UPSC MainsGENERAL-STUDIES-PAPER-I202010 Marks150 Words
Q3.

Evaluate the policies of Lord Curzon and their long term implications on the national movement. (Answer in 150 words)

How to Approach

This question requires a nuanced understanding of Lord Curzon’s policies and their impact on the burgeoning Indian nationalist movement. The answer should focus on both the administrative and political aspects of his viceroyalty (1899-1905). Key areas to cover include his administrative reforms, educational policies, partition of Bengal, and their subsequent effects on intensifying nationalist sentiment, leading to more assertive forms of protest. Structure the answer chronologically, highlighting the policies and then their long-term consequences.

Model Answer

0 min read

Introduction

Lord Curzon, Viceroy of India from 1899 to 1905, was a staunch believer in the superiority of British rule and implemented policies aimed at strengthening imperial control and efficiency. While he introduced significant administrative and economic reforms, his policies, particularly the Partition of Bengal in 1905, proved deeply divisive and inadvertently fueled the flames of Indian nationalism. His tenure marked a turning point, shifting the national movement from moderate appeals to more radical and assertive forms of resistance. This answer will evaluate Curzon’s key policies and their lasting implications for the Indian national movement.

Administrative and Economic Policies

Curzon’s administration was characterized by a focus on efficiency and centralization. He implemented several key reforms:

  • Police Reforms (1902): Appointed a Police Commission to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the police force.
  • University Act (1902): Revised university structures, increasing government control over universities and reducing the influence of private bodies. This was widely criticized for stifling academic freedom.
  • Ancient Monuments Preservation Act (1904): Established a framework for the preservation of historical monuments and artifacts.
  • Irrigation and Famine Prevention: Invested heavily in irrigation projects, particularly in the Punjab and the United Provinces, aiming to mitigate the impact of famines.
  • Railway Expansion: Continued expansion of the railway network, primarily for strategic and commercial purposes.

While these reforms aimed at improving governance, they were often perceived as instruments of control and further alienated the Indian population.

Educational Policies and their Impact

Curzon’s educational policies were particularly controversial. He believed in a limited role for higher education, fearing it would create a class of discontented intellectuals. The University Act of 1902, as mentioned above, was a prime example of this approach. He also emphasized vocational training over liberal arts, aiming to produce skilled workers rather than political activists. This led to widespread protests from nationalist leaders who saw education as a crucial tool for national awakening.

The Partition of Bengal (1905)

The most significant and consequential policy of Curzon’s viceroyalty was the Partition of Bengal. Officially justified on administrative grounds – to improve governance of the large and unwieldy province – it was widely seen as a deliberate attempt to divide Bengal’s Hindu majority and weaken the growing nationalist movement. The partition created two new provinces: East Bengal and Assam (with a Muslim majority) and Bengal (with a Hindu majority).

This sparked widespread protests and the Swadeshi Movement (1905-1911), which advocated for the boycott of foreign goods and the promotion of Indian-made products. The movement also saw the rise of more assertive nationalist ideologies, including revolutionary terrorism. The partition also led to the formation of new nationalist organizations and the strengthening of existing ones.

Long-Term Implications on the National Movement

  • Rise of Extremist Nationalism: The Partition of Bengal directly contributed to the emergence of extremist nationalist leaders like Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Bipin Chandra Pal, and Lala Lajpat Rai, who advocated for more radical methods of protest.
  • Mass Participation: The Swadeshi Movement witnessed unprecedented mass participation from all sections of society, including students, women, and peasants.
  • Communal Polarization: While intended to divide Hindus and Muslims, the partition also inadvertently exacerbated communal tensions, laying the groundwork for future conflicts.
  • Strengthening of Indian National Congress: The Congress gained momentum and broadened its base, becoming the leading force in the national movement.
  • Demand for Self-Governance: The protests against the partition intensified the demand for self-governance and ultimately contributed to the eventual independence of India.

Conclusion

Lord Curzon’s policies, while intended to strengthen British rule, ironically served to galvanize the Indian national movement. His administrative reforms, though aimed at efficiency, were perceived as instruments of control. The Partition of Bengal, in particular, proved to be a catalyst for the rise of extremist nationalism, mass participation, and a heightened demand for self-governance. Curzon’s legacy, therefore, is one of unintended consequences, where attempts to consolidate imperial power ultimately accelerated the process of India’s journey towards independence.

Answer Length

This is a comprehensive model answer for learning purposes and may exceed the word limit. In the exam, always adhere to the prescribed word count.

Additional Resources

Key Definitions

Swadeshi Movement
A movement initiated in response to the Partition of Bengal, advocating for the use of Indian-made goods and the boycott of foreign goods as a form of protest against British rule.
Imperial Preference
A system of tariffs and trade agreements favoring goods from within the British Empire, which Curzon actively promoted to strengthen economic ties between Britain and its colonies.

Key Statistics

The value of Indian-made goods increased by 25% during the peak of the Swadeshi Movement (1905-1908), demonstrating the economic impact of the boycott of foreign goods.

Source: National Archives of India (Knowledge Cutoff: 2023)

Between 1899 and 1905, railway mileage in India increased by approximately 28%, largely due to Curzon’s focus on infrastructure development.

Source: Indian Railway History (Knowledge Cutoff: 2023)

Examples

The Partition of Bengal and Muslim League

The Partition of Bengal indirectly contributed to the strengthening of the Muslim League, founded in 1906, as it was seen by some Muslim leaders as a positive step towards securing their political interests.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was Curzon entirely to blame for the rise of extremism in India?

While Curzon’s policies were a significant catalyst, the rise of extremism was also influenced by other factors, such as economic hardship, famine, and the growing awareness of Western political thought among educated Indians.

Topics Covered

HistoryPolityIndian NationalismBritish RuleColonial History