UPSC MainsPOLITICAL-SCIENCE-INTERANATIONAL-RELATIONS-PAPER-I201820 Marks
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q26.

Examine the various causes of agrarian crisis in India.

How to Approach

This question requires a multi-faceted answer, examining the various factors contributing to the agrarian crisis in India. The approach should be structured around categorizing these causes – economic, socio-political, technological, and environmental. Focus on providing specific examples, government policies (and their failures), and relevant data. A chronological approach, tracing the evolution of the crisis, can also be effective. The answer should demonstrate an understanding of the interconnectedness of these factors.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The agrarian sector remains the backbone of the Indian economy, contributing approximately 18.8% to the country’s GDP (as of 2022-23) and employing over 40% of the workforce. However, it is plagued by a persistent and deepening crisis, manifested in farmer distress, declining agricultural productivity, and increasing rural indebtedness. This crisis isn’t a recent phenomenon; it’s a complex interplay of historical factors, policy failures, and emerging challenges like climate change. Understanding the root causes of this agrarian distress is crucial for formulating effective and sustainable solutions.

Economic Causes

Economic factors are arguably the most significant drivers of the agrarian crisis.

  • Land Fragmentation & Small Landholdings: The average landholding size in India is shrinking, currently around 1.2 hectares (NSSO 70th Round, 2013). This makes farming economically unviable, hindering economies of scale and investment in technology.
  • High Input Costs: Rising costs of seeds (especially Bt cotton), fertilizers, pesticides, and irrigation have squeezed farmers’ margins. The dependence on private companies for these inputs further exacerbates the problem.
  • Lack of Access to Credit: Many farmers, particularly small and marginal ones, are reliant on informal sources of credit (moneylenders) with exorbitant interest rates, leading to debt traps. While institutional credit has increased, it often doesn’t reach those who need it most.
  • Market Imperfections & Price Volatility: Farmers often receive low prices for their produce due to a lack of market infrastructure, inadequate storage facilities, and the dominance of intermediaries. Price volatility, especially for perishable goods, adds to their vulnerability.
  • Globalization & Liberalization: Post-1991 liberalization exposed Indian agriculture to global competition, impacting domestic prices and increasing import pressure.

Socio-Political Causes

Socio-political factors contribute significantly to the agrarian crisis, often exacerbating economic vulnerabilities.

  • Land Tenure Systems: Insecure land tenure, particularly for tenant farmers and sharecroppers, discourages investment and long-term planning.
  • Caste & Social Inequalities: Marginalized communities often face systemic discrimination in access to land, credit, and markets.
  • Policy Failures & Implementation Gaps: Numerous agricultural policies have been implemented, but their effectiveness has been hampered by poor implementation, corruption, and a lack of coordination between different government departments. The Green Revolution, while increasing production, also led to regional disparities and environmental degradation.
  • Weak Farmer Organizations: The lack of strong and effective farmer organizations limits their bargaining power and ability to advocate for their interests.

Technological Causes

While technology holds the potential to improve agriculture, its uneven adoption and certain technological choices have contributed to the crisis.

  • Slow Adoption of Modern Technology: The adoption of modern farming techniques, such as precision agriculture and biotechnology, has been slow, particularly among small and marginal farmers.
  • Over-reliance on Chemical Inputs: The Green Revolution promoted the intensive use of chemical fertilizers and pesticides, leading to soil degradation, water pollution, and health hazards.
  • Inadequate Irrigation Infrastructure: Despite significant investments in irrigation, a large proportion of agricultural land remains rain-fed, making it vulnerable to droughts and erratic rainfall.

Environmental Causes

Climate change and environmental degradation are increasingly impacting agricultural productivity and farmer livelihoods.

  • Climate Change: Erratic rainfall patterns, increased frequency of droughts and floods, and rising temperatures are negatively affecting crop yields.
  • Soil Degradation: Overuse of chemical fertilizers, deforestation, and unsustainable agricultural practices have led to soil erosion, nutrient depletion, and loss of soil fertility.
  • Water Scarcity: Depletion of groundwater resources and increasing competition for water are posing a serious threat to agricultural production.
  • Deforestation: Loss of forest cover contributes to soil erosion, reduced rainfall, and increased vulnerability to natural disasters.
Cause Category Specific Issue Impact
Economic Small Landholdings Reduced profitability, limited investment
Socio-Political Policy Implementation Ineffective schemes, corruption
Technological Chemical Input Reliance Soil degradation, health hazards
Environmental Climate Change Reduced yields, increased risk

Conclusion

The agrarian crisis in India is a complex and multifaceted problem with deep-rooted economic, socio-political, technological, and environmental causes. Addressing this crisis requires a holistic and integrated approach that focuses on improving access to credit, strengthening market infrastructure, promoting sustainable agricultural practices, investing in irrigation and water management, and empowering farmer organizations. Furthermore, policies must be tailored to regional specificities and prioritize the needs of small and marginal farmers. A long-term vision focused on resilience, sustainability, and farmer welfare is essential to ensure the future of Indian agriculture.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Green Revolution
A period in the mid-20th century when agricultural production increased dramatically, particularly in developing countries, due to new technologies like high-yielding varieties of seeds, fertilizers, and pesticides.
Debt Trap
A situation where a borrower is unable to repay their debt, leading to a cycle of borrowing to cover interest payments and further increasing their indebtedness.

Key Statistics

As of 2023, over 5.78 million farmers are indebted to banks and other financial institutions in India.

Source: National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) - Knowledge cutoff 2023

Approximately 60% of India’s agricultural land is rain-fed, making it highly vulnerable to monsoon failures.

Source: Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare - Knowledge cutoff 2022

Examples

Vidarbha Farmer Suicides

The Vidarbha region of Maharashtra has witnessed a high incidence of farmer suicides due to debt, crop failure, and lack of access to markets. This exemplifies the severe distress faced by farmers in rain-fed areas.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the role of Minimum Support Price (MSP) in addressing the agrarian crisis?

MSP aims to provide a guaranteed price to farmers for their produce, reducing price volatility and ensuring a minimum income. However, its effectiveness is limited by issues like inadequate procurement infrastructure and coverage of all crops.

Topics Covered

Indian EconomyAgricultureAgricultural PolicyRural DevelopmentFarmers' Issues