Model Answer
0 min readIntroduction
Currency convertibility refers to the ease with which a country’s currency can be exchanged for other currencies. It’s a crucial aspect of a country’s integration into the global economy. While a fully convertible currency facilitates international trade and investment, it also exposes the economy to external shocks. As of late 2023, India operates under a managed float exchange rate regime with some capital controls. The question of whether the Indian Rupee is ‘fully convertible’ is complex, requiring an examination of the extent to which restrictions on currency exchange have been lifted, particularly concerning capital account transactions.
Understanding Currency Convertibility
Currency convertibility exists on a spectrum. It’s generally categorized into three stages:
- Stage 1: Current Account Convertibility: This allows exchange of currency for trade in goods and services. India achieved current account convertibility in 1994, as part of the broader economic liberalization reforms initiated in 1991.
- Stage 2: Limited Capital Account Convertibility: This permits limited exchange of currency for certain capital account transactions, such as foreign direct investment (FDI) and portfolio investment within specified limits. India has made significant progress in this stage, but restrictions remain.
- Stage 3: Full Capital Account Convertibility: This allows unrestricted flow of capital in and out of the country, with no limitations on the amount or type of capital transactions. This is the most liberalized form of convertibility.
India’s Current Status: Partially Convertible
Currently, the Indian Rupee is not fully convertible. While significant liberalization has occurred, several restrictions remain on capital account transactions. These include:
- Limits on Foreign Portfolio Investment (FPI): There are limits on the amount of investment foreign entities can make in Indian equity and debt markets.
- Restrictions on Outward Foreign Direct Investment (OFDI): Indian companies face limitations on the amount they can invest abroad.
- Capital Controls on Resident Individuals: There are limits on the amount of money resident Indians can remit abroad under the Liberalised Remittance Scheme (LRS). As of October 2023, the limit is USD 250,000 per financial year.
- Restrictions on External Commercial Borrowings (ECB): Regulations govern the amount and terms of borrowing from foreign sources.
These controls are managed by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), which has the authority to regulate foreign exchange transactions under the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA), 1999.
Arguments For Full Convertibility
- Increased Capital Inflows: Full convertibility could attract larger inflows of foreign capital, boosting economic growth.
- Enhanced Efficiency of Capital Allocation: Unrestricted capital flows would allow capital to move to its most productive uses, improving economic efficiency.
- Reduced Transaction Costs: Eliminating exchange controls would lower the costs of international transactions.
- Greater Integration with Global Financial Markets: Full convertibility would integrate India more fully into the global financial system.
Arguments Against Full Convertibility
- Volatility and Exchange Rate Risk: Unrestricted capital flows can lead to greater volatility in the exchange rate, potentially destabilizing the economy. The Asian Financial Crisis of 1997-98 serves as a cautionary tale.
- Hot Money Flows: Full convertibility could attract speculative ‘hot money’ flows, which can quickly reverse and create financial instability.
- Loss of Monetary Policy Autonomy: Large capital inflows can complicate monetary policy, making it difficult for the RBI to control inflation.
- Potential for Capital Flight: In times of economic or political uncertainty, full convertibility could facilitate large-scale capital flight, exacerbating the crisis.
The Tarapore Committee Reports
Several committees have examined the issue of capital account convertibility in India. The most notable are the Tarapore Committee reports (1997 and 2006). These committees recommended a phased approach to capital account liberalization, contingent on meeting certain macroeconomic conditions, such as a fiscal deficit of less than 3.5% of GDP and inflation below 5%. These conditions have not been consistently met, leading to a cautious approach by the RBI.
| Committee | Year | Key Recommendations |
|---|---|---|
| Tarapore Committee I | 1997 | Phased liberalization of capital account, contingent on macroeconomic stability. |
| Tarapore Committee II | 2006 | Revised macroeconomic conditions for liberalization, emphasizing fiscal consolidation and inflation control. |
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Indian Rupee is currently partially convertible, with significant restrictions remaining on capital account transactions. While full convertibility offers potential benefits in terms of increased capital inflows and economic efficiency, it also poses risks to macroeconomic stability. Given India’s unique economic and political context, a cautious and phased approach to capital account liberalization, guided by macroeconomic fundamentals and prudent regulation, remains the most appropriate strategy. The RBI’s continued vigilance and careful management of capital flows are crucial for mitigating the risks associated with greater financial integration.
Answer Length
This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.