UPSC MainsAGRICULTURE-PAPER-II201915 Marks
Q24.

What is pesticide resistance ? Differentiate between simple and multiple resistance in insect pests with examples. Prescribe measures to overcome pesticide resistance problems.

How to Approach

This question requires a detailed understanding of pesticide resistance in insect pests. The approach should involve defining pesticide resistance, clearly differentiating between simple and multiple resistance with illustrative examples, and then prescribing comprehensive measures to mitigate the problem. The answer should be structured into introduction, body (defining resistance, differentiating types, and mitigation strategies), and conclusion. Use of tables for comparison will enhance clarity. Focus on providing practical and scientifically sound solutions.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Pesticide resistance, a growing concern in modern agriculture, refers to the decreased susceptibility of a pest population to a pesticide to which it was previously sensitive. This phenomenon arises due to the evolutionary adaptation of pests in response to repeated exposure to the same or similar pesticides. The overuse and misuse of pesticides have accelerated this process, leading to significant economic losses and challenges in crop protection. Globally, it is estimated that pests cause approximately 35% crop loss, and pesticide resistance exacerbates this issue. Understanding the mechanisms and types of resistance, and implementing effective management strategies, are crucial for sustainable agriculture.

What is Pesticide Resistance?

Pesticide resistance is a genetic phenomenon where a pest population evolves to tolerate doses of pesticides that would have previously killed them. This isn’t about individual insects developing immunity; rather, it’s about the survival and reproduction of those individuals within a population that possess genes conferring some level of resistance. Over time, these resistant genes become more prevalent, leading to a population largely unaffected by the pesticide.

Differentiating Between Simple and Multiple Resistance

Insect pests can develop different types of resistance, broadly categorized as simple and multiple resistance. The key difference lies in the number of pesticides to which the pest has become resistant.

Feature Simple Resistance Multiple Resistance
Definition Resistance to a single pesticide. Resistance to two or more pesticides belonging to different chemical classes.
Mechanism Often involves a single gene mutation or metabolic detoxification pathway alteration. Involves multiple genes and complex metabolic changes, often combining different resistance mechanisms.
Development Develops relatively quickly with consistent use of a single pesticide. Develops more slowly, requiring exposure to multiple pesticides over a longer period.
Example Culex quinquefasciatus mosquitoes in Sri Lanka developed resistance to organophosphates due to increased levels of carboxylesterase enzymes. Myzus persicae (peach-potato aphid) in Europe exhibits resistance to organophosphates, pyrethroids, and neonicotinoids due to multiple mechanisms including target site mutations and metabolic detoxification.

Mechanisms of Pesticide Resistance

  • Metabolic Resistance: Increased production of enzymes that detoxify the pesticide.
  • Target Site Resistance: Mutations in the gene encoding the pesticide’s target site, reducing its binding affinity.
  • Reduced Penetration: Changes in the insect’s cuticle reducing pesticide absorption.
  • Behavioral Resistance: Altered behavior to avoid pesticide exposure.
  • Enhanced Excretion: Increased ability to excrete the pesticide.

Measures to Overcome Pesticide Resistance Problems

Addressing pesticide resistance requires a multifaceted approach integrating various strategies:

  • Integrated Pest Management (IPM): Implementing IPM programs that combine biological control, cultural practices, and judicious use of pesticides.
  • Rotation of Pesticides: Alternating pesticides with different modes of action to prevent the selection of resistant genes.
  • Pesticide Mixtures: Using mixtures of pesticides with different modes of action (synergistic mixtures) can delay resistance development. However, this should be done cautiously to avoid exacerbating resistance.
  • Refugia Strategy: Maintaining a portion of the pest population that is not exposed to the pesticide (refugia) to provide susceptible individuals for mating.
  • Monitoring Resistance: Regularly monitoring pest populations for resistance levels to guide pesticide selection and management strategies.
  • Use of Biopesticides: Promoting the use of biopesticides (e.g., Bacillus thuringiensis) and other environmentally friendly pest control methods.
  • Responsible Pesticide Use: Educating farmers on proper pesticide application techniques, dosage, and safety precautions.
  • Gene Technology: Utilizing genetically modified crops expressing Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) toxins, offering a targeted and often more sustainable pest control solution.

Conclusion

Pesticide resistance is a complex evolutionary challenge that demands proactive and integrated management strategies. Relying solely on chemical control is unsustainable and accelerates the development of resistance. A shift towards IPM, coupled with responsible pesticide use, monitoring, and the exploration of alternative pest control methods, is essential for preserving the efficacy of pesticides and ensuring long-term agricultural productivity. Continuous research and development of novel pest control technologies are also crucial in this ongoing battle against evolving pest populations.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Metabolic Detoxification
The process by which organisms break down toxic substances, such as pesticides, into less harmful compounds. This is a major mechanism of pesticide resistance in insects.
Refugia
A portion of a pest population that remains unsprayed or unexposed to a pesticide, serving as a source of susceptible individuals for mating with resistant individuals, thereby slowing down the spread of resistance genes.

Key Statistics

Approximately 700 insect species have developed resistance to at least one insecticide as of 2023.

Source: IRAC (Insecticide Resistance Action Committee)

Global losses due to pesticide resistance are estimated to be in the billions of dollars annually, impacting food security and agricultural economies.

Source: FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations) - Knowledge cutoff 2023

Examples

Diamondback Moth Resistance

<i>Plutella xylostella</i> (diamondback moth), a major pest of cruciferous crops, has developed resistance to a wide range of insecticides globally, including pyrethroids, organophosphates, and spinosad, demonstrating rapid adaptation and widespread resistance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can pesticide resistance be reversed?

While complete reversal is difficult, resistance levels can be reduced by removing the selective pressure (i.e., stopping the use of the pesticide), allowing susceptible individuals to reproduce and increase in the population. However, this requires a long-term commitment and careful monitoring.

Topics Covered

AgricultureEntomologyCrop ProtectionPesticide ResistanceInsect PestsPest Management