Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
The Cripps Mission, dispatched to India in March 1942 amidst the escalating Second World War, aimed to secure Indian cooperation and support for the British war effort. Sir Stafford Cripps, the mission leader, was tasked with negotiating an agreement for India’s self-governance post-war, while retaining British control during the conflict. However, the mission was met with widespread opposition and ultimately failed to achieve its objectives. The statement that the Cripps Mission was “plagued throughout, and ultimately torpedoed” accurately reflects the inherent weaknesses of the proposals and the complex political landscape of India at the time.
Background and Objectives
By 1942, the war situation had deteriorated for Britain, with the fall of Singapore and Burma posing a direct threat to India. British authorities realized the necessity of gaining Indian support – both material and political – for a successful war effort. The Atlantic Charter (August 1941), which affirmed the right of all peoples to choose their own form of government, created pressure on Britain to address Indian demands for self-rule. The Cripps Mission was, therefore, a response to these pressures, offering a framework for constitutional reforms.
The Cripps Proposals
The Cripps proposals were complex and offered a somewhat ambiguous vision of India’s future. Key features included:
- Dominion Status: India was offered Dominion Status after the war, similar to Canada or Australia.
- Constituent Assembly: Provision for an Indian Constituent Assembly after the war, elected by provincial assemblies, to draft a new constitution.
- ‘Opt-Out’ Clause: Provinces were given the option to secede from the Union of India and form separate entities. This was a major point of contention.
- Defence: Defence of India would remain under British control during the war.
- Emergency Powers: The Governor-General would retain significant emergency powers.
Reasons for Failure
Opposition from the Congress
The Indian National Congress, led by Mahatma Gandhi, rejected the Cripps proposals for several reasons:
- Immediate Self-Governance: The Congress demanded immediate transfer of power, not a promise of Dominion Status after the war.
- ‘Opt-Out’ Clause: The ‘opt-out’ clause was seen as a divisive tactic that would fragment India along communal lines.
- Governor-General’s Powers: The extensive powers retained by the Governor-General were unacceptable to the Congress.
- Representation in the Viceroy’s Executive Council: The Congress wanted full Indian representation in the Viceroy’s Executive Council, which was not adequately addressed.
Opposition from the Muslim League
The Muslim League, led by Muhammad Ali Jinnah, also rejected the proposals, but for different reasons:
- Insufficient Protection for Muslims: Jinnah argued that the proposals did not adequately protect the rights of Muslims and did not guarantee separate electorates.
- ‘Opt-Out’ Clause: While the League supported the ‘opt-out’ clause in principle, they felt it didn’t sufficiently safeguard Muslim-majority provinces.
British Strategic Considerations
The British government was unwilling to concede complete control during the war. They feared that a fully independent India might withdraw from the war effort or fall under Japanese influence. Stafford Cripps himself lacked the authority to make significant concessions, and his inflexible approach further exacerbated the situation.
The ‘Torpedoing’ of the Mission
The failure of the Cripps Mission led to increased political tension in India. The Congress launched the ‘Quit India’ Movement in August 1942, further complicating the situation. The British government responded with widespread arrests and repression. The mission’s failure effectively demonstrated the irreconcilable differences between the British government and Indian political leaders, paving the way for eventual independence.
Conclusion
The Cripps Mission, despite its intentions, was fundamentally flawed due to its ambiguous proposals, the conflicting demands of Indian political parties, and the British government’s reluctance to relinquish control during wartime. The ‘opt-out’ clause proved particularly divisive, exacerbating communal tensions and undermining the possibility of a united India. The mission’s failure ultimately accelerated the momentum towards Indian independence, albeit through a more turbulent path marked by the Quit India Movement and subsequent negotiations.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.