UPSC MainsHISTORY-PAPER-I201920 Marks
Q18.

The emergence of early capitalism in the Mughal period was primarily due to urbanisation and commercialisation. Comment.

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of the Mughal economy. The approach should be to first define early capitalism and then demonstrate how urbanization and commercialization fostered its emergence during the Mughal period. Focus on the changes in production, trade, and financial systems. Structure the answer chronologically, highlighting key developments under different rulers. Include specific examples of industries and trading networks. Finally, acknowledge limitations and alternative perspectives.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The Mughal period (1526-1857) witnessed significant economic changes that laid the groundwork for proto-industrialization and the emergence of early capitalist tendencies in India. While not fully developed capitalism as understood in the European context, the Mughal economy exhibited features like increased commodity production, a sophisticated financial system, and a growing merchant class. This transformation was intrinsically linked to the expansion of urban centers and the flourishing of both internal and external trade, leading to a process of commercialization that fundamentally altered traditional economic structures. This answer will explore how urbanization and commercialization acted as primary drivers of these early capitalist developments.

Urbanization as a Catalyst

The Mughal period saw a significant increase in urbanization. Cities like Delhi, Agra, Lahore, and Surat flourished as centers of administration, trade, and craft production. This urban growth created a demand for goods and services, stimulating production and attracting skilled artisans and merchants.

  • Delhi and Agra: These imperial cities were hubs of luxury goods production, catering to the needs of the court and nobility. This fostered specialized crafts like textile weaving, jewelry making, and carpet manufacturing.
  • Coastal Cities (Surat, Masulipatnam, Hooghly): These ports became crucial centers for international trade, connecting India to Southeast Asia, Persia, and Europe. They facilitated the exchange of goods and capital, driving commercial activity.
  • Growth of Qasbas: Smaller urban centers (Qasbas) emerged as local market towns, serving as intermediaries between rural producers and larger urban centers. They provided essential services like credit and storage.

Commercialization of Agriculture and Handicrafts

The Mughal administration actively promoted commercialization through various policies. The land revenue system, while often exploitative, incentivized agricultural production for the market. The growth of handicrafts was also spurred by both domestic and foreign demand.

  • Agricultural Commercialization: The introduction of new crops like tobacco, cotton, and indigo, coupled with improved irrigation techniques, led to a surplus in agricultural production. This surplus was increasingly sold in the market rather than consumed locally.
  • Handicraft Production: Mughal India was renowned for its high-quality handicrafts, particularly textiles. The state encouraged the production of textiles through policies like karwana (loan system) and by providing patronage to skilled artisans.
  • Indigo Cultivation: The demand for indigo in Europe led to its widespread cultivation in regions like Bengal and Gujarat. This resulted in a significant commercial crop and the emergence of indigo planters.

Development of a Financial System

The Mughal period witnessed the development of a sophisticated financial system that facilitated trade and commerce. This included the use of hundi (bills of exchange), banking institutions, and a standardized coinage system.

  • Hundi System: Hundis were widely used as instruments of credit and exchange, allowing merchants to conduct transactions over long distances without the physical transfer of cash.
  • Banking Institutions: Indigenous banking institutions, like sarrafs (money changers) and mahajans (moneylenders), provided credit and facilitated financial transactions.
  • Coinage: The Mughals introduced a standardized coinage system based on silver and copper, which facilitated trade and commerce. Akbar’s coinage reforms were particularly significant.

Rise of Merchant Communities

The commercialization of the economy led to the rise of powerful merchant communities who played a crucial role in facilitating trade and accumulating wealth.

  • Multanis and Banyas: These communities were prominent in long-distance trade, connecting different regions of India and beyond.
  • Foreign Merchants: English, Dutch, French, and Portuguese merchants established trading posts in India, further stimulating commercial activity.

Limitations and Nuances

It’s important to note that the early capitalist developments in the Mughal period were limited by several factors. The dominance of agrarian relations, the lack of a strong private property rights system, and the prevalence of state control over key industries hindered the full development of capitalism. Furthermore, the Mughal economy was largely based on pre-capitalist modes of production, with limited mechanization and wage labor.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the emergence of early capitalist features in the Mughal period was undeniably driven by urbanization and commercialization. The growth of cities, the expansion of trade, the development of a financial system, and the rise of merchant communities all contributed to a more dynamic and market-oriented economy. However, it is crucial to recognize that this was not a full-fledged capitalist system, but rather a transitional phase characterized by proto-industrialization and the emergence of capitalist tendencies within a largely agrarian context. The foundations laid during the Mughal period, however, would prove significant in shaping the subsequent economic developments in India.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Commercialization
The process by which economic activities are increasingly oriented towards the market, with goods and services produced for sale rather than for direct consumption.
Karwana
A system of advances made by merchants or state officials to artisans, ensuring a supply of goods and tying artisans to a particular patron or market.

Key Statistics

India’s share of the world’s GDP declined from approximately 24% in 1700 to 18% in 1750, indicating a relative economic stagnation despite internal growth. (Source: Angus Maddison, *Contours of the World Economy, 1-2030 AD* - Knowledge Cutoff 2021)

Source: Angus Maddison, *Contours of the World Economy, 1-2030 AD*

Surat accounted for approximately 90% of India’s overseas trade during the 17th century, demonstrating its importance as a major commercial center. (Source: Irfan Habib, *An Atlas of Mughal India* - Knowledge Cutoff 2021)

Source: Irfan Habib, *An Atlas of Mughal India*

Examples

Textile Industry in Bengal

Bengal became a major center for textile production during the Mughal period, particularly muslin and silk. The demand from Europe and other parts of Asia led to a significant increase in production and the development of specialized weaving communities.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was the Mughal economy truly capitalist?

While the Mughal economy exhibited several features associated with early capitalism, such as commercialization and the development of financial institutions, it lacked key characteristics like widespread private property rights, industrial mechanization, and a fully developed wage labor system. It was more accurately described as a proto-industrial or transitional economy.

Topics Covered

Medieval HistoryEconomyMughal EmpireUrbanizationTradeCommercialization