Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
W.B. Yeats’s “The Second Coming,” written in 1919 in the aftermath of World War I and amidst the Irish War of Independence, is a powerful and unsettling poem reflecting a sense of societal breakdown and the loss of traditional values. The lines, “The best lack all conviction, while the worst / Are full of passionate intensity,” encapsulate the poem’s central theme – the paralysis of reason and morality in the face of rising extremism. These lines aren’t merely a poetic observation but a stark commentary on the political and social climate of the time, where moderate voices were drowned out by fervent, often dangerous, ideologies. Understanding these lines requires delving into Yeats’s symbolism and the historical context that shaped his vision.
Context and Symbolism
Yeats wrote “The Second Coming” during a period of immense upheaval. The First World War had shattered the old order, and the Russian Revolution had introduced a new, radical ideology. Ireland was embroiled in its own struggle for independence, marked by violence and political polarization. Yeats, deeply concerned about these developments, used the imagery of a falcon losing its connection with the falconer to symbolize the disintegration of control and the unleashing of chaos.
Dissecting the Lines
“The best lack all conviction”
Here, “the best” refers to those possessing reason, moderation, and a commitment to traditional values. Yeats suggests that these individuals, overwhelmed by the scale of the crisis and disillusioned by the failures of the past, have lost their faith in established systems and their ability to effect change. They are paralyzed by doubt and unable to articulate a compelling vision for the future. This isn’t necessarily a moral failing, but rather a consequence of intellectual honesty and a recognition of the complexities of the world.
“while the worst / Are full of passionate intensity”
In contrast, “the worst” represents those driven by extreme ideologies – be it political fanaticism, religious zealotry, or destructive impulses. These individuals, unburdened by doubt or moral scruples, possess a fervent belief in their cause and are willing to pursue it with ruthless determination. Their “passionate intensity” is not rooted in reason or compassion, but in a blind faith and a desire for power. This intensity, while seemingly powerful, is ultimately destructive, leading to violence and societal collapse.
Historical and Contemporary Relevance
The lines resonated deeply with the anxieties of Yeats’s time, reflecting the rise of fascism and communism in Europe. The Bolsheviks, for example, were driven by a passionate, albeit ruthless, ideology, while moderate voices were often marginalized. The poem’s relevance extends beyond the early 20th century. We see echoes of this dynamic in contemporary political landscapes, where extremist groups often gain traction by exploiting fear and resentment, while moderate voices struggle to be heard.
Yeats’s Use of Imagery and Tone
Yeats’s use of stark contrasts and apocalyptic imagery reinforces the poem’s message. The image of the “rough beast” slouching towards Bethlehem symbolizes the birth of a new, terrifying era. The tone is one of foreboding and despair, reflecting Yeats’s pessimistic outlook on the future. He doesn’t offer solutions, but rather presents a chilling diagnosis of the ills afflicting modern society.
| Characteristic | “The Best” | “The Worst” |
|---|---|---|
| Motivation | Reason, Moderation, Traditional Values | Extreme Ideology, Power, Ruthlessness |
| State of Mind | Doubt, Disillusionment, Paralysis | Fervent Belief, Passionate Intensity, Blind Faith |
| Impact | Inability to Effect Change | Destructive Actions, Societal Collapse |
Conclusion
Yeats’s lines remain profoundly relevant today, serving as a cautionary tale about the dangers of extremism and the importance of reasoned discourse. The poem highlights the vulnerability of societies when moderate voices are silenced and passionate intensity trumps critical thinking. While the poem offers a bleak vision, it also compels us to confront the forces that threaten to undermine our values and to strive for a more balanced and rational approach to the challenges facing humanity. The enduring power of these lines lies in their ability to resonate across time and cultures, reminding us of the fragility of civilization and the constant need for vigilance.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.