UPSC MainsECONOMICS-PAPER-I201815 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q19.

How does rural economic activity create environmental degradation in developing economies?

How to Approach

This question requires a multi-faceted answer linking rural economic activities to environmental degradation, specifically within the context of developing economies. The answer should begin by defining key terms and establishing the context of rural economies in developing nations. It should then systematically explore various rural economic activities (agriculture, forestry, fishing, livestock) and how each contributes to environmental problems like deforestation, soil erosion, water pollution, and biodiversity loss. The answer should also discuss the underlying drivers – poverty, lack of regulation, and market failures. A structured approach, categorizing activities and their impacts, is recommended.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Rural economies in developing countries are often heavily reliant on natural resource-based activities for livelihoods. These economies, characterized by a significant proportion of the population engaged in agriculture, forestry, and related sectors, frequently face a trade-off between economic development and environmental sustainability. The pursuit of immediate economic gains often leads to unsustainable practices that degrade the environment, creating a vicious cycle of poverty and ecological damage. According to the World Bank (2023, knowledge cutoff), approximately 70% of the poor in developing countries live in rural areas and depend directly on natural resources. This dependence exacerbates the environmental consequences of rural economic activity.

Agricultural Practices and Environmental Degradation

Agriculture, the mainstay of many rural economies, is a significant driver of environmental degradation.

  • Intensive Farming: The Green Revolution, while increasing food production, led to overuse of chemical fertilizers and pesticides. This results in soil degradation, water pollution (eutrophication), and loss of biodiversity. For example, excessive fertilizer use in the Indo-Gangetic Plain has led to nitrate contamination of groundwater.
  • Deforestation for Agricultural Expansion: Clearing forests for agricultural land is a major cause of deforestation, particularly in regions like the Amazon rainforest and Southeast Asia. This leads to habitat loss, soil erosion, and climate change.
  • Irrigation and Waterlogging: Large-scale irrigation projects, while boosting agricultural output, can lead to waterlogging, salinization of soils, and depletion of groundwater resources. The Bhakra Nangal Dam project in India, while beneficial, has also contributed to waterlogging in surrounding areas.
  • Monoculture: The practice of growing a single crop over large areas reduces biodiversity and increases vulnerability to pests and diseases, necessitating increased pesticide use.

Forestry and Related Activities

Forests provide crucial ecosystem services, but their exploitation for economic gain often leads to environmental damage.

  • Illegal Logging: Unsustainable logging practices, particularly illegal logging, contribute to deforestation, habitat loss, and soil erosion.
  • Fuelwood Collection: In many developing countries, fuelwood is a primary source of energy for rural households. Over-reliance on fuelwood leads to deforestation and forest degradation.
  • Shifting Cultivation (Slash and Burn): While traditionally sustainable at low population densities, increased population pressure has made shifting cultivation a major driver of deforestation in regions like Northeast India and the Amazon.

Livestock and its Environmental Impacts

Livestock rearing, a significant rural economic activity, has substantial environmental consequences.

  • Overgrazing: Excessive grazing leads to soil compaction, erosion, and desertification.
  • Methane Emissions: Livestock, particularly ruminants like cattle, release significant amounts of methane, a potent greenhouse gas.
  • Deforestation for Pastureland: Forests are often cleared to create pastureland for livestock, contributing to deforestation and habitat loss.

Fishing and Aquaculture

While providing food and livelihoods, fishing and aquaculture can also degrade the environment.

  • Overfishing: Depletion of fish stocks due to overfishing disrupts marine ecosystems.
  • Destructive Fishing Practices: Practices like dynamite fishing and bottom trawling damage coral reefs and other marine habitats.
  • Aquaculture Pollution: Intensive aquaculture can lead to water pollution from fish waste, antibiotics, and feed.

Underlying Drivers of Environmental Degradation

Several underlying factors exacerbate the environmental impacts of rural economic activities:

  • Poverty: Poverty forces people to prioritize immediate economic needs over long-term environmental sustainability.
  • Lack of Secure Land Tenure: Without secure land rights, people are less likely to invest in sustainable land management practices.
  • Weak Governance and Regulation: Inadequate environmental regulations and weak enforcement allow unsustainable practices to continue.
  • Market Failures: The failure to internalize environmental costs in market prices encourages unsustainable resource use.
Rural Economic Activity Environmental Impact Example Region
Agriculture (Intensive) Soil degradation, water pollution, biodiversity loss Punjab, India
Forestry (Illegal Logging) Deforestation, habitat loss Indonesia
Livestock (Overgrazing) Soil erosion, desertification Sahel region, Africa
Fishing (Overfishing) Depletion of fish stocks South China Sea

Conclusion

Rural economic activity in developing economies is intrinsically linked to environmental degradation, driven by a complex interplay of economic pressures, institutional weaknesses, and market failures. Addressing this challenge requires a holistic approach that integrates environmental sustainability into rural development strategies. This includes promoting sustainable agricultural practices, strengthening environmental regulations, securing land tenure rights, and investing in alternative livelihood options. Ultimately, achieving sustainable rural development necessitates a shift towards a green economy that values ecosystem services and prioritizes long-term ecological health alongside economic growth.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Eutrophication
The process by which a body of water becomes enriched with nutrients, leading to excessive plant growth and oxygen depletion.
Tragedy of the Commons
An economic theory, popularized by Garrett Hardin, describing a situation in a shared-resource system where individuals acting independently and rationally according to their self-interest behave contrary to the best interests of the whole by depleting that resource.

Key Statistics

Globally, deforestation contributes to approximately 10-15% of greenhouse gas emissions.

Source: FAO, 2020 (knowledge cutoff)

Approximately 80% of global deforestation is driven by agricultural expansion.

Source: World Resources Institute, 2021 (knowledge cutoff)

Examples

Chipko Movement

The Chipko Movement in India (1973) demonstrated the power of community-based forest conservation in preventing deforestation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can economic growth and environmental sustainability coexist in rural areas?

Yes, through the adoption of sustainable practices, green technologies, and policies that incentivize environmental conservation. The concept of 'ecological modernization' suggests that economic growth can be decoupled from environmental degradation.

Topics Covered

EnvironmentEconomyDevelopment EconomicsEnvironmental IssuesRural DevelopmentSustainability