities based on cultural background. Caste-based discrimination in India, discrimination against indigenous populations.
Race Systemic racism, historical disadvantages, unequal treatment by institutions. Racial profiling, disparities in healthcare access.

Conclusion

In conclusion, gender, ethnicity, and race are fundamental dimensions of social stratification, shaping individuals’ life chances and perpetuating inequalities. These dimensions are not isolated but intersect, creating complex systems of disadvantage. Addressing these inequalities requires a multi-faceted approach that challenges discriminatory structures, promotes social justice, and recognizes the importance of intersectionality. Moving towards a more equitable society necessitates dismantling the historical and ongoing power imbalances embedded within these dimensions of stratification and fostering inclusive policies that ensure equal opportunities for all.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Social Stratification
A system by which a society ranks categories of people in a hierarchy, based on differential access to valued resources.
Intersectionality
A framework for understanding how aspects of a person's social and political identities combine to create unique modes of discrimination and privilege.

Key Statistics

According to the World Bank (2023), the global gender pay gap is estimated at 20%.

Source: World Bank, 2023

As per the National Family Health Survey-5 (2019-21), the sex ratio at birth in India is 929 females per 1000 males.

Source: National Family Health Survey-5 (NFHS-5)

Examples

Redlining in the US

A discriminatory practice where banks refused to offer mortgages or insurance to people living in predominantly minority neighborhoods, contributing to wealth disparities and racial segregation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is social stratification inevitable?

While some degree of social differentiation may be inherent in any society, the extent and rigidity of stratification are not inevitable. Social policies and movements can challenge and reduce inequalities.

Topics Covered

Social StratificationSocial InequalityGender InequalityRacial InequalityEthnic Inequality