Dalvoy Logo
Dalvoy
UPSC MainsHISTORY-PAPER-II201910 Marks150 Words
हिंदी में पढ़ें
Q3.

Two important intellectual criteria which informed the reform movements were rationalism and religious universalism.

How to Approach

This question requires an understanding of the intellectual currents that shaped 19th-century Indian reform movements. The answer should define rationalism and religious universalism, then illustrate how these principles manifested in the work of key reformers and movements. Structure the answer by first defining the concepts, then discussing how rationalism influenced reform (e.g., challenging social evils), and finally, how religious universalism played a role (e.g., promoting interfaith harmony). Specific examples are crucial.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

The 19th century witnessed a surge of reform movements in India, responding to perceived social, religious, and political stagnation. These movements weren’t merely reactive; they were deeply informed by evolving intellectual currents. Two particularly significant criteria shaping these reforms were rationalism – emphasizing reason and evidence over tradition – and religious universalism – the belief in the essential unity of all religions. These principles provided the intellectual framework for challenging existing norms and advocating for a more just and equitable society, laying the groundwork for modern India.

Rationalism and its Impact

Rationalism, stemming from the Enlightenment in Europe, encouraged a critical examination of established beliefs and practices. Indian reformers adopted this approach to dismantle harmful social customs and superstitions.

  • Critique of Idol Worship: Reformers like Ram Mohan Roy, influenced by rationalist thought, vehemently opposed idol worship and polytheism, viewing them as irrational and hindering societal progress. His Brahmo Samaj (1828) advocated for monotheistic worship based on reason.
  • Challenge to Sati: The abolition of Sati (1829) was a direct outcome of rationalist arguments. Raja Ram Mohan Roy’s relentless campaign, backed by evidence of the practice’s cruelty and lack of scriptural sanction, convinced Lord William Bentinck to outlaw it.
  • Advocacy for Widow Remarriage: Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar championed widow remarriage, arguing against the irrationality of denying widows the right to rebuild their lives. His efforts led to the Widow Remarriage Act, 1856.
  • Opposition to Caste System: While complex, rationalist arguments were used to critique the rigid hierarchies and discriminatory practices inherent in the caste system, though complete dismantling proved more challenging.

Religious Universalism and its Manifestations

Religious universalism, the idea that all religions share common underlying principles, fostered a spirit of tolerance and interfaith dialogue. This principle was crucial in countering communal tensions and promoting national unity.

  • The Prarthana Samaj (1867): Founded in Bombay, the Prarthana Samaj emphasized the ethical teachings common to all religions, rejecting ritualistic practices and promoting devotional worship. It drew inspiration from the Brahmo Samaj but focused on Marathi-speaking communities.
  • Ramakrishna Mission (1897): Swami Vivekananda, through the Ramakrishna Mission, propagated the idea of the inherent divinity of all religions. His address at the Parliament of the World’s Religions in Chicago (1893) showcased this universalist perspective, gaining international recognition.
  • Arya Samaj (1875): While emphasizing Vedic principles, Dayananda Saraswati also advocated for a return to the original, pure form of religion, free from later accretions and superstitions, implicitly acknowledging the potential for truth in other faiths.
  • Interfaith Dialogue: Reformers actively engaged in interfaith dialogues, seeking common ground and promoting mutual respect between different religious communities. This was particularly important in a diverse society like India.

Interplay of Rationalism and Religious Universalism

These two intellectual criteria were often intertwined. Reformers used rationalism to critique harmful practices *within* their own religions and religious universalism to build bridges with other faiths. For example, Ram Mohan Roy’s critique of idolatry was rooted in rationalism, but his advocacy for monotheism reflected a belief in the underlying unity of religious experience.

Intellectual Criterion Key Reformers/Movements Impact
Rationalism Ram Mohan Roy, Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar Abolition of Sati, Widow Remarriage, Critique of Idol Worship
Religious Universalism Swami Vivekananda, Prarthana Samaj Interfaith Harmony, National Unity, Promotion of Ethical Values

Conclusion

The intellectual criteria of rationalism and religious universalism were pivotal in shaping the 19th-century Indian reform movements. They provided the ideological tools to challenge social injustices, promote religious tolerance, and lay the foundations for a modern, progressive India. While these movements faced limitations and internal contradictions, their legacy continues to inspire efforts towards social reform and interfaith harmony in contemporary India. The emphasis on reason and inclusivity remains vital for navigating the complexities of a diverse and evolving nation.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Evaluate your handwritten answer in under a minute

Free trial available • Trusted by 1,00,000+ aspirants

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Rationalism
A philosophical approach that emphasizes reason and logic as the primary sources of knowledge and justification, rejecting reliance on tradition, faith, or emotion.
Religious Universalism
The belief that all religions share fundamental truths and that different religious paths ultimately lead to the same ultimate reality.

Key Statistics

The number of Sati cases reported in Bengal Presidency in 1818 was 378 (Source: Historical records of the East India Company).

Source: East India Company Records

Literacy rates in India were estimated to be around 5% in 1857, highlighting the need for educational reforms championed by many of these movements (Source: British India Census Reports).

Source: British India Census Reports (Knowledge Cutoff 2023)

Examples

The Young Bengal Movement

Founded by Henry Derozio in 1828, this movement promoted radical and rationalist ideas among young Bengalis, challenging traditional norms and advocating for social and political reforms.

The Aligarh Movement

Sir Syed Ahmed Khan’s Aligarh Movement (late 19th century) promoted modern education among Muslims, emphasizing rationalism and scientific inquiry while also advocating for social reform within the Muslim community.

Frequently Asked Questions

▶Were these reform movements solely influenced by Western thought?

While Western thought played a role, these movements also drew inspiration from indigenous traditions and a desire to revitalize Indian society based on its own strengths and values. They weren’t simply imitations of Western models.

▶What were the limitations of these reform movements?

Many movements were limited in their reach, primarily impacting the upper and middle classes. They often failed to address the concerns of the lower castes and marginalized communities effectively. Also, some movements were criticized for being overly focused on religious reform and neglecting broader socio-economic issues.

Topics Covered

HistoryIndian HistorySocial HistoryReform MovementsRationalismReligious Universalism19th Century India
Back to all HISTORY-PAPER-II 2019 questions